Jump to content

DRAGONMOUNT

A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY

Werthead

Contributor
  • Posts

    1763
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Werthead

  1. The world moves on, and 5-6 years later nobody cares about these 'groundbreaking' tv series. The books, on the other hand, stay with the audience with much longer (2-3 decades at least.)

     

     

     
    People are still excited about the new X-Files and Twin Peaks seasons and have picked up the old series to rewatch or watch for the first time. ST:TNG, a show which is 30 years old this year, still gets tons of viewers on repeats and Netflix (actually, so does the original and that's 51 years old). Far more people have watched The Wire in the 10 years since it finished than when it was on. So a really good, classic show will have quite a long lifespan.
     
    TV shows that are failures won't be remembered for as long, of course. They're already talking about a new Dresden Files show ten years after the last one was a failure.
  2.  

    Interesting thought: we know now that Taim was originally meant to be Demandred and RJ changed his mind abruptly later on.

     

    For the TV show, would people prefer:

     

    1) Keeping Taim as Demandred and going with the LoC/ACoS depiction of Taim throughout, expose Taim as Demandred dramatically later on and just drop the whole Shara thing.

    2) Go with the idea of Taim being a separate character and drop all the oddball references in LoC/ACoS that hinted he was a Forsaken.

    3) Adapt the books as they are and just let the TV viewers get confused about it so book readers can explain it to them and feel superior later on.

     

    There's probably quite a few issues that require judgement calls like this to be made.

     

     

     

    They will probably eliminate or minimize much of the Eye of the World storyline since its so close to Lord of the Rings.

     

    I think that's quite difficult because EotW is the entry point to the series and it worked in hooking people in (to the tune of almost 100 million book sales), so messing around with that approach may be inadvisable.

     

    I think there are some ways of dealing with it. One thought is to show the Trolloc attack on Emond's Field (at least in flashback) and have the Myrddraal unmasked and Lan fights and drives him off. That unmasking of the Myrddraal I think ups the WTFness early on and also quickly negate their Nazgul-ness.

     

    Another idea I had a while ago was not to take Tam and Rand back to their farm, keep them in Emond's Field to witness the Trolloc attack, and then have them cut off  in an alley or something and attacked by Narg (of course played by Academy Award Winner Daniel Day Lewis in a cameo), where Tam is injured. This has various benefits - like seeing the attack in-progress - and could save money by not having to build Rand and Tam's farmhouse only to burn it down five minutes later. The only major problem is why Tam would take his heron-marked sword with him (but you could add a line that Rand's been seeing the Myrddraal for a couple of days and Tam took it with them to town as a precaution).

     

    OTOH, the way RJ does it in the books is more suspenseful and there's probably going to need to be a standing farmhouse set (to be redressed as required) to stand in for the several that Mat and Rand visit later on, so it wouldn't make much odds.

  3. Interesting thought: we know now that Taim was originally meant to be Demandred and RJ changed his mind abruptly later on.

     

    For the TV show, would people prefer:

     

    1) Keeping Taim as Demandred and going with the LoC/ACoS depiction of Taim throughout, expose Taim as Demandred dramatically later on and just drop the whole Shara thing.

    2) Go with the idea of Taim being a separate character and drop all the oddball references in LoC/ACoS that hinted he was a Forsaken.

    3) Adapt the books as they are and just let the TV viewers get confused about it so book readers can explain it to them and feel superior later on.

     

    There's probably quite a few issues that require judgement calls like this to be made.

  4. 1. Harriet's role in WOT was simple: according to RJ she was a beta reader (NOT an editor) Does she hold the rights ot the estate I don't know, but:

     

    Harriet was working for Tom Doherty as an editor until she decided to go back to Charleston. When he founded Tor Books, he got her to agree to continue working for him as a freelancer. In that capacity she edited quite a few early Tor books, most famously Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card and the first few Black Company books by Glen Cook. After Robert Jordan (whom Harriet married in 1981) started working on Wheel of Time she gradually moved from editing other work to working on WoT exclusively from the early 1990s onwards.

     

    But Harriet absolutely worked on every single WoT book as a professional editor. She also did beta readings of the material in progress and came up with about half of the chapter titles in the series, as well as coming up with ideas for the chapter icons. She also did some work on the appendix for each book, and coallating some of RJ's notes.

     

    As Robert Jordan's widow and his partner in the Bandersnatch Group, Harriet also pretty much is the Jordan Estate.

     

    Someone buys it, you publish the deal. All these 'we develop the series/films on the quiet' is baloney.

     

    Not entirely. Companies buy the rights and then keep quiet about it all the time. The GoT deal was done-in-principle in January 2006, so it was a year before it was formally announced. If there are multiple parties involved and one party decides to suddenly hold things up, the other parties cannot proceed without them. I wouldn't be surprised if there was lingering legal issues from the Red Eagle fiasco.

  5. CW could do a fun, lightweight version of WoT: The 100 is a decent show that doesn't hold back on ruthlessness, character deaths or difficult storylines. But it is very much an exception and you'd lose the opportunity to do a decent version of WoT elsewhere.

     

    Based on the negotiations that were underway with Sony, my guess would be that Sony has bought the rights and would be discussing the project with AMC (their partner on Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul). Amazon I think would be very interested as they likely want a tentpole fantasy series. Amazon have also had a massive upheaval in the way their shows are bought and operate recently, which has put a lot of projects on hold, which would also go some way to explaining the long delay since there was any news.

  6. I have to wonder if Red Eagle Entertainment is still involved somehow because this seems like an oddly long wait after Team Jordans announcement.

     

    I strongly suspect that an agreement was reached where Red Eagle could possibly remain "producers in name only" (with a small slice of any profits made) but with no active involvement in the project, done just to get them to drop the legal action and holding everything up for years. That's pretty common in Hollywood.

  7. Well, it's only been 6 months. Although we are all very excited about this and want more news there probably isn't much for them to say at this point. Some info on showrunner and writers would be nice and an indication of which direction they are going, as would info on which tv company is involved. It's possible some or all of these are yet to be decided and/or they are waiting for more to be done before making an announcement. That said, some life signs would be great to know the project hasn't just died...

     

    Sure, but there's no reason the company involved couldn't identify itself, unless there was a corporate need not to. They might also be trying to identify a time they can make the announcement for maximum impact.

     

    Maybe they got a better offer, and right now they are trying to free themselves from the former contract.

     

    Allegedly the rights sale was worth north of $10 million. I consider it unlikely that another production company would sweep in and try to outbid them after the fact, and there'd be contractual clauses preventing that.

  8. They have to follow this route, because the books are written this way

     

    They won't be adapting the books plot beat for plot beat though. If they did, we'd need 20+ seasons (of 20 episodes per season) and each episode would cost $20 million and there'd be over 2,000 speaking roles. Even a 2-books-per-season, 16-episodes-per-season TV show is going to have to dramatically cut things, probably starting around the midpoint of the series and going onwards. I can see there being maybe 5-6 Aes Sedai named characters of note in Egwene's camp rather than 20+, maybe only half a dozen named Asha'man ever showing up rather than dozens, one or two major nobles per faction versus dozens in the books and so on.

     

    It would be really good getting some recent informations about the series. 6 months later, and  we don't know anything about it.

     

    It is curious. My guess is that there was some kind of last-minute legal hitch. As far as I know the deal was done, but the company involved has chosen not to announce it yet. There may be issues getting writes/directors/produces of the calibre they need. I also get the impression they haven't gotten an excited, involved showrunner on board and they really need that to move forwards.

  9. I still wonder if they might make it a story about Egwene and Rand. Their storylines tend to mirror one another.

     

    Thematically, this reinforces the principle male/female dynamic of the books. The first book sets us up to think that the main characters are Rand/Mat/Perrin and Egwene/Nynaeve are support, but when you step back and look at the whole story then it is really Rand and Egwene's stories, with Mat, Perrin, Nynaeve and Elayne as the secondary main characters. RJ plays a bit of bait-and-switch with the reader there. Whether that's because he didn't envisage Egwene being so crucial at the start or he deliberately planned to switch things around, but I think taking the approach of Rand and Egwene being the main POV characters from the start is valid.

     

    You would have to consider some restructuring though. There's long periods in the second half of the series where Rand is doing absolutely nothing of interest (Far Madding was, rather blatantly, late-developed filler material just to give Rand something to do) and there's quite a few periods in the first half where Egwene is off-page doing training montages with the Aes Sedai, Moiraine and the Aiel Wise Ones. You'd have to equalise things a bit.

  10. Chinese production company DMG has picked up the rights to all of Brandon Sanderson's Cosmere universe books - past and present - for colossal sums of money.

     

    The company has earmarked $270 million as 50% of the production budget for three films. They will be looking for international partners to pick up the rest of the budget, which given who they've worked with in the past (they've co-produced everything from Iron Man 3 to Looper) probably won't be hard.

     

    The first two movies will be The Way of Kings and Mistborn: The Final Empire. Exactly how they're going to boil those books (especially Way of Kings) down into a single movie remains to be seen. They've already appointed writer-producers to Way of Kings and are prioritising the project on a fast-track to the screen.

  11. You're also talking about a studio/director that turned the Hobbit into 3 movies.

     

    In Jackson's defence, it does appear that he was forced to do this at gunpoint by the studio, who wanted to make as much money as possible. Apparently, after Del Toro walked rather than comply, Jackson suggested he could do the same and the studio said that was fine as they had a bunch of other directors lined up. Zach Snyder's name was thrown around (possibly a little implausibly, as he was already attached to the WB DC movies). Jackson decided to do the project rather than risk something else screwing it up.

     

    That doesn't excuse a lot of the BS he pulled with CG Super Legolas and the pointless long battle with Smaug at the end of the second movie, but I do have some sympathy for the problems he was under.

  12. To be fair, they could probably make the first 5 books last 1 season each.

     

    Later books, like 6,7,8/ 9,10,11/ 12,13,14 could all be one season each.

     

     

    That's still 12 seasons, which will not happen.

     

    Bad at Math?

    That's 8 Seasons.

    6-8 = 1 season

    9-11 = 1 Season

    12-14 = 1 Season

    3 Seasons

    + first 5

    = 8 Seasons, not 12.

     

    The way you wrote it looked like Books 1-5 = 5 seasons, then a season each for 6, 7, 8/9, 10, 11/12, 13, 14. Your formatting didn't translate well (although I should have realised something was up, as Book 10 certainly would never make for a season by itself!).

     

    People get this idea stuck in their heads that some books have to be multiple seasons, or require 1 season per book.

     

    The books represent useful story beat points, which work for television as they do for prose. It starts breaking down around Book 6, and then collapses altogether around Book 8 (at which point even RJ struggled to make each book work as a cohesive entity in its own right, and then gave up), but certainly for the earlier books maintaining a season/book relationship is useful. Later on you can go to town on mixing things up.

     

    I've proposed either a simple 2:1 ration (seven seasons, 2 books per season) or an even more ambitious 6 season structure which is 1/2, 3/4, 5/6, 7/8/9, 10/11/12 and 13/14. Both require 16-episode seasons to be even remotely viable though. Any less than that and it's time to pull out the scissors and start cutting even more radically than will be required for this structure.

     

    All the battle descriptions. All the dress, and hair pulling can all be described on screen in seconds over hours.

     

    People said this for Lord of the Rings and they said it for ASoIaF and it never, ever works out like this. The time you save in description you lost again in characterisation (externalising their internal development), exposition and action. Lord of the Rings is far more description-heavy than WoT and it still took an absolute immense amount of time, even when Tolkien spent 3 pages on a description of the Misty Mountains that Jackson solved with an 8-second camera pan.

     

    We aren't even getting into the idea, that they could craft the seasons to not follow the books on a 1:1 basis, but actually follow the timeline which gets shifted a bit in the later books...

     

    That will certainly be necessary for at least 12 and 13, otherwise the story will stop making sense.

  13. That would be ridiculous, though. The Shannara Chronicles had a budget of 40 million for its first season (and it still looked terrible). The first season of Game of Thrones got a 60 million dollar budget and that was before anyone knew if a show like that was even viable. After Game of Thrones companies should be willing to invest a good deal more than that since the risk has to be considered significantly lower. If they aren't they shouldn't even bother, frankly, since there is virtually no chance of it succeeding.

     

    $25 million is really not possible. That'd put the show below the budget of most American police procedurals and three-set sitcoms.

     

    Shannara being reasonably successful is useful, because it and Game of Thrones combined show there's legs in a fantasy show. Even more borderline fantasy stuff like The Magicians, historical shows like Outlander, Vikings and The Last Kingdom and even The 100 and Westworld - which may be both SF but with a gritty, period aesthetic - all helps because it shows there's an appetite for more genre stuff in that vein.

     

    Plus Wheel of Time's book sales are absolutely titanic, far higher and with far more readers than ASoIaF had before GoT started. That provides a built-in audience.

     

    On that basis I think it's quite reasonable to expect Wheel of Time to get made (and I'm assured that a deal has been done or just about been done and they're waiting until they've made more progress in securing more talent before making an announcement) and for a major party to be involved. I'm holding out hope it's Netflix or Amazon, as they have both the money and the flexible filming schedules and air times to make it happen the way it needs.

  14. It's also important to note that nowhere in the books is it directly or clearly acknowledged that Randland is our world in a vastly distant future.  That little tidbit comes only from "word of god" answer to a question that has no relevance or importance to the story whatsoever.  We don't even know how far into the future the Age of Legends is from now, whether there was any apocalyptic event that separates their Age from ours, whether there was an Age between our Age and the AOL, or whether their geography was identical to or even similar to ours.

     

    Ameratsu, Shiva and Kali showing up are kind of a big hint. So is the Mercedes Benz hood ornament, and the giraffe freize, and the aircraft contrails. I agree, the mythological backstory should remain hinted at, but it shouldn't be removed altogether.

     

    I suspect RJ would have included a few more hints if he had lived (he seemed to be going somewhere with the Ogier and the Book of Translation in KoD, but Sanderson never picked up on it), but ultimately it's irrelevant to the main storyline.

     

    To be fair, they could probably make the first 5 books last 1 season each.

    Later books, like 6,7,8/ 9,10,11/ 12,13,14 could all be one season each.

     

     

    That's still 12 seasons, which will not happen.

     

    One thing everyone has to consider, and is often not really understood, is that the length of the books don't have a set ratio of pages to minutes.

    Many chapters are going to translate to mere minutes on screen time, while others will translate to hours.

     

    Any chapter in which RJ introduces a location, cast of characters, what outfits they are wearing, what they did that morning before they go on about there day, may take 15+ pages to describe. But on video, that can all be accomplished in under 30 seconds.

     

    Dialogue and action scenes are going to take the longest screen time, but conversely, take the fewest pages in the books.

     

     

    Yes and no. There is actually a Hollywood rule of thumb that one page in a traditonal paperback equals 1 minute of screen time. It's why movies of even reasonably-sized books are quite truncated: the average book is around 300 pages long but that's still five hours of screen time. The Lord of the Rings movie trilogy - which is otherwise reasonably faithful - is 11 hours long in its extended version and still leaves a lot of stuff out. A faithful adaptation of the novel would require it to be more like 16-17 hours. The rule works because what you gain in being able to show in a few seconds which might take pages (description, mostly) you lose in dialogue and action scenes. A big problem is that the visual medium cannot effectively show interior character monologues, so an adaptation has to find a way of externalising that character development which also takes up time you might have gained elsewhere.

  15. They can't do a season per book, or if they try it will be a good sign they are not committed to taking the project seriously. There is no way this will last 14 seasons.

     

    I agree a strong budget is required. $10 million+ per episode is a bit ambitious for a new show off the bat, but certainly GoT's starting budget ($6 million per ep) should not be out of the question. It can go up later on if the first season is successful. It's worth bearing in mind that the average budget-per-episode on US TV is still $2 million, with even the CW's superhero shows with lots of effects getting less than $3 million per episode.

  16.  

    A simple POV device. If your POV character in a scene is a channeller, we can see stuff from their viewpoint, complete with colours swirling around and so on. If they're not, then you just see the effects of the weaves, not the weaves themselves.

     

     

     

     I get the POV device, but my concern is more about how to make some of the confrontations between channelers compelling to watch. Take for example, a beautifully choreographed kung fu scene, then compare that to 2 static combatants weaving the one power. You can see the challenge of creating an epic fight scene, to choreograph a dance of weaves to rival Hong Kong Kung Fu cinema, that's what I want   :ph34r:   :flamingsword:   :perrin:

     

     

    Hmm. It wouldn't work as-is for WoT, but it may be worth checking out Avatar: The Last Airbender, in which the elemental magic (not dissimilar to the One Power) is "cast" by the characters through differing forms of martial arts. We know the Aes Sedai make hand signs when launching fireballs and so on, so there may be some kind of visual cue that can be developed that would work in a similar manner.

  17. Script/ screen adaptation is another big concern of mine. GoT season are only 10 episodes long, and that seems to be the going rate on all major series from Netflix, Amazon, USA, AMC etc. The season will have to be longer than 10 episodes right? I realize there' a lot of meat dedicated to detailed descriptions of people, places and concepts that will translate directly into what we see on screen, but there's still a whole lot of story telling as well. 

     

    The maximum number of episodes possible is about 16 (which is what The Walking Dead gets) and I think WoT would need that. You might be able to squeeze it into 14 episode seasons, 12 if you want to be quite ruthless. 10...well, you could get some of the story there, but not all of it and you'd have to cut out a lot of good stuff.

     

    The reason for that is that you really need to do two books per season (for 7 seasons total), so roughly 8 episodes per book. You can move that around a little - The Dragon Reborn, the shortest book in the series, could be done in 6 and The Shadow Rising, the longest book, might need 10 - but that gives you a rough ballpark to be aiming for. With 10-episode seasons, can you really do The Eye of the World or Lord of Chaos justice in just 5 episodes each? It's better than a movie situation, but it's still going to be massively limiting.

     

    How will weaving the one power be acted out? Remember the battle between Nynaeve and Moghedion in Chachin? At one point during their fierce battle it is said that if anyone had entered the room all they would see is 2 women glaring at each other, hands to their side. As the reader, we know there's in fact a maelstrom of weaves being cut and countered around two critical weaves of spirit, one from each combatant, to shield the other from Saidar. IMO, this is one of the best 1v1 bouts in the whole series, how do you recreate the same intensity in a live action format? When so much of what made that confrontation intense comes from the thoughts racing through Nynaeve's mind?

    A simple POV device. If your POV character in a scene is a channeller, we can see stuff from their viewpoint, complete with colours swirling around and so on. If they're not, then you just see the effects of the weaves, not the weaves themselves.

  18. It depends on how you want to go with it. The Aiel being fair-skinned is completely illogical after 3,400 years living in what is effectively a desert, so do you go with RJ's literary description or do you go with what makes more scientific sense and will scan better to an audience? But then you go have to figure in Rand's appearance being unusual in the Two Rivers so some kind of distinctive element is still required. Then you have the somewhat unclear descriptions of Two Rivers folk, with fans apparently generally believing they're fair-skinned Europeans but the descriptions making a lot of references to "dark" colouring and artwork (official and not) being all over the place in depicting them, from quite fair-skinned to quite northern Mediterranean (Italian/Spanish/Greek).

     

    Then you have the issue that you start casting and pretty quickly the homegenity is going to become a limiting factor. You have an awesome actor for Mat and an awesome actress for Egwene, but they're from different ethnic backgrounds. Do you potentially lose an actor for an inferior one for the sake of homegenity or do you just go with the best actors and rationalise it (or just ignore it)? WoT does have the explanation that in the Age of Legends the entire human race in all its creeds and colours had been thrown and mixed together, and then jumbled up in the Breaking, so you can adopt colour-blind casting if you really wanted to. But would that be disrespectful to the books? Or if Robert Jordan was still here would he be laughing his head off and saying it really doesn't matter as long as the actors are the best?

     

    What happens then if the production decides to film in, say, New Zealand for costs? You can fly in the main actors from wherever, but your entire secondary cast on down is going to be pretty much either white or Maori, with very few other options available (Shannara has this situation to deal with). Do you ignore that or rationalise it somehow in the story?

     

    That's why saying, "It's got to be like the books 100%" is highly unrealistic. Depending on budget, filming location and the size of the available acting pool they're going to have to make some changes to that side of things.

  19. I think Amazon would be the canny choice. They've been selling WoT books for 20 years, millions of them, so they know how big the fanbase is. They're also still looking for a killer show that will make people tune in: Man in the High Castle and a couple of their other shows are excellent (and The Tick looks like it could be great) but they haven't got a "killer app" yet and WoT could fill that gap quite nicely. Amazon also have serious financial firepower they can put into the show and would be more likely to fund the longer seasons (16 episodes each minimum, with each season covering two novels) that will be required to do the story justice.

     

    Showtime have been looking for a new big hit for a while now, but my concern with them is that they don't have as much financial muscle as some of the other options. You can't do WoT on the cheap.

  20. I believe those with knowledge of the deal have confirmed that HBO is not the studio involved, and have showed zero interest in any other fantasy property as long as GoT is ongoing. And yes, Westworld is very much the show they are (foolishly, IMO) pinning their hopes on to repeat GoT's success.

     

    The same sources have indicated that the WoT deal was for over $10 million, which is substantial for a book-to-TV deal. To my mind, the only companies realistically in the running to spend that money are Starz, AMC, Showtime, Netflix or Amazon. And I strongly suspect it's the Sony TV deal that was under negotiation before the Winter Dragon/Red Eagle situation blew up.

  21. Yup, the only thing that's happened is that a TV studio has picked up the option. They certainly won't be anywhere near set-building, casting or actual physical production. Why they are now is probably getting a pilot script put together and they'll then look at that and whether they want to exercise the option as a pilot or a full season order.

     

    In terms of announcement, that has to come I believe before pre-production starts (to allow people in the industry to put in job applicatons and so on), but exactly where is up to the studio. The studio could have announced the project months ago, but this delay suggest they want a meatier announcement with more information on the writer and producers. That could come pretty much at any time now.

  22. The Call by Peadar O Guilin

     

    The island of Ireland has been sealed off from the rest of the world by a mystical barrier. Technology cannot penetrate it. The people of Ireland, the division between north and south no longer mattering, are under constant attack. Every teenager is "Called", summoned to another realm where they do battle with the Aes Sidhe, the ancient rulers of Ireland before they were banished in a great war. The Sidhe have a day in their realm (three minutes in ours) to hunt down and kill the child, otherwise the victime escapes. Sometimes the Sidhe spare the victim, to return them home mutilated or "changed" in some horrific fashion. Most of the time, the Sidhe kill the victim.

    Nessa is a teenager at school, but in this age schools do not teach algebra or humanities. Instead they teach each student on how to survive in the Sidhe realm, how to kill the fairies and how to escape back home. Nessa's prospects are dim due to a childhood brush with polio and the resulting weakening of her legs. But Nessa has made a vow to survive, no matter the cost.

    It's been nine years since Peadar O'Guilin released his debut novel, The Inferior, an SF story of high-tech and savage, cannibalistic societies coexisting next to each other. Since then, he's made a habit of writing stories that combine mythology, SF and horror, told with verve and intelligence. The Call is an evolution of that storytelling style, and should be a major step forward for his career.

    The Call is a rich story mixing horror, survivalism and deep-rooted Irish mythology. "Hey, this sounds a bit like The Hunger Games," some may say, and I suspect the comparison will become a cornerstone of future reviews. However, I would argue that the story is less like The Hunger Games and, at least in spirit and tone, more like that's novel's considerably darker, superior and more adult inspiration, Koushun Takami's Battle Royale. Like that novel The Call channels many of the real issues, challenges and emotional turmoils of being a teenager, given greater resonance by being studied through the lens of an extraordinary situation that transforms the foibles of adolescence into a grim and deadly game of survival.

    The result is a mash-up of Battle Royale, Terry Pratchett's Lord and Ladies and an Irish version of Skins, but parsed by O'Guilin's signature dark wit and expert pacing. The book moves like a rollercoaster from the off, but has time to delve into Irish mythology, reflect on teenage angst and sexuality (this is a pretty frank book in that regard) and develop its key characters, not just redoubtable protagonist Nessa but also her friends, the teachers at the school and her sworn enemies. O'Guilin has developed that most enviable knack of dropping us into a character's head for a few moments and establishing them as a full-realised person in just a page or two. He does this so well that it's hard not feel sympathy even for the "bad guys" when they get offed.

    It's a short novel at 320 pages, but it moves fast, is extremely bloody-minded and has a body count that might make even George R.R. Martin wince. It's also very smart, with its premise and "rules" interrogated by the characters as much as by the reader, and tremendously adult. It may be marketed as a "YA" book but it does not pander to presupposed juvenile tastes. It treats its audience with respect and credits them with intelligence.

    There's not much to say that is negative. It's another one of these books that's the first of a series but the marketing doesn't really mention it (a sequel, The Cauldron, should follow in due course). It also feels like the danger of "sleeper agents", people sent back by the Sidhe having apparently survived their Calling but in reality transformed into their slaves, should have been more properly considered by the Irish authorities and protected against. But these are less than minor issues.

    The Call (****½) will be published by David Fickling Books in the UK and Ireland on 30 August this year, and in the USA by Scholastic around the same time. I very strongly recommend it.

    Edit: I've now had a couple of people ask about this. The term "Aes Sidhe" is the original Irish term ("Aos Si" is a more recent form) for a mythological species of fairies or elves who originally ruled Ireland before being defeated by men. The Book of Conquests (also The Book of Invasions or The Book of the Taking of Ireland) is an account of this conflict, dating back to the 11th Century but based on considerably older oral traditions.

    Needless to say, the term massively predates the term "Aes Sedai", which Robert Jordan borrowed from the Irish for his Wheel of Time sequence beginning in 1990. O'Guilin is simply using the original term from Irish mythology.
×
×
  • Create New...