SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-7]

Kook is pre-  

[Mafia-8]

We should probably lynch Witch Doc first anyways. It looks to me like he definitely submitted incorrect info. Whether or not Space Kook did can be figured out later.

Yeah.  I would tend to agree with the underlined.  I actually have my right eye on another target - just to test a theory.  I think it's an idea even Space Kook would get behind.

[Mafia-10]

 

KOOK can reveal sooner if he wishes to. In the meantime, why is it such a bad idea to argue without information?

 

lol Really?

 

Then why share WD's night actions? If you want actual educated input, as opposed to just standing there and listening to yourself talk, then you need to give us the full picture. Otherwise don't act surprised when all you get is people shooting out of their arse.

 

 

Which is exactly what I want. Keep shotting. You might hit something.

[Mafia-8]

By the way, there are going to be two lynches tomorrow.  So heads up and all that.

[Mafia-10]

Only problem: last time we tried this magistrate lynching, we never got a flip until both trains were finished.

[Mafia-21]

 

*sigh*

 

Listen, I know that I'm telling the truth.  You don't.  Based on this, I know WD had a Watcher role for me to steal on N3.  How you were able to steal on N2 and then me on N3 when he says he did nothing in between doesn't make sense.  He is either lying or the data is somehow flawed.  Why is this not sinking in?

 Again with the accusation that my data is "somehow flawed."  I guess it it's possible your theory isn't "sinking in" because it doesn't make any sort of logical sense?

 

I did steal the role N2.  Of that fact there is no dispute. 

You claimed you stole the role N3.  Of that fact there is no dispute. 

WD claims the role was stolen N3.  Of that fact there is no dispute. 

WD claims he holstered Nights 2 and 3.  Of that fact there is no dispute.

 

The data is good.  There is no room for error.  You are flailing.

 

 

OMG.  This is just pathetic.  I've outlined the only 2 possibilities.  The more likely scenario is that he's scum and that would explain why we both stole what we did.....and open up a game mechanic we didn't know existed.  I said this in the PM to you.

 

How you translate what I say into "flailing" is just sad.  You're ruining whatever credibility you've gained by being confirmed town.  Just stop posting until we know more.

[Mafia-21]

Space Kook's continued dodging should be noted though.

 

Why don't you just get it over with and admit that your "scum in the trap" argument sucked?

 

What are you talking about?  How is that in any way relevant to why I wanted out of the trap?  You're putting a round peg into a square hole.  Try again.

[Mafia-21]

 

We should probably lynch Witch Doc first anyways. It looks to me like he definitely submitted incorrect info. Whether or not Space Kook did can be figured out later.

Yeah.  I would tend to agree with the underlined.  I actually have my right eye on another target - just to test a theory.  I think it's an idea even Space Kook would get behind.

 

 

Does it involve giving me a pencil to jam into your left eyesocket?  I'd be all about that plan!!!!

[Mafia-8]

 

 

We should probably lynch Witch Doc first anyways. It looks to me like he definitely submitted incorrect info. Whether or not Space Kook did can be figured out later.

Yeah.  I would tend to agree with the underlined.  I actually have my right eye on another target - just to test a theory.  I think it's an idea even Space Kook would get behind.

 

 

Does it involve giving me a pencil to jam into your left eyesocket?  I'd be all about that plan!!!!

No.  It doesn't.  Scum.

[Mafia-10]

Verb, MANTIS: please drop it. What about hunting scum.

 

So what y'all think about this creepy pile of heap?

[Mafia-9]

xD   Ice ice baby.

[Mafia-10]

Also, seriously.

 

22 players in the game. 6-7 scum. Scum needs to be lynched asap. The more and the sooner, the better. (you're in a hurry cause your mod is up to something)

 

You know that A or B is scum (or both). You don't know which. You are given a chance to flip a coin that instakills one of them. Would you choose to flip it?

[Mafia-21]

 

 

 

We should probably lynch Witch Doc first anyways. It looks to me like he definitely submitted incorrect info. Whether or not Space Kook did can be figured out later.

Yeah.  I would tend to agree with the underlined.  I actually have my right eye on another target - just to test a theory.  I think it's an idea even Space Kook would get behind.

 

 

Does it involve giving me a pencil to jam into your left eyesocket?  I'd be all about that plan!!!!

No.  It doesn't.  Scum.

 

 

You keep using that word.  I don't think it means what you think it means.

[Mafia-21]

As to the bussing comment if WD flips scum:  meh.  Then why is another player vetting my info?  Wax & Mantis know this, yet (Mantis at least) can't remember that far back and keeps accusing me of being scum.

[Mafia-17]

 

 

Space Kook's continued dodging should be noted though.

 

Why don't you just get it over with and admit that your "scum in the trap" argument sucked?

What are you talking about? How is that in any way relevant to why I wanted out of the trap? You're putting a round peg into a square hole. Try again.

I don't mind you wanting out of the trap. That was perfectly logical.

 

What wasn't logical was you expecting everyone to immediately release you and your reasoning for wanting to keep Coffin in the trap. Scum motives are not easily guessed and are easily WIFOMed. There was no reason to think that Coffin was scum just because he was trapped. For those of us outside the trap, there wasn't much difference between the two of you. Hyde had claimed a cop view on you, but like you've been reminding us, N1 cop views aren't necessarily trustworthy in this game. So you acting like we should obviously let you out but keep Coffin in there looked pretty bad.

[Mafia-10]

As to the bussing comment if WD flips scum:  meh.  Then why is another player vetting my info?  Wax & Mantis know this, yet (Mantis at least) can't remember that far back and keeps accusing me of being scum.

 

Please let me know who is vetting your info. 

[Mafia-17]

Ugh. DM sucks right now.

 

I disagree with the 6-7 scum thing btw. Weren't there 5 members of the gang?

 

So maybe 5 scum with a suit?

[Mafia-10]

I think game started with 5 scum with 2-3 suits (that they received at start, or maybe later).

[Mafia-21]

 

 

Space Kook's continued dodging should be noted though.

 

Why don't you just get it over with and admit that your "scum in the trap" argument sucked?

What are you talking about? How is that in any way relevant to why I wanted out of the trap? You're putting a round peg into a square hole. Try again.

I don't mind you wanting out of the trap. That was perfectly logical.

 

What wasn't logical was you expecting everyone to immediately release you and your reasoning for wanting to keep Coffin in the trap. Scum motives are not easily guessed and are easily WIFOMed. There was no reason to think that Coffin was scum just because he was trapped. For those of us outside the trap, there wasn't much difference between the two of you. Hyde had claimed a cop view on you, but like you've been reminding us, N1 cop views aren't necessarily trustworthy in this game. So you acting like we should obviously let you out but keep Coffin in there looked pretty bad.

 

 

I was asking to be released - that was me wanting to remain alive and play the game.  As for keeping Coffin in there, I was offering a theory on scum vetting a member until endgame.  Like I said in the post I mentioned it in, it is a move I would have considered making if I was scum.  I wanted to put the info out there for town to digest.  Are you suggesting that wasn't a logical thing to do?

 

As to the bold, you basically make it impossible for me to be scum, lol.  If I argued letting me go and keeping him in to die, wouldn't that kind of make it seem obvious that I just did what I said scum could do - place a member in there to look townish?

 

 

 

 

As to the bussing comment if WD flips scum:  meh.  Then why is another player vetting my info?  Wax & Mantis know this, yet (Mantis at least) can't remember that far back and keeps accusing me of being scum.

 

Please let me know who is vetting your info. 

 

 

[Mafia-21]

 

As to the bussing comment if WD flips scum:  meh.  Then why is another player vetting my info?  Wax & Mantis know this, yet (Mantis at least) can't remember that far back and keeps accusing me of being scum.

 

Please let me know who is vetting your info. 

 

 

What is this, I don't even.....

[Mafia-17]

I think game started with 5 scum with 2-3 suits (that they received at start, or maybe later).

 

I think you're out of your mind.

[Mafia-17]

I wish Salami would let Yates do the leg work.

[Mafia-10]

Who is Yates?

[Mafia-21]

Not sure that would be much better, Wombat.

[Mafia-8]

Who is Yates?

They think I'm Yates.  I'll take that as a compliment.