DEMONOLOGY - GAME THREAD

[Mafia-16]

From my vantage Marsh doesn't fit anywhere based on how I think the different groups are numbered.

 

If he's what I'm assuming he is then I am wrong elsewhere

[Mafia-16]

Or my picture wasn't as clear as it was before with how things are structured.

[Mafia-20]

A Crush check is fine. He had plenty of time to say more yesterday had he wanted to.

[Mafia-20]

16, would you agree that the two remaining Demons are not friends?

[Mafia-16]

Friends in what capacity?

 

I had it down to Marsh/Crusher

 

If people can confirm Marsh then it is someone else.

[Mafia-17]

Night Actions will help narrow down the PoE regardless.

[Mafia-20]

I am unaware of anything to Notbob's credit.

[Mafia-17]

If Scum!Shad posted 400+ times then color me impressed.

[Mafia-20]

Friends in what capacity?

I suppose it depends on whether we are facing two Mafia teams or one team and an independent killer. I've been suspecting the latter, but I have no real grounds for this.

[Mafia-16]

I am unaware of anything to Notbob's credit.

He's Daddy Heathen

[Mafia-17]

 

Friends in what capacity?

I suppose it depends on whether we are facing two Mafia teams or one team and an independent killer. I've been suspecting the latter, but I have no real grounds for this.

 

 

21 players would make me think there prolly is a 3rd party player.

[Mafia-16]

 

Friends in what capacity?

I suppose it depends on whether we are facing two Mafia teams or one team and an independent killer. I've been suspecting the latter, but I have no real grounds for this.

Close but no cigar.

[Mafia-20]

I wonder if it is as simple as Crush and Tinker.

[Mafia-20]

There are quite a few things that don't match up with my own knowledge, but that's all relevant to how players have chosen to utilize their own.

[Mafia-12]

I wonder if it is as simple as Crush and Tinker.

 

Tiinker is only an option if there is exactly one traitor in the ranks.

[Mafia-20]

I was informed at the start of this game that certain groups were very explicitly town, but given that members of the Order are claiming they received misleading information, I'm not sure anymore.

[Mafia-10]

I can say without a shadow of doubt there are two demons left.

How can you know this? unless you're one of them.

[Mafia-10]

 

 

Friends in what capacity?

I suppose it depends on whether we are facing two Mafia teams or one team and an independent killer. I've been suspecting the latter, but I have no real grounds for this.

Close but no cigar.

You seem very certain.

[Mafia-20]

Heathens are specifically town players. A traitor who is explicitly a Heathen would contradict my role PM.

 

The Order is town as a collective, but the verbiage is less specific about its constituents. It rather strongly implies that they would all be town, but it does not state this as a matter of fact.

 

If that can be trusted. I have never played in a game where it could not be, but different communities view these things differently, so I don't know what is standard for the mod.

[Mafia-10]

 

I can say without a shadow of doubt there are two demons left.

How can you know this? unless you're one of them.

Who do you think they are?

[Mafia-12]

Heathens are specifically town players. A traitor who is explicitly a Heathen would contradict my role PM.

 

The Order is town as a collective, but the verbiage is less specific about its constituents. It rather strongly implies that they would all be town, but it does not state this as a matter of fact.

 

If that can be trusted. I have never played in a game where it could not be, but different communities view these things differently, so I don't know what is standard for the mod.

 

OK.  Then no need to waste a check on Tiinker.

 

DPR games are generally complex and occasionally misleading, but not bastard games.  I'm inclined to believe that not giving Zander the names of the Order members even though the Order role PMs said the Acolyte would have them was a minor error rather than an intentional mod lie.

[Mafia-20]

I'll look into this more and get back to you.

[Mafia-16]

 

 

I can say without a shadow of doubt there are two demons left.

How can you know this? unless you're one of them.

Who do you think they are?

I've already said.

[Mafia-20]

But one of them claimed he can be confirmed.

[Mafia-16]

I know.

 

Which means someone else doesn't fit where I thought they should.