SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-8]

Umm...you said you got Watcher from him on N2. His actions confirm my steal on N3 - it is your steal on N2 that doesn't line up.

I didn't say I got the watcher from him N2. I did get the watcher from him N2. Not really sure you know where you are going with this...

[Mafia-2]

I believe Mr. Kook is referring to your information on Witch Doctor which clearly states that WD lost his watcher role on Night 3, not Night 2 (as you have claimed several times).

[Mafia-7]

Umm...you said you got Watcher from him on N2. His actions confirm my steal on N3 - it is your steal on N2 that doesn't line up.

 

Creating a narrative like that doesn't seem very pro-town to me.

 

 

Peeps - sorry to be late - the storefront to my business was broken into last night, and I still have a good bit of work to have glass replaced and get things back up and running. I'll be able to update this afternoon, but I wanted to check in while i had a minute. Realistically, we're looking at 4 or 5 EST before I can update, so smoke 'em if ya got 'em. 

 

Sucks.  Hopefully everything is put back to order quickly.

[Mafia-21]

 

I mean you weren't forthcoming with the info as to who was running the suit until you got pressure.

So? Was there a reason I should have been?

 

 

Umm...you said you got Watcher from him on N2.  His actions confirm my steal on N3 - it is your steal on N2 that doesn't line up.

 

I hate to break this to you but he had one of his accounts flip town and you haven't.

 

 

Thanks, genius.  Still appears that his N2 info is the one not lining up.  Mine does.  Makes me think there is an error in there somewhere.  He had a Watcher role on N3 for me to steal.  Can't really break it down much simpler than that.

 

 

 

 

 

I didn't say I got the watcher from him N2. I did get the watcher from him N2. Not really sure you know where you are going with this...

 

 

Then he is lying about his actions.  He confirmed my N3.  So either we are BOTH scum, or he is lying (or your info is somehow tainted).

 

 

 

 

 

Umm...you said you got Watcher from him on N2. His actions confirm my steal on N3 - it is your steal on N2 that doesn't line up.

 

Creating a narrative like that doesn't seem very pro-town to me.

 

 

Your face isn't very pro-town.

[Mafia-17]

 

 

What makes you say that?  Do you know how many empty costumes there are?

24 players signed up, there's 27 players on the list. That should mean there's 3 suits, two have been discovered already. Get it? 

 

 

 

 

I would guess Zombie is the suit though. If he is mafia with his "other" account, it would make sense to let the suit let the talking about the suit. And he wasn't very willing to tell us who his other account was. 

 

 

Yeah... Nope.

 

 

Found this for Space Kook since I know he's lazy and won't have done it himself.

[Mafia-21]

Damn right.  So maybe 4 suits.  Still puts you at 50%.  5 suits?  33% at a minimum.  Both odds I'd gladly take in lynching you.

[Mafia-3]

So once again, we return to the question I asked but you artfully dodged.  Why shouldn't we have left you in the trap?

[Mafia-10]

We should have left him in the trap.

[Mafia-10]

The arguments of his actions adding up vs Mantis' actions don't is ridiculous.

 

We know that Mantis is telling the truth. That means at least one of WD and KOOK lying. Possibly both.

 

Just cook them both tomorrow.

[Mafia-7]

 

Your face isn't very pro-town.

 

 

You're only saying that because it is translucent.

[Mafia-9]

I agree that something is off. I find it somewhat suspicious that most of Witch Doctor's night actions are holstering. It's an easy way to stay under the rader and avoid contradictions in case he's fibbing. Are we going to be seeing Kook's night actions as well or are you only going to reveal them come day break?  It's kind of hard to debate this with only half of the information out there.

[Mafia-11]

I´m sorry to hear that, DPR. I hope everything will be alright.

[Mafia-2]

I agree that something is off. I find it somewhat suspicious that most of Witch Doctor's night actions are holstering. It's an easy way to stay under the rader and avoid contradictions in case he's fibbing. Are we going to be seeing Kook's night actions as well or are you only going to reveal them come day break?  It's kind of hard to debate this with only half of the information out there.

 

FOS at you, Kitten.

 

 

You talk about staying under the radar, but WD hasn't exactly been under any radar, he's been consistently brought up as a good lynch candidate and doesn't appear to particularly care about what goes on in this game at all.  I'd call him more absentee than lurking.

[Mafia-9]

I'm not referring to his activity level on thread. I'm referring to the night actions he sent to Wax and Mantis. An easy way to avoid them finding inconsistencies is claiming that he holstered. If his night activity was more diverse then we'd have more to work with. 

[Mafia-10]

I agree that something is off. I find it somewhat suspicious that most of Witch Doctor's night actions are holstering. It's an easy way to stay under the rader and avoid contradictions in case he's fibbing. Are we going to be seeing Kook's night actions as well or are you only going to reveal them come day break?  It's kind of hard to debate this with only half of the information out there.

 

Hard, isn't it?

Sux to be scum. You're supposed to have all the information.

[Mafia-10]

KOOK can reveal sooner if he wishes to. In the meantime, why is it such a bad idea to argue without information?

[Mafia-10]

Warning. People may lie in maffia.

[Mafia-21]

So once again, we return to the question I asked but you artfully dodged.  Why shouldn't we have left you in the trap?

The arguments of his actions adding up vs Mantis' actions don't is ridiculous.

 

We know that Mantis is telling the truth. That means at least one of WD and KOOK lying. Possibly both.

 

Just cook them both tomorrow.

 

You dopes.  We gave info - WaxMantis "analyzed" it.  It appears that either myself or WD are lying (or the data is somehow wrong).  If a LLL is the answer, then it is town's best interests for me to fight and survive (as a townie) and have the LLL go down.  If there was no other way, I'd sacrifice myself.  But I see a way, if the data is correct - we lynch WD as potential scum. 

 

If he flips town, then I'm dead.  If that happens, we know there is an error in the data.  THAT will help town more than my town flip from the trap.  THAT only helps scum.  I'd rather stay alive and fight/play as an active contributor to the game.  How about WD?

[Mafia-8]

So either we are BOTH scum, or he is lying (or your info is somehow tainted).

Care to elaborate?  I don't see how anything can be tainted here.

 

Mantis stole WD's Watcher role on N2.

WD claims to have holstered N2 and N3.

You claim you stole Watcher from WD on N3.

WD claims he had his Watcher stolen on N3.

 

Don't see how my info got "tainted" there.  Are you lying to us about your night actions?

[Mafia-10]

KOOK, if we left you in the trap, then you'd be dead now:

 

a) you flipped scum, wel, then just a step closer to eliminating the maffia team

b) you flipped town, then WD would be a sure lynch

 

that's surely better than the situation now, isn't it - even in the case you're town

[Mafia-21]

 

So either we are BOTH scum, or he is lying (or your info is somehow tainted).

Care to elaborate?  I don't see how anything can be tainted here.

 

Mantis stole WD's Watcher role on N2.

WD claims to have holstered N2 and N3.

You claim you stole Watcher from WD on N3.

WD claims he had his Watcher stolen on N3.

 

Don't see how my info got "tainted" there.  Are you lying to us about your night actions?

 

 

*sigh*

 

Listen, I know that I'm telling the truth.  You don't.  Based on this, I know WD had a Watcher role for me to steal on N3.  How you were able to steal on N2 and then me on N3 when he says he did nothing in between doesn't make sense.  He is either lying or the data is somehow flawed.  Why is this not sinking in?

 

 

 

 

KOOK, if we left you in the trap, then you'd be dead now:

 

a) you flipped scum, wel, then just a step closer to eliminating the maffia team

b) you flipped town, then WD would be a sure lynch

 

that's surely better than the situation now, isn't it - even in the case you're town

 

Wrong.  In your scenario, we lose 1 scum and 1 townie.  In mine, we are hopefully losing 0 townies.  If either WD or myself are lying, it is WD and we don't lose a townie at all.  Surely you can see how my scenario is more favorable to the town?

[Mafia-17]

I think we've done all we can without more info from Witch Doc or DPR. You guys are arguing from PoV info asymmetry right now which is useless.

 

We should probably lynch Witch Doc first anyways. It looks to me like he definitely submitted incorrect info. Whether or not Space Kook did can be figured out later.

[Mafia-8]

*sigh*

 

Listen, I know that I'm telling the truth.  You don't.  Based on this, I know WD had a Watcher role for me to steal on N3.  How you were able to steal on N2 and then me on N3 when he says he did nothing in between doesn't make sense.  He is either lying or the data is somehow flawed.  Why is this not sinking in?

 Again with the accusation that my data is "somehow flawed."  I guess it it's possible your theory isn't "sinking in" because it doesn't make any sort of logical sense?

 

I did steal the role N2.  Of that fact there is no dispute. 

You claimed you stole the role N3.  Of that fact there is no dispute. 

WD claims the role was stolen N3.  Of that fact there is no dispute. 

WD claims he holstered Nights 2 and 3.  Of that fact there is no dispute.

 

The data is good.  There is no room for error.  You are flailing.

[Mafia-9]

KOOK can reveal sooner if he wishes to. In the meantime, why is it such a bad idea to argue without information?

 

lol Really?

 

Then why share WD's night actions? If you want actual educated input, as opposed to just standing there and listening to yourself talk, then you need to give us the full picture. Otherwise don't act surprised when all you get is people shooting out of their arse.

[Mafia-17]

Space Kook's continued dodging should be noted though.

 

Why don't you just get it over with and admit that your "scum in the trap" argument sucked?