SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-10]

All files should be updated. Please check yours if I got everythign right. Would be nice if you managed to do that before night ends. Thanks.

[Mafia-6]

sorry guys im only here for like 5 seconds. have had some RL dramas happen. I should be able to get here tomorrow night

[Mafia-16]

*taps nails on the desk and pulls a face*

[Mafia-10]

OKAY so on the low chance we die:

 

- you can use the given txt links to claim (that ensures it is your claim has been sent to me)

- in case someone gets very creative, this is a checker program for whether a link is one of the links I've given you guys, or a fake:

 

http://maffiacs.asphostpage.net/MaffiaCS.asp

 

I didn't put too much work into writing this so the layout is very basic. You just copy your link into the form, press submit and if you get "OK", then it's one of the links I've given out.

 

If not, it isn't. This ensures that no one can "cheat" by creating an own txt on dropbox and link it instead of mine. In other words, everyone has to claim with his "blind claim to me". No takebacks :)

 

In case you are on the suspicious side. ASP is just like regular html. It runs on the HOSTING server (so it never does anything on your own computer). This one just takes your link and displays if it's okay.

[Mafia-10]

Full Claims:

 

 

 

1 index 10

2 PlayerName WEREWOLF mafia

3 index 10

4 Role#1 Cop

5 Role#2 Stealing

6 Action-N1 Cop

7 Target-N1 TAR MOnSTER

8 Results-N1 Town

9 Suffer-N1 0

10 Action-N2 Steal

11 Target-N2 DR. COFFIN

12 Results-N2 Magis

13 Suffer-N2 0

14 Action-N3 DEAD

15 Target-N3 DEAD

16 Results-N3 DEAD

17 Suffer-N3 0

18 Action-N3 DEAD

 

 

 

 

 

1 index 20

2 PlayerName MANTIS mafia

3 index 20

4 Role#1 0

5 Role#2 Stealing

6 Action-N1 N/A

7 Target-N1 N/A

8 Results-N1 N/A

9 Suffer-N1 0

10 Action-N2 Steal

11 Target-N2 WICTH DOCTOR

12 Results-N2 Watcher

13 Suffer-N2 0

14 Action-N3 0

15 Target-N3 0

16 Results-N3 0

 

 

 

 

 

1 index 18

2 PlayerName WAX PHANTOM mafia

3 index 18

4 Role#1 NONE

5 Role#2 Stealing

6 Action-N1 N/A

7 Target-N1 N/A

8 Results-N1 N/A

9 Suffer-N1 0

10 Action-N2 Steal

11 Target-N2 DEMON SHARK

12 Results-N2 nothing

13 Suffer-N2 0

14 Action-N3 Steal

15 Target-N3 CAT CREATURE

16 Results-N3 nothing

17 Suffer-N3 0

 

 

 

 

 

1 index 23

2 PlayerName JAGUARO mafia

3 index 23

4 Role#1 Cop

5 Role#2 Stealing

6 Action-N1 steal

7 Target-N1 BLACK KNIGHT

8 Results-N1 empty

9 Suffer-N1 lost Cop (CREEPER?)

10 Action-N2 Steal

11 Target-N2 CHARLIE ROBOT

12 Results-N2 empty

13 Suffer-N2 0

14 Action-N3 DEAD

15 Target-N3 DEAD

16 Results-N3 DEAD

17 Suffer-N3 0

 

 

 

I'll full claim ourselves (until D3/N3) in case we die.

 

If we die, ask WITCH DOCTOR and SPACE KOOK to post their fullclaim txt, if they refuse, just lynch them. One of those two is maffia.

[Mafia-21]

QQ MOAR

 

Dude, I'd add you to the PM string, but I won't subject you to that....even if you were scum.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Just for the record:

 

Space Kook and Creepy Heap are likely going to be tomorrow's lynches - plural - given the information we have currently.

 

Please send in your night actions ASAP. Cases will be presented upon daybreak.

This is awful. You can't analyze data for your life, as I said in PM. I stole something. I'm pretty sure mafia can't steal. You can confirm that WD says I stole from him. I stole N3. If he didn't start with a Watcher, he acquired one prior to my N3 steal. Maybe he grabbed it that same night? Dunno.

 

My point: you are accusing me with incomplete information, and all it does is make you look silly. All this junk about "near 100%" and "almost positive" is just icing on the cake. You will try to lynch me tomorrow. You might be successful based on being a confirmed townie. You'll also go down in flames the next day as the worst data analyzing townie in the history of DM mafia.

 

Most. Misguided. Townie. Ever. Damn, son....you're waaayyyyy better as scum. Sit down before you hurt yourself.

 

You're sure that maffia can't steal? How can you be sure of such a thing? I'd really like to know that.

 

For the record, if

 

A claims to have stolen from B on Night X and

B claims that he was stolen from on Night X

 

that doesn't vet either of the players. Maybe A is lying (and knows that someone else did the stealing). Maybe both are lying. Maybe both are telling the truth.

 

This isn't the case here btw. It's just an example. I don't think night is the best time for discussing clears and claims.

We'll get to this on the morning.

 

 

Feeling more comfortable with Tar/Zombie based on tonight's posts.

 

I very much agree that it's anti-town to refuse to cooperate with Wax and Mantis here. Space Kook and Demon Shark, how about you answer the question I posed during Charlie's lynch.

 

Regardless of whether you think Wax and Mantis are particularly competent, what's the worst case scenario that you think is going to happen by having them collect and compare the night actions?

Holy crap, THEY HAVE MY ACTIONS. I'M NOT WITHHOLDING.

 

CREEPER, you're confusing things. DEMON SHARK does have his actions unsent yet and pushes the agenda of not sharing information.

I can confirm that KOOK has sent us his actions (and we never claimed not to have KOOK's actions). I can also confirm that he told us not to give us his actions unless he gets released.

 

 

 

BikiniWax, I'm pretty sure scum can't steal.  I asked DPR who else had a permanent steal like me, and his response was 'about 21ish other people'.  Scum probably can't steal.  Why would they?  They want to catch people stealing - it fits the flavor of the game, too.

[Mafia-21]

 

If we die, ask WITCH DOCTOR and SPACE KOOK to post their fullclaim txt, if they refuse, just lynch them. One of those two is maffia.

 

 

No offense, but you could easily be making an error in analyzing the data.  Before you even THINK about starting a train on either WD or I, you had better submit all info on this thread, along with your analysis and hypothesis.

 

If the data makes sense, I'll vote WD with a quickness.

[Mafia-10]

If I live, I'll post the analysis.

 

If I die, just have them fullclaim both and you'll see the contradiction yourself.

[Mafia-10]

Where does this BIKINI thing come from? Do I have a new name now? Wasn't Salami good enough?

[Mafia-10]

BTW we do have more contradictions, they'll be posted in due time.

[Mafia-13]

Where does this BIKINI thing come from? Do I have a new name now? Wasn't Salami good enough?

 

ROFL

[Mafia-21]

Where does this BIKINI thing come from? Do I have a new name now? Wasn't Salami good enough?

 

Did the joke sail over your head?

 

 

 

BTW we do have more contradictions, they'll be posted in due time.

 

Not good.  If you don't have results from people by now, you're not getting them.  You need to get ALL contradictions out on thread.  If you two die, all you do is get WD or I strung up.....but what about others that you might have found?  They slither on?

 

You need to post the contradictions.

[Mafia-10]

I understood nothing of that joke, yes.

[Mafia-13]

I understood nothing of that joke, yes.

 

You are made of wax, he's calling you a specific type of wax: bikini wax.

[Mafia-10]

Alright. I understand what that might be, but I don't know the expression. English is not my first language.

[Mafia-17]

27 accounts in the game.

4+ suits in the game.

That means max 23 people in the game or max 22 people besides yourself.

See what I'm getting at here?

 

This is why you don't game Wes. Even when he's not a bastard he's a bastard. <3 Wes.

[Mafia-21]

You know what a bikini is, right?  Please don't say no.....

[Mafia-21]

27 accounts in the game.

4+ suits in the game.

That means max 23 people in the game or max 22 people besides yourself.

See what I'm getting at here?

 

This is why you don't game Wes. Even when he's not a bastard he's a bastard. <3 Wes.

 

If your suit # is correct then yes, I guess scum could have stealing abilities based on what Wes said to me.  But the tone of his PM suggested the entire town has it.  It just doesn't fit the game to have scum stealing - they set traps to catch stealing....which the town does.  It makes sense.  Don't ignore this logic.

 

I'm not saying we should charge blindly down this path.  I've already said my theory might suck.

 

What do you think about the fact that you're a confirmed suit player and we know at least one is controlled by scum, and that we've already flipped 2 as town?  Mmm?

[Mafia-10]

I'm pretty sure that all suits can steal. They must have been made equal. 

 

As for the contradiction: KOOK claims that he has stolen a watcher from WD on night 3.

MANTIS stole a watcher from WD on N2.

 

WD claims that he has had his (singular!) watcher stolen.

[Mafia-21]

Easy answer then:  WD, what did you do on N2 and N3?

 

 

 

If all suits can steal, then we are farther away from catching scum than I hoped.

[Mafia-17]

I think that Wes already shot down that line of reasoning when he confirmed that there is at least one other suit besides me in this game.

 

All else being equal, assuming there are less than 4 suits remaining, I am more likely than your average player to be scum. But all else isn't equal. The other suit players are hiding. I'm not. And I have played a pro-town game.

 

And before you come in with the clean = scummy thing, I said pro-town, not clean. Gotta get yer hands all tarry if yeh wanna find scum.

[Mafia-13]

I think that Wes already shot down that line of reasoning when he confirmed that there is at least one other suit besides me in this game.

 

All else being equal, assuming there are less than 4 suits remaining, I am more likely than your average player to be scum. But all else isn't equal. The other suit players are hiding. I'm not. And I have played a pro-town game.

 

And before you come in with the clean = scummy thing, I said pro-town, not clean. Gotta get yer hands all tarry if yeh wanna find scum.

 

I am not touching your lump of goo.

[Mafia-21]

I think that Wes already shot down that line of reasoning when he confirmed that there is at least one other suit besides me in this game.

 

All else being equal, assuming there are less than 4 suits remaining, I am more likely than your average player to be scum. But all else isn't equal. The other suit players are hiding. I'm not. And I have played a pro-town game.

 

And before you come in with the clean = scummy thing, I said pro-town, not clean. Gotta get yer hands all tarry if yeh wanna find scum.

 

He confirmed more than just you left?  Quote?

 

And if 2, then you are 50% chance at being scum.  Still better odds than any other potential lynch at this time.

[Mafia-13]

And Tar, you were hiding behind your suit until it started to get run up yesterday, so you really weren't out in the open until you started to get pressure.

[Mafia-21]

Witch Doctor = 6 posts

Skeleton = 11 posts

Cat Creature = 13 posts

Elias Kingston = 15 posts

Capt. Cutler = 16 posts

 

88 pages in, and N4 right now.  We need more, folks.  WD, especially you - you are at the center of debate alongside myself, and I can do nothing to clear or condemn either of us until you help out.