SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-14]

I ask because it seems like your working to disprove my reasons/case. Or at least dismiss it and have others do the same. Just because it's D1 doesn't mean we have to all pile like sheep with no thought of our own. I may be wrong, but at least I'm thinking for myself.

[Mafia-18]

unvote vote Black Knight

 

Not gonna be here for the deadline. Don't want a random lynch or a blind lynch.

[Mafia-14]

unvote vote Black Knight

 

Not gonna be here for the deadline. Don't want a random lynch or a blind lynch.

*facepalm* really? I don't want a random either, but a blind lynch? There have been cases made against each BK and GC. I'm not sure what you mean by blind lynch.

[Mafia-5]

You too seem so sure. Interesting. Why is my case, which is based on not only the Velma mention but also the lack of defense until "I did it for reactions" (also only admitted when very close to a lynch), any different or less important than one based on PM mention?

Simple.  Resistance.  Or lack thereof.  There seems to be some resistance to the Black Knight counterwagon for absolutely no good reason.  The Ghost Clown wagon built up without so much as a whisper of resistance.  It's almost like Ghost Clown didn't have any friends to help out while Black Knight does.  I wonder who has friends on Day 1...

[Mafia-5]

*facepalm* really? I don't want a random either, but a blind lynch? There have been cases made against each BK and GC. I'm not sure what you mean by blind lynch.

I'm pretty sure he means a lynch not controlled by Town.

[Mafia-14]

 

 

You too seem so sure. Interesting. Why is my case, which is based on not only the Velma mention but also the lack of defense until "I did it for reactions" (also only admitted when very close to a lynch), any different or less important than one based on PM mention?

Simple. Resistance. Or lack thereof. There seems to be some resistance to the Black Knight counterwagon for absolutely no good reason. The Ghost Clown wagon built up without so much as a whisper of resistance. It's almost like Ghost Clown didn't have any friends to help out while Black Knight does. I wonder who has friends on Day 1...

Ok, I can see your point. Makes sense.

 

Unvote Vote Black Knight

[Mafia-4]

 

You too seem so sure. Interesting. Why is my case, which is based on not only the Velma mention but also the lack of defense until "I did it for reactions" (also only admitted when very close to a lynch), any different or less important than one based on PM mention?

Simple.  Resistance.  Or lack thereof.  There seems to be some resistance to the Black Knight counterwagon for absolutely no good reason.  The Ghost Clown wagon built up without so much as a whisper of resistance.  It's almost like Ghost Clown didn't have any friends to help out while Black Knight does.  I wonder who has friends on Day 1...

 

 

 

Well said Kitty Kat.  

 

unvote vote blacknight

[Mafia-14]

[quote name="JAGUARO mafia" post="2993432" timestamp="1375385

I'm pretty sure he means a lynch not controlled by Town.

Possibly, I'll wait to get an answer from the source though.

[Mafia-14]

By my count that's

 

Black Knight: 12

Ghost Clown: 9

[CHARLIE ROBOT mafia]

Miner 49er

Creeper

Ghost

 

They stick out to me and I will case later when I can get fully awake. For now I would rather see unvote vote black knight die than Ghost clown.

 

Pterodactyl and the one I voted before seem odd on memory as well, but I have no basis for that mentally ATM just a feeling from reading last night.

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

 

Unvote

 

Nope.  Too easy.  Ghost is Town.

 

Vote Black Knight

 

In case you all forgot, he's the one that was hyper aware of the fact Velma would be scum in this game.  My Jaguar senses are tingling.

Hyper aware? Not only did I casually mention it, but the knowledge came from me actually bothering to read my PM.

 

After Ghost Clown, you're next.

 

That's what I said.

 

PM's would say Gangmember - Mafia, Monster - Town. So yeah, bothering to read my PM gave me the knowledge of who's who and isn't an indicator of alignment, so you fixating on this completely when you don't seem to have properly thought it through is just a large fountain of BS. The PMs don't mention who's who so it leads me to believe that you don't know what a town PM looks like. Jaguaro and TarMonster trying to sound like hotshots.

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

 

 

You too seem so sure. Interesting. Why is my case, which is based on not only the Velma mention but also the lack of defense until "I did it for reactions" (also only admitted when very close to a lynch), any different or less important than one based on PM mention?

Simple. Resistance. Or lack thereof. There seems to be some resistance to the Black Knight counterwagon for absolutely no good reason. The Ghost Clown wagon built up without so much as a whisper of resistance. It's almost like Ghost Clown didn't have any friends to help out while Black Knight does. I wonder who has friends on Day 1...

Or it seems like he has friends, since his train stopped and then direction was shifted to another for no apparent reason. You seem to have an ability to tunnel on one point only.

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

Vote Count please

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

Miner 49er

Creeper

Ghost

 

They stick out to me and I will case later when I can get fully awake. For now I would rather see unvote vote black knight die than Ghost clown.

 

Pterodactyl and the one I voted before seem odd on memory as well, but I have no basis for that mentally ATM just a feeling from reading last night.

BS. Deadline is 4 hours and who do you want to go casing? You're already voting me. Cover post for bandwagon vote.

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

I'm a Tracker.

[Mafia-14]

I'm a Tracker.

Unvote Vote Ghost Clown

 

At the sake of not risking a town power role I'll switch back to my originally suspect. I'll vote back if necessary. I'll be back online in an hour or two.

[Mafia-13]

I'm a Tracker.

 

unvote, vote Ghost Clown

[Mafia-17]

My vote stays. I think he's mafia and tracker is one of the worst investigative roles imo anyways and could be either alignment.

[Mafia-21]

unvote vote Black Knight

 

Not gonna be here for the deadline. Don't want a random lynch or a blind lynch.

 

 

 

unvote vote Black Knight

 

Not gonna be here for the deadline. Don't want a random lynch or a blind lynch.

*facepalm* really? I don't want a random either, but a blind lynch? There have been cases made against each BK and GC. I'm not sure what you mean by blind lynch.

 

 

 

 

*facepalm* really? I don't want a random either, but a blind lynch? There have been cases made against each BK and GC. I'm not sure what you mean by blind lynch.

I'm pretty sure he means a lynch not controlled by Town.

 

 

FYI, a blind lynch would be when the person being lynched does not have a chance to claim or defend.  The town lynches blind without having any idea based on responses/defense from the person being lynched.

[Mafia-21]

My vote stays. I think he's mafia and tracker is one of the worst investigative roles imo anyways and could be either alignment.

 

You, sir, are awfully confident.

[Mafia-9]

Checking in and going through the thread now. Sorry, been busy.

[Mafia-5]

Unvote

 

Vote No Lynch

 

We don't have time to figure out if Black Knight is lying or not.  And I still think Ghost is Town due to the ease of wagon formation.  I suppose the same could be said of Black Knight.  We are better served with a no lynch than a mislynch.  We'll get our info from the night actions and figure out what's what in the morning.

 

Please vote no lynch, everyone, and we can avoid a random lynch.

[Mafia-5]

My vote stays. I think he's mafia and tracker is one of the worst investigative roles imo anyways and could be either alignment.

Not really a risk I'm willing to take.

[Mafia-21]

Unvote

 

Vote No Lynch

 

We don't have time to figure out if Black Knight is lying or not.  And I still think Ghost is Town due to the ease of wagon formation.  I suppose the same could be said of Black Knight.  We are better served with a no lynch than a mislynch.  We'll get our info from the night actions and figure out what's what in the morning.

 

Please vote no lynch, everyone, and we can avoid a random lynch.

 

No way.  Getting that coroner report and using that to gauge how people treated the train when jumping on and off is why you never No Lynch in the early game.

[Mafia-21]

 

My vote stays. I think he's mafia and tracker is one of the worst investigative roles imo anyways and could be either alignment.

Not really a risk I'm willing to take.

 

 

On D1?  Why so nervous?