SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[PTERODACTYL mafia]

I gotta wonder about the utility of the traps. If mafia controlled who they were set on during the night, then mafia would never get trapped in them. Likewise, if the trap only goes for people visiting the selected target there's still no way scum would be in the trap (unless they wanted to get themselves stuck in the trap on purpose, but that's a dangerous gambit to run).

[PTERODACTYL mafia]

Also, Demon Shark, I'm town. So I don't understand you keep poking at lynching me calling me "known scum" when you aren't even voting for me.

[CHARLIE ROBOT mafia]

Pitiful.

 

Do any of you have a case and reasoning or am I supposed to say "No i'm not!" Everytime someone calls me mafia?

 

Is that how this works?

[Mafia-11]

Vote release DR. Coffin

 

 

Charlie - I just read the case on you and I thought it was interesting that you said that if someone is viewed town then they are town considering that you had a mirror. I´m willing to vote for you.

[Mafia-10]

I'm not sure why Space Kook is all of a sudden up in business.  Good lord, you get bear trapped and suddenly you're Kook the Messiah.

 

 

As for this ChArLiE lynch - why is everybody wasting their time on this poor soul when pTeRo is known scum?

 

 

And several other things:

 

1) Where the dump is The Black Knight?

 

2) Ever wonder why Wax Phantom is so adamant about not holstering?  Sure he tries to make a good point out of it, but if using actions is the only way for scum to catch us innocents, and Waxface wants us to use them instead of holstering.....What's he worried about, having to scum hunt the ol' fashioned way instead of using all these sophisticated gadgets and doodads?

 

3) I look good, really good, in a deep vee

 

4) Mantis, what if I want to visit for tea?

Where the dump is your full role/action claim? You've posted at least 3 times today. Sure you can send your actions at the same time.

[Mafia-2]

Don't half-arse a vote, jump in them waters mate.

[Mafia-10]

Pitiful.

 

Do any of you have a case and reasoning or am I supposed to say "No i'm not!" Everytime someone calls me mafia?

 

Is that how this works?

You send me all your night actions in PM and we'll see how it works. Or you die.

[Mafia-10]

We have found at least one LLL. But not sure yet who. Stay tuned.

[Mafia-10]

DR COFFIN sent his actions. At the moment we have no reason to believe him lying. We can't be sure that he is town either.

 

It is likely that he has started the game with a magistrate role.

[Mafia-2]

 

Pitiful.

 

Do any of you have a case and reasoning or am I supposed to say "No i'm not!" Everytime someone calls me mafia?

 

Is that how this works?

You send me all your night actions in PM and we'll see how it works. Or you die.

 

 

Power-trip much?

[Mafia-10]

Not really.

 

We are cross-checking actions to determine who the scum might be. CHARLIE ROBOT refuses to claim his actions (CHARLIE, oyu can even claim in public now, but still better in PM).

Town has nothing to be afraid of or nothing to lose here, only scum.

 

Are you scum?

 

ALSO, he is at L-3 and likely lynch target. People usually claim in that position so that town might confirm them in any normal case.

[Mafia-10]

Also, how is PTERO known scum? Did you view him or smth?

[Mafia-2]

This is boring.  Where is everyone?

[Mafia-10]

This is boring.  Where is everyone?

Why are you refusing to send your actions to the confirmed townies?

Why do you refuse to clarify your PTERO claims?

[PTERODACTYL mafia]

Mr. Shark, you have 18 total posts. Calling out others for not being here doesn't make sense.

[Mafia-2]

Thank you Mr. Dactyl.  Your respect does wonders for my critical view on the younger generation.

 

 

 

And look at that, I have 19.  I'm moving up in my old age.

[Mafia-10]

Thank you Mr. Dactyl.  Your respect does wonders for my critical view on the younger generation.

 

And look at that, I have 19.  I'm moving up in my old age.

Why are you refusing to send your actions to the confirmed townies?

Why do you refuse to clarify your PTERO claims?

[Mafia-21]

I didn't say it for you.  I said it for everyone else.  Because a bunch of people didn't vote me to be released but voted you so it would make sense if they were your scum mates.

 

I see.  Good luck with that.

 

 

 

 

 

You send me all your night actions in PM and we'll see how it works. Or you die.

 

 

Power-trip much?

 

Not really.

 

BikiniSalamiWax, chillax.  You are power-tripping, lol.  Just sit back and enjoy.

 

Look at your alt.  Now back to mine.  Now back at yours.  Quick!  Now back to mine.  Sadly, you aren't me, but if you stopped posting like a crankypants and switched to being cool, you could be more like me.

[Mafia-17]

 

 

I'm L-1 on getting released from this trap.  Witch Doctor has confirmed that I stole a 1x Watcher role last night.  Please hammer my release.

 

That means nothing to me as I don't see Witch Dr as being particularly town. 

 

Vote Release Kook

Vote Release Coffin

 

 

You think mafia are stealing from people?  I don't.  If somebody confirms a steal, that goes a long way (to me) towards confirming they are town.

 

Mafia are getting people "caught" stealing.  A successful steal and confirmation could very likely be the same as a Cop viewing in this game.

 

 

Ok, here's my theory now that I'm out of the trap:  If we holster, mafia can't catch anybody stealing.  If we call our shots and use the trackers/watchers accordingly, we can catch scum trying to get us caught.

 

Example:

 

Player A steals from Player B.  Scum probably target one of them to "catch aka NK".  If a watcher watches Player A and B, and a tracker tracks A, we can probably identify if scum try to get somebody caught.  If we have people firing willy-nilly in every direction, there will be enough confusion for scum to kill/catch people without detection.  If we coordinate, we should be good.

 

Meanwhile, we need to get mirrors out of the game.  Get them used up, or all in the hands of certain players.  This way we can reasonably trust Cop views.

 

Is this plan crap?  Maybe.  But it is a plan, and I've yet to see one I think is better.

 

 

 

 

 

 

DR. COFFIN (7) - Wax, Zombie, Charlie, Creeper, Witch, Tar, Cat

 

SPACE KOOK (11)  - Wax, Hyde, Kook, Zombie, Creepy Heap, Cutler, Charlie, Creeper, Witch, Tar, Cat

 

It takes 12 votes each to release Dr. Coffin and Space Kook.

 

Why the difference between Coffin and Kook?  Hyde, Kook, and Creepy Heap, I'm lookin' at you.  Why exactly would you vote to release one and not the other? 

 

 

I know my alignment, so I voted for myself.  I don't know Coffin's.  What is hard to understand about that?

 

 

 

Also, the only way we can continue to scumhunt in my theory is if we unlock the van.  Fred most likely has the keys.  We need to find him, and lynch him.  Of all the scum likely to have an extra suit, it would be Fred.

 

Therefore, I'm really thinking we might want to look into a Tar Monster lynch.  He's confirming a 2nd suit.  We know scum has one.  We know 2 people flipped town.  Are there more than 3, and Tar is town as well?  Maybe....but wouldn't we want THREE confirmed town in that case?

 

Damn.  Should've left this guy in the trap.

[Mafia-21]

Careful, we still haven't decided whether to test the alignment of you and your little Zombie yet.

[Mafia-21]

Also, your FACE.

[Mafia-10]

Careful, we still haven't decided whether to test the alignment of you and your little Zombie yet.

We have.

No test yet.

[Mafia-17]

 

 

I dont' think mafia are stealing from people.  But it wouldn't be hard for you and Witch to both be mafia and claim stealing to "validate" both of you. 

 

As for your plan, at least the idea of a watcher seems reasonable. 

 

 

We literally have no idea how to properly scumhunt yet.  You think scum would put themselves out there like that when town is this confused?  I don't.

 

 

REALLY?

[Mafia-2]

 

Thank you Mr. Dactyl.  Your respect does wonders for my critical view on the younger generation.
 
And look at that, I have 19.  I'm moving up in my old age.

Why are you refusing to send your actions to the confirmed townies?
Why do you refuse to clarify your PTERO claims?

 

Ah, Wax-on, you do persist.

 

 

 

I wish you would Wax-off, but since you seem committed to bothering me...

 

 

 

Mr. Dactyl has played, in my opinion, a scummy game of scumminess.  It is known.

 

 

As to the former, I have this to say:

 

 

You have given me no reason to trust you.  You and Mantis played a terrible game, were lynched, and now you want everyone to send you all their info so that you and Mantis can piece it together.  I'd rather not have you and Mantis running the show.  I don't care that you two claim to be the "only confirmed town," you've given me no reason to believe that you and your partner in crime are competent enough to look at the information, let alone sort through it and lead the town with your tweedle dee, tweedle dum routine that you have going on.  I play my cards close to the chest, especially in a DPR game, and if you can't deal with that then you better start preparing for the incoming apoplexia.

[Mafia-21]

 

Careful, we still haven't decided whether to test the alignment of you and your little Zombie yet.

We have.

No test yet.

 

 

"We" would be you and Mantis.

 

The "We" I refer to is the rest of the town.  What's better than 2 confirmed townies?  Three.  At some point, one of these suits will be controlled by scum.  There are only so many double-alts in the game.  Chance are reasonable that Tar Monster is scum based on that.

 

I'm cool with the Charlie train today, but we should be really thinking about validating Tar/Zombie tomorrow.