Jump to content




  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by grump

  1. Hey guys I don't take anything personally, I was just happy to have about a 40% more or less confirmation that I was thinking along more or less correct lines. So if it makes anyone happy to cheer my 60% wrong rate I am good with that. Thanks the grump
  2. Questions: How are they getting through Rands defenses to send him dreams? Alanna I think. In spite of everything he still has a soft spot for women and for Lanfear Are the seanchan committed to fighting in rands current army of light. Will Lan get toasted at the gap. If it happens, how and by who will Camylyn be saved? Who else will be in the circle with Rand Will it be another of his sweeties or the girl that will help him die. What part will Fain play in the last battle? Rand has 2 black wounds in his side, fuzzy sight, and a lost hand, Isn'r he supposed to be more banged up than that? Is it possible or necessary for Suian or Settele to be restored to full power. Do the wise ones know what Avendia does about the aiel future. These questions don't seem quite on the same level as the ones answered but should give us something to chew on till the last book comes. Thanks the grump
  3. 1. The true Power works in Far Madding I e The tall scarred blond Rand met there was Moridin in discuise. 2.The Finns were responsibile for Lanfears loss of power. 3. Who mesaana turned out to be 4. All of morgauses kids know she is alive. 5. Perrins group has discovered circles and power wrought weapons as well as a leader. 6. Noal was Jain Farstrider confirmed 7. It looks like red and black will meld at the black tower. 8.While we know Grendal did not personally destroy (kill?)two of the chosen, she is being held responsibile by The DO for three. 9. All of the armies of light except Lans will soon be gathered in one place. 10. Moraine got rescued 11. In the wolf dream Perrin can ignore balefire and other weaves. Only a couple of questions bother me now, where is Logain, and the damane that will help him die, and what did Loial say at the Great Stump I liked this book Thanks the grump
  4. yoniy0 Sorry, I would have said so sooner, but had trouble getting on. I had just popped over from a spoiler board. Thanks the grump
  5. [Removed Spoilers] Thanks the grump Mod Note: Alluding to spoilers is just as bad as the spoiler it's self.
  6. Hey you may be right, I just saw on another thread that he killed asmo. I am highly disappointed as I had slayer pegged for that. O well I will hold on to my dreams for a while anyway. Until some one shows me a stronger case against someone else. Thanks the grump
  7. I didn't expect much in the way of agreement, but just like I think Nesune is Meassana,now that I have said it and why I think so, I will wait and see how close or far away I am. Oh yeah, I think Slayer Killed Asmo, Cyndane traded power for freedom and then was doublecrossed and killed by the finns before being brought back by the DO. That Noal lost his memory and gained his broken bones in another deal crafted by the Finns Even if none of the above turns out to be right I had lots of fun turning it up and possibly even a blind grump may find an acorn of truth somewhere in the Wheel of Time Thanks grump
  8. I think it is WEIRAMON. NO I AM NOT JOKING! He is constantly an idiot but can you think of a better disguise. he is in a position of power, but no one will let him use it because he is such a loose cannon. Remember that he and Dashiva are tasked with keeping an eye on Rand. Remember how many times he is sent away then returns without permission. He is always pristine when everybody else is covered with mud and blood. POD He reacts out of charactor only one time that I can find. Path of Daggers Pages 537-539 speaking to Gedwyn showing that he is not only not an idiot but a darkfriend of considerable authority. His last words are "Kill who ever you wish, where ever you wish" Gedwyn is one of the five who try to kill Rand later. another of the five in Far Madding remembers that both Taim and Demandred had ok ed the attack. He is First to call Rand "Lord of the Morning" an otherwise forgotten title for the Dragon. Last and certainly least. I TGS RJ and BS make a special point in that one of rands personalities says "at least he isn't pretending to be anybody else" to the other. Thanks the grump
  9. Hey guys (and ladies) everybody goes round and round about this subject. Maybe a reboot would help. so: WHAT CHARACTER (MALE)DO YOU THINK IS LEAST LIKELY TO BE DEMANDRED. The grump
  10. Min got all 5 a pass, including black elza at the swearing, by telling rand they would all serve in their own fashion. and this sister was the only one sharp enough to detect eguene hidden in the corner The POV proves she is as passionate a researcher as Grendal says she was weaves can be inverted and tied off, so what does appearance have to do with anything. All of the Chosen can disguise and control their power levels cant they? keep pecking the grump
  11. Okay One theory coming up Mesaana is a teacher and researcher. in the Prologue of TGS Grendal says that freedom of research may have been a factor inj her pledging to the DO. that would make her a brown, The sister I'm thinking of was publicly ordered to be in the 6 person official envoy to Rand by her Ajah head. (although she states she would have been happy to come anyway))In her POV she laments that with all the time that has passed, she still has been able to catalog 50 new plants and animals. She also mentions that however things turn out she plans to write a paper on rand, Eguene tells the wise ones that this sister has a habit of speaking her thoughts out loud, and they are told she has been muttering about seals in the library. After the battle of the Wells she is the only sister who pays any attention to what is going on. from this point on she is constantly shielded and guarded 24 hours a day. Perhaps this is why she missed her meeting with the chosen. She is among the first 5 to swear to Rand, her reason being she cant study him from where she is now Min says all of them will serve him in their own fashion and get them by. Soralei feels they would benifit from a trip, and asks Caudsuane to take them with her to Far Madding. as this sister comes through the gate she is wearing a bronze dress. She reacts most sharply when Rand tells cuadsuane he is going to cleanse the mens power. She is in one of the defence circles but not controling the flow when he does it her circle is one with causultys. at this point you wonder if she was punished for not coming or not helping the bad guys enough. In TGS she first makes an appearance when Simi escapes as a corpse,but hurrah a few minutes later she is weak but alive. Why is that I wonder? none of the 3 should have been left alive. You can't find her in the tower, because she is one of those who have been gone for a while and can't be checked on until they get back. you can find her name by looking at any of the places discribed peck away the grump
  12. Jake From the beginning YOU are the one who has introduced and re introduced this mythical website. Not me, What's your problem bud ? I got chewed out and have moved on. Don't you have any ideas about mesaana to present? i would like to look them over. the grump
  13. Blade It almost sounds as though you might have read that free article on the not to be named website. In it I explain that the research I did on Verin was very helpful when she was eliminated as Mesaana. The misdirection is she is not anywhere where that people are currently looking for her. Then if you list all the reasons why she might not have showed up and pick the right one, there are about 8 clues scattered in books 6-10 that show this same sister acting like Mesaana. Even in the article i didn't use her name, because everyone will have to track her for themselves until they are as convinced as I am. Yep I wouldn't mind making a buck or two, but the WOT stuff is just a very small part of that effort. I may be wrong, but if I'm not it's nice to know I got there first. the grump
  14. Mamagement: I'm sorry, but if you will look, nowhere in my last 3 messages did I ever bring up the website in question. Please talk to jake about that, he was responsibile for both labeling and making the judgement to reveal it. I WAS at fault for confirming it however. I'm sorry . As pennance I will reveal the clue that put me on the road to finding Mesaana. I figured out why she didn't come, and that narrowed the search enough to pick up the other clues that were left. I will be more careful in future. thanks grump
  15. Thanks Jake, I didn't feel comfortable about telling everyone where to go. and to find something I wrote 6 months ago, before the site was even fully up too. I don't suppose you looked at it long enough to see what is there and read the free samples or check what else was being sold or the prices involved. Yep you are right ! My WOT stuff is currently at [YARDSALE SITE REMOVED] Thanks again Jake the grump
  16. Hey Jake You see a website identified anywhere in my message? Should you manage to figure out where to go, you would have noted that there are some WOT articles accessable to any one at no charge. In fact one contains a hint to how I found Mesaana. Anyhow I will repeat again, there is some great misdirection at work about those 2 The grump
  17. I've been gone for a while. I think RJ, Brandon and Harriet have pulled 2 of the greatest feats of misdirection in the world. They have everyone looking everywhere but where Mesaana and Demandred really are. Mesaana gets pretty regular mention from book six on. Book ten contains the one big hint everyone keeps talking about. figure that out and use it as a starting point and she is pretty easy to track. There are even a couple of sideways hints in TGS. Demandred was a lot tougher, I have only found 4 places in the entire series where he has broken cover. one of them was in TGS and is pretty blatant. I've published my thoughts on these 2 and other characters elsewere , but maybe this article will help you out a little in your search the grump
  18. I haven't had time to keep up with all the latest theories about some of the major mysteries that RJ left. But from what I've seen quoted from him , he felt he had left enough clues to solve most of them. didn't he say something to the effect, the answers are simple, just ask different questions? But on to my purpose in writing just now. I ran across a site with some far out but semi reasonable thoughts in some of those things. I pass it to you to look at or ignore. [YARDSALE SITE REMOVED]. Until next time
  19. Maybe he's Demandred. Is he free at all the right times? HAH!!
  20. remember RJ only left clues and round the corner pointers. We wouldn't be having this conversation if he was willing to address the central question. He simply describes the same closed room mystery with different players at least 2 other times. Still only one persons opinion !
  21. Rj said there were enough clues in the first 5 books to solve his death. Grendal is mentioned once in the 5th book, whereas Slayer makes 8-10 appearances in the first 5 books. With his described powers he has no trouble getting into or out of a locked room. Isem looks enough like Lan (who Asmo knows is supposed to be far away) to provoke a "YOU". Grendal could state he was dead if Slayer had killed on her orders, as he is known to do errands for any of the chosen who call upon him. In fact any of the Chosen suspects including Lanfear could have put his death in motion, and used Slayer as the tool. Since he is not listed in the poll by name, he is in the All others category and thus fits RJ's very few correct answers statement. Just one persons opinion !
  22. Moraine knew what was going to happen, she stated she would be thought dead but was not. Since she did not die, the effect on lan have to be placed somewhere else. I believe she arranged all that happened, including severing the bond. It was probably uncomfortable for her but she knew it needed to be done and did it. The 2 letters prove she already had a plan in place. Thom's letter proves she saw into what happens in the world of Finns at least 3 different ways or outcomes. Give her a break, she was the only one who actually knew what was going on that day.
  23. Moraine knew what was going to happen, she states everyone will think she is dead. It seems to me she had plenty of time to make any arrangements she needed to both mask the bond and transfer it. Also what ever happened to Lanfear happened while she was with the finns, and yet, you keep denying them any responsibility for any of the changes. She herself says Aliva is as strong as she was BEFORE being held captive by the finns. So the finns were there when all these changes were going on, but sat and watched while unknown powers tinkered around in their territory. I don't think so! I hope we won't all be disappointed if we ever find out what really happened in some of these small but interesting happenings
  24. Luckers You Keep stating that this, that , or the other are proven facts The aren't They are opinions only. Let me list a few. 1. Lanfear was stilled going through the door. 2. Lanfear was killed going through the door 3. They arrived in a flash of light. (we only know that there were fireworks on the Rands side) 4. The finns shunned or even killed her for coming because they dont allow evil there. (I might mention here that no one denys Slayer is evil, but he pops in and out of their territory when ever he wants to.) In sumation Lanfear was stilled, killed,escaped,(or thrown out)Resurected in a new body , healed and put back in harness,weakened by take your pick, Death stilling,the DO, the finns or someone or thing totally new and unwritten about. It seems to me that as in the case of Asmo, RJ left clues as to what happened but we just aren't picking up on them. Oh by the way! thanks for clueing me in on the wishes thing. I did not know that before I still tend to think the simplist explanation is the best as yet.
  • Create New...