Jump to content




  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Pandemonium

  1. I think the tv series will be just fine if it doesn't start with Dragonmount. there are other ways to convey this message later
  2. wot is all about balance. nothing goes unopposed. to accept that balefire, the chaos force, is unopposed would mean there is no higher unifying force. that would be counter to the patter, the creator, the yin yang and everything wot stands for. I thing RJ planned this early on and it is nice to finally know the meaning of the flame of the aes sedai.
  3. One group that needs to get either expanded or dropped is the Seafolk. Other boat captains can take their place. also, the kin could easily be the ones that studied the bowl of the winds. although the bowl of the winds could also be dropped. The whole role of of the coramoor was never fleshed out entirely and the sea folk pretty much disappeared in the last few books. although I do remember that Aviendha had a vision of the sea folk turned land folk, simply known as the folk.
  4. she is an actress so maybe she has more range that she can show here. not too worried about green screen experience. height can visually altered based on filming techniques. I already know that not everything is going to match the book description. that is ok, that is why it is an adaptation. just wait until some of your minor characters are removed entirely. there are going to many things we disagree with, but none of that is in our control. I'm going reserve all judgement until the airing. hopefully I like it, but if not I'll just keep rereading the books to keep alive m
  5. pike sounds great to me. this series has come a long way since the eotw prologue debacle. I bet pike will pull off the sexy and sophisticated moraine needed for television. especially if they die her hair black
  6. i i was disappointed with some aspects of GoT but I was very happy they were allowed to be offensive and display controversial behavior. WoT is no where near as edgy as game of thrones, but it certainly has elements of abuse, rape, chauvinism, etc. I rather them keep it real than appease to a bunch of people that complain on twitter. I don't want them to take out shadar haran beating graendal and mesaana just because it might offend some. likewise matt's womanizing should not he sugar coated, nor should graendal's and rhavin's mind rapes.
  7. skin color is irrelevant in wot and I could care less how they cast it. If they go by the books there will be many races and cultures and main characters like Tuon will be black. All that is great, no problem. Just hope they keep the modern political narratives out of this. I want it to be more like game of thrones where they can do surprising things without offending someone. If they have to be politically correct then it will ruin the tv show. One of the key traits of the wheel of time was all the different perspectives and all the communication barriers that would crop up betwee
  8. yep, basically they need to avoid any of the mistakes that the last jedi made. forced political statements take away from the story. I loved that they are using a more diverse cast, but that movie wasn't a great one for a number of reasons. The director is the one that screwed it up. wot already has great diversity and racism doesn't seem like a big issue in this world so hopefully they don't try to.shoehorn in modern politics. there sre definitely groups of people that don't like each other though
  9. if they turn this into the sjw wot i will tune it out so quickly..... that said, feminism is a strong element of wot. as long as they can make it self reflective and keep the humor in tact then it should fare well. also wot is all about balance so hopefully they don't underestimate the male element, especially rand/perrin/matt. hopefully they equally display the flaws of both the males and females as well. some of the aes sedai can be quite tyrannical and i hope they don't display the white tower as a feminine utopia.
  10. whomever plays loial should get the main narration duties, aka the wheel weaves intro, etc
  11. 7 or 8 episodes per season wont cut it, only the last 2 got seasons bad that few episodes. wot is considerably denser than got. as for nudity, i think will definitely appear. there are some very adult themes and actions happening in between the lines of text. RJ was a master of subtlety and an expert at crafting the imagination. however, tv typically leaves very little to the imagination these days. sure, not all scenes need to display nudity, but many do. nudee scenarios include the shienar bathhouses, the aiel saunas, birgitte appearing nude from tel'aran'rhiod
  12. i think galad could be cut out of the series. he barely played a role in anything significant. they might want to get a good looking face, but i felt his duel with demandred kind of ruined the ending a bit. there was no need for 3 sword fights. also the children of the light didnt play a huge role in the overall story and probably wouldnt be missed if cut.
  13. yes they are going to have to cut characters. I don't think it makes sense to cut Rands first meeting with Elayne. that was a pivotal scene. that said, I don't think Galad is a necessary character. in fact, the whole children of the light are not really necessary to the wheel of time narrative. Pedro niall and semen valda really don't add much. even gawyn isn't a necessary character. I felt that the 3 sword fights with Demandred kind of detracted from Lans fight final fight. even padan fain might not be necessary, he wasn't that essential and his final battle with Matt was an enormous
  14. These shows were enormously popular back then and remain so now: Fox commissioned six new episodes of The X-Files and it was the most successful new TV drama on their network last year (although only one episode was arguably really good, the rest were meh). More will follow. Showtime has spent an absolutely insane amount of money on the new Twin Peaks, to the tune of many tens of millions of dollars and convincing David Lynch (who hasn't directed a live-action project in a decade) to direct the entire thing, and are already ramping up marketing four months out. It may turn out to be rubbish, b
  15. I like the way you lay it out here. However, Moiraine and Nynaeve would never have said that Moridin could not be dangerous or did not intend any harm. If Nynaeve delved Moridin, she could probably see his health was rapidly returning. For this reason, I never liked the Moridin walks off into the sunset ending that this book had. I think a little more explanation was needed.
  16. I personally think Sanderson could have written this section a bit better. Even a sentence or 2 of clarification would have made all the difference. For example, Alivia's part was way too down-played at the end. I think if we had a had a small Alivia POV explaining what was going on it would have added wonderfully to the ending. Especially since Aliva was the one prophesized to help Rand die. Since Alvia was one of the 4 people to know what was really going, her POV would have been very appropriate. I guess I never liked the ending very much because it never made sense why Moridin wa
  17. One thing about the ending that I never understood was why Moridin's body was not put under guard. Nynaeve and Moiraine didn't know that Moridin was really Rand did they? They saw Rand battling Moridin in Shayol Ghul. I mean it would be kind of odd to just let a random body that walked out of Shayol Ghul go free. Anyway, I didn't understand that part of the book. Other intreprations are welcome.
  18. I will never buy this non-canon fan-fiction, but how exactly did Demandred kill the Jumara and how did he kill the Nym? This whole Shara back-story Brandon has written just seems pretty goofy. I would really love to know why a whole country would be so afraid of the Dragon that would embrace the shadow. I would also love to know how the prophecies became so mis-interpreted and/or corrupted.
  19. Did anyone else find the sword duels highly unrealistic? How does Gawyn, with the 3 bloodknife rings, and superspeed abilities not even get a scratch off on Demandred? Yet both Galad and an exhausted Lan were able to take Demandred to the limit. This just doesn't make much sense to me. Especially after we saw how good Gawyn was without the bloodknife ter'angreal. I can understand that demandred was done in by his ego to be the best. Any smart general would have just immediately had Gawyn, Galad, or Lan killed. Yet Demandred had to prove he could best any man in single combat.
  20. Great review KCF. This was my favorite review so far, and I think you definitely put the criticisms of AMOL in the proper context. Can't wait to get this tomorrow
  21. Did you really need to make a separate thread for this meandering diatribe? Wasn't the criticism thread a better place for this?
  22. Jain was probably at least 80 years old so it isn't far-fetched even if Androl is 60+
  23. I think Herid hit the nail on its head already. Nobody else in this thread will be able to come up with an explanation that is even remotely close. Nice idea, and it also explains Androl's mysterious past.
  24. So how about them Mets? I sure can't wait to read that 70K chapter in AMOL with upwards of 80 POVs
  • Create New...