[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[monstrman]

This is dum

[Guest]

All I know is that mechanically one of you and tiink is a wolf because otherwise you'd be lynched and game would be over right now

 

I agree with you but I also posted my "mechanical" thoughts here vvvv

 

[unvote]

 

So firstly I think it's very strange that the Tiink train didn't pick up. According to me most of you have him as scum and yet none of you are voting? Been thinking about that.

 

So either [1] he's scum. In this case the remaining scum member isn't voting him yet so as not to give her-/himself away, imo. Maybe he/she is hoping to move the attention elsewhere.

 

Or [2] Tiink is town. In this case I look scummy for starting his train. I think whoever the two scum are are either hoping to have only one on his train later so as not to look too eager. I don't know.

 

It's actually in total weird to me that the only people that have been voted this day is me and Tiink - who was voted by me.

 

 

And after reading through Sooh's stuff, which I'll post now, I'm inclined to think Tiink/Me is w/w or v/v. It's not the first one. So.

[monstrman]

I don't think it can be v/v still

 

I left my vote on you a full day and the game isn't over

[Guest]

Sooh's interactions with us remaining 6.

 

 

 

Going to colour-code names.

Myself, Tiink, Nego-Dya, Monstrman, Hellian-Wildfire, Pral/Kat.

 

• Very early interactions with myself and Tiink - both of us initiated it.

• Nego joke-voted me and Sooh further commented on that.

• She mentions me (and Darthe) again when Zander thought I was scummy.

• Then she decides that I am scummy and says Tiink’s vote on Zander is bad

• Pral says something to Tiink and Tiink unvotes an obvious joke-vote, and Sooh comments on that

• Pral comments on my AtE, which Zander says is a misrep of him, which Sooh comments on.

• * Comments on Nego’s joke vote after Monstrman says it’s scummy to unvote me

• Says Monstrman is a villager - first time she mentions him

• Says she’ll keep an eye on Tiink

• Here she actually seems to be defending me against Zander that said I misrepped him, and Darthe agrees with her reasoning

• Says I and Tiink are her scummiest

• Again she seems to be defending me

• Then it was that thing where I said I liked to town too, albeit not as much as to wolf

• Answers a question towards her read on me to Nego

• Wants to know why people think I’m village

• Says she likes my thoughts list

• Mentions Hellian is a lurker

• Ask Zander why he singled-out Hellian and Kat/Pral over the rest

• Agrees with Nego’s thoughts and answers him about her knowledge of me

• * Comments on Tiink & Monstrman to Pral

• She votes Tiink here

• Gives reasoning for voting Tiink

• Agrees with Monstrman about Zander here

• Doesn’t move to Zander but stays on Tiink to “increase his activity”

• Unvotes Tiink because she’s “temporarily satisfied” and moves on to shade Zander

• Says she doesn’t read Monstrman or Dice easily

• Agrees with Calder that either Dice or Nego is scum, Monstrman is town and Dice is unknown

• Comments on conversation between Monstrman and me, and highlights Darthe poking in. Also, reads list with Monstrman, myself and Nego as town, and unsure about Tiink, Kat/Pral and Hellian.

• Wants to discuss my alignment with Calder

• Asks if I’ve mentioned Nolder

• Agrees with Monstrman that a Zander post is AtE

• Defends Monstrman when Z says he AtE’s a lot

• Replies to me asking her about Nolder

• Replies to me asking about Darthe

• Comments to Monstrman about EoD1

• Says Monstrman should make a case on her

• Comments on Monstrman’s defence of himself

• Asks Nego why he doesn’t want to vote Wildfire

• Says she doesn’t have time to get into Monstrman’s vote on her

• Says Tiink and I are interesting

• Asks Believer why he voted Tiink

• Asks Pral why he voted me

• Defends Tiink like she defended me beginning game

• Continues arguing with Nolder about Tiink, saying Tiink got a good scum team in Besie/Nego and voted accordingly

• First mention of Dya she’s really excited

And her last post is some strange Aladdin one about Tiink that shouldn’t be considered for gameplay.

 

 

 

[Guest]

I don't think it can be v/v still

 

I left my vote on you a full day and the game isn't over

 

Exactly why I think either you or Tiink are scum. And the second was waiting to hammer. Unless you're both scum and was just hopefully waiting. 

[monstrman]

[V]wildfire [/v]

[Guest]

Going by Sooh's interactions with us, she treated me and Tiink very much the same. She defended us both and sussed us both. 

 

This is why I think Tiink is town with me. Then I'm inclined to think Wildfire is scum.

[Guest]

xpost

[monstrman]

[unvote]

[Guest]

I'm not looking much into whoever the deepwolf is. There has to be one. I'm certain of it.

[monstrman]

I agree with you and this is some sick analysis if you're a wolf

 

You literally just instantly 180d my opinion of your alignment

[monstrman]

I think it's wild/pral

[monstrman]

Could it be wild/pral?

 

Were they on at the same time during the time I was voting you?

[Guest]

I still think it's you, Monstrman. I'll try to case it. If it's not you, I'm going to say it's Pral/Kat - unless the thoughts in the thread have been right and Nego-Dya is a godfather.

[monstrman]

Idk the vote thing makes me feel like tiink is probably the wolf

[Guest]

Could it be wild/pral?

 

Were they on at the same time during the time I was voting you?

 

I don't know, but yes. It can be. I really don't know where to even start with the deepwolf thing. You are my best bet.

[Guest]

lol, can you make up your mind?

[monstrman]

Going by Sooh's interactions with us, she treated me and Tiink very much the same. She defended us both and sussed us both. 

 

This is why I think Tiink is town with me. Then I'm inclined to think Wildfire is scum.

 

I don't think it can be v/v still

I left my vote on you a full day and the game isn't over

 

 

Exactly why I think either you or Tiink are scum. And the second was waiting to hammer. Unless you're both scum and was just hopefully waiting.

Okay wait a second

 

Which one do you think because it can't be both

[monstrman]

 

Could it be wild/pral?

Were they on at the same time during the time I was voting you?

 

 

I don't know, but yes. It can be. I really don't know where to even start with the deepwolf thing. You are my best bet.

I am an awful bet

[monstrman]

I have been the most engaged, most around, and most opinionated person in the thread

 

That person is literally never a wolf

 

Not sometimes a wolf

 

Not a wolf every hundred games

 

literally never

[monstrman]

Aside from Darthe, that is.

 

He was engaged and opinionated maybe a little more than me

[Guest]

Going by Sooh's interactions with us, she treated me and Tiink very much the same. She defended us both and sussed us both. 

 

This is why I think Tiink is town with me. Then I'm inclined to think Wildfire is scum.

Idk the vote thing makes me feel like tiink is probably the wolf

 

I don't think so.

 

The list is this: Me. Nego/Dya (cop + gameplay). Monstrman (gameplay). Pral/Kat (gameplay). Tiink (Sooh interactions). Wildfire (?).

[Guest]

 

Going by Sooh's interactions with us, she treated me and Tiink very much the same. She defended us both and sussed us both. 

 

This is why I think Tiink is town with me. Then I'm inclined to think Wildfire is scum.

 

I don't think it can be v/v still

I left my vote on you a full day and the game isn't over

 

Exactly why I think either you or Tiink are scum. And the second was waiting to hammer. Unless you're both scum and was just hopefully waiting.

Okay wait a second

 

Which one do you think because it can't be both

 

 

That is the question. Are you and Tiink v/w, w/v or w/w? Nothing else makes sense.

 

If you're v, then he's w and Sooh interactions when compared to mine means that she did it without thinking, maybe not on purpose, or maybe on purpose???

If he's v, then you are deepwolf.

Or you are both wolf and I suck at this.

[monstrman]

Tiink I need to see your endgame thought process

 

We're getting the lynch correct today and I'm making sure of it

[Guest]

If I go by Wildfire is scum, then I think you are the deepwolf. Going to ISO you, but that's more important for next day when we're hunting deepwolves.

 

Today, I'd like to lynch a less-in-hiding scum. We have to lynch a scum. Is it Tiink or Wildfire? I'm betting on Wildfire.