SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-2]

I think calling out usage of abilities on people is wise.

 

Also, we need to lynch the scum holding the keys to the mystery van.  My guess is Fred - lynch him, and the town can get a new slew of roles handed out.

 

Ye have my thanks.

 

unvote, vote Major Tom

[Mafia-21]

 

I think calling out usage of abilities on people is wise.

 

Also, we need to lynch the scum holding the keys to the mystery van.  My guess is Fred - lynch him, and the town can get a new slew of roles handed out.

 

The funny thing about lynching is that sometimes it helps to vote.  Jus' saying.

 

 

 *cough*

 

Vote: Black Knight

 

Not sure on 2nd lynch yet.

[Mafia-21]

 

I think calling out usage of abilities on people is wise.

 

Also, we need to lynch the scum holding the keys to the mystery van.  My guess is Fred - lynch him, and the town can get a new slew of roles handed out.

 

Ye have my thanks.

 

unvote, vote Major Tom

 

 

??

[Mafia-5]

Can I use both of my votes on Space Kook?

[Mafia-21]

No, you're dead.  And why?

[Mafia-7]

 

 

I think calling out usage of abilities on people is wise.

 

Also, we need to lynch the scum holding the keys to the mystery van.  My guess is Fred - lynch him, and the town can get a new slew of roles handed out.

 

The funny thing about lynching is that sometimes it helps to vote.  Jus' saying.

 

 

 *cough*

 

Vote: Black Knight

 

Not sure on 2nd lynch yet.

 

 

Missed that as I only checked DPR's last VC.

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

Well, if they aren't flipping me early, I'm voting for scum.

 

 

 

Unvote all

 

Vote Zombie

Vote Cutler

You've got one vote since we lynched you already.

[Mafia-18]

OKAY, so MANTIS should be unvoted. As soon as JAgs flip, he'll be confirmed either way so lynching him makes no sense.

 

I'm fine with keeping pressure on Witch Doctor (even though he's just been replaced). We need another train, however.

 

Creepy Heap, MR HYDE, Demonshark

[Mafia-18]

Evereyone got one vote now, the other is fixed on the first lynch, by my understanding.

[PTERODACTYL mafia]

Unvote

[Mafia-18]

Just an idea. I'm not sure if revealing our night actions is a good idea, as long as we're missing some crucial points about how the game mechanics work, there's too much chance of helping scum without meaning to. But it migth be a good idea to record our results somehow, somewhere.

 

Problem is, there's no one we can trust.

 

I don't believe that not stealing would help us.

[Mafia-21]

Just an idea. I'm not sure if revealing our night actions is a good idea, as long as we're missing some crucial points about how the game mechanics work, there's too much chance of helping scum without meaning to. But it migth be a good idea to record our results somehow, somewhere.

 

Problem is, there's no one we can trust.

 

I don't believe that not stealing would help us.

 

If Jags flips town, we can trust Mantis.  If he holsters all actions and serves as a conduit of information, that might work.  Or it might blow up in our faces.  I'm ready!

[Mafia-2]

OKAY, so MANTIS should be unvoted. As soon as JAgs flip, he'll be confirmed either way so lynching him makes no sense.

 

I'm fine with keeping pressure on Witch Doctor (even though he's just been replaced). We need another train, however.

 

Creepy Heap, MR HYDE, Demonshark

 

What's your read against Hyde?

[Mafia-1]

Unvote, vote Capt. Cutler

 

I'd like to here from the new WITCH before voting there.  I am also okay with switching my vote to CREEPY HEAP or DEMON SHARK

[CHARLIE ROBOT mafia]

Space cook = Verbal

[Mafia-8]

You can PM all of your previous night actions to me once my alignment is confirmed. 

[Mafia-18]

 

Just an idea. I'm not sure if revealing our night actions is a good idea, as long as we're missing some crucial points about how the game mechanics work, there's too much chance of helping scum without meaning to. But it migth be a good idea to record our results somehow, somewhere.

 

Problem is, there's no one we can trust.

 

I don't believe that not stealing would help us.

 

If Jags flips town, we can trust Mantis.  If he holsters all actions and serves as a conduit of information, that might work.  Or it might blow up in our faces.  I'm ready!

 

Nah, I don't think holstering actions help.

[Mafia-18]

 

OKAY, so MANTIS should be unvoted. As soon as JAgs flip, he'll be confirmed either way so lynching him makes no sense.

 

I'm fine with keeping pressure on Witch Doctor (even though he's just been replaced). We need another train, however.

 

Creepy Heap, MR HYDE, Demonshark

 

What's your read against Hyde?

 

Nothing strong or tangible, just some scum vibes here and there. I need a re-read.

[Mafia-7]

 

 

 

I don't believe that not stealing would help us.

 

 

Nah, I don't think holstering actions help.

 

 

Why do you say this?

[Mafia-18]

Why do you say this?

Because I don't believe that scum can only catch people who are using a Night Action. That doesn't make sense as a game mechanic. There must be much more.

[Mafia-7]

 

 

Because I don't believe that scum can only catch people who are using a Night Action. That doesn't make sense as a game mechanic. There must be much more.

 

 

But do you think that scum can catch people who are out stealing?

[Mafia-18]

 

Because I don't believe that scum can only catch people who are using a Night Action. That doesn't make sense as a game mechanic. There must be much more.

 

But do you think that scum can catch people who are out stealing?

 

Not a clue. I think we need more information. I believe that the game has a lot of players for a good reason: enough days to find the right pattern.

 

Summary of actions and summary of mod confirmations/hints is badly needed for sure.

[Mafia-2]

 

 

There was a ton of resistance to the Black Knight lynch for no good reason even before his reveal. Tracker makes perfect sense as a role for the gang to have thematically speaking. It's not a very powerful in the hands of town and it just blows my mind that we weren't able to secure the lynch on him.

 

 

 

There was a ton of resistance to the Black Knight lynch for no good reason even before his reveal. Tracker makes perfect sense as a role for the gang to have thematically speaking. It's not a very powerful in the hands of town and it just blows my mind that we weren't able to secure the lynch on him.

 

What's this game-related talk?  Get out of here, yo!

 

 

Fluff

 

 

 

 

SPACE COOK > SPACE KOOK

/realtalk

 

I definitely know who you are now.

 

 

Is that a tracker claim in the middle of the night?

 

 

Really?  You're fishing on that one?  I know who is behind the alt (I think I do)....I have no clue about his role.  That much should have been obvious.  I'll break it down a little further for you in the future, though.

 

 

I think Kook was the only one who actually thought Werewolf might be fishing.  More than likely just trying to throw a fake 2cents into the mix.  Terrible.

 

Vote Black Knight

 

He's a  lying sack of scum.

 

Here begins his "plan" to out TBK

 

 

I'm assuming that steal ability is for roles. Unless someone randomly has a steal ability as well and stole it successfully or Mr. Jaguar here was blocked for some reason, it seems to me that Black Knight is lying. My reasoning is the stalled out lynch yesterday.

 

I'm interested in what Knight has to say about all of this though.

 

Interesting.

 

1) You called Black Knight a liar before Jaguaro told us about his steal attempt.

2) If there is someone else out there with stealing ability, well, Black Knight would be a likely target.

3) There are more ways for a NA to fail: JAGUARO - what were you told exactly?

 

 

Wolf makes a good point about Ptero's series of actions.  So continues his "plan."

 

 

Vote Black Knight

 

He's a  lying sack of scum.

 

I'm assuming that steal ability is for roles. Unless someone randomly has a steal ability as well and stole it successfully or Mr. Jaguar here was blocked for some reason, it seems to me that Black Knight is lying. My reasoning is the stalled out lynch yesterday.

 

I'm interested in what Knight has to say about all of this though.

 

Which one is it now?

 

 

Making a big leap that TBK is scum and trying to lead the town on a wild lynch chase resulting in the lynch of the one claimed pr at the time.  Hey Ptero, why don't you quit trying to lead the town with circumstantial evidence?

 

Why not both?

 

Tries to make light of the fact that he's called TBK out for two completely different and unrelated reasons.  His wording is completely off - his reasoning for TBK lying is because the lynch stalled yesterday?  He had just said it was because he stole nothing.  If he stole nothing and believed TBK to be scum, it would be because he claimed tracker, not because of a stalled lynch.

 

Well. Seems everyone is confused then. Also seems plausible that there are many more stealing roles than I expected. In any case, I think Jag played it poorly by announcing what he did. Should have kept that crap secret like I was trying to do to see if Black Knight would have mentioned being stolen from. Once everyone checks in, we will know if anybody stole from Knight or not.

 

More like you're trying to use mass confusion as a cover to hide your own confused scrambling.

 

 

I asked you a question, Pterowhatever. Why/what did you accuse Black Knight to lie about in the first place? 

It is both, by the way. It just so happens I too had a steal ability and got nothing from Black Knight. So yes, it is both. I believed he was a liar. The fact that Jag had the same result I did is just further proof for me.

 

I thought I answered that here, but I stole nothing from him despite my best efforts. If he had a role, I'd have it now.

 

 

I'm not sure why Ptero outright dismisses the idea that he and Jag were the only ones stealing from TBK.  TBK was probably targeted more than anyone else N1  The fact that Ptero tried to steal from him and came up empty is a terrible reason to believe that TBK was scum imo  It sounds like he just wanted to continue the lynch attempt from yesterday because he knows that TBK is town.  He doesn't even bother to address TBK's claim about having tracked the Mummy.

 

 

 

Hrm. Well, I suppose there aren't enough people checked in yet. I also suppose it is possible that mafia might have had stealing roles as well. Well this is akward, everyone using up their 1 time abilities on N1 on the same person.

 

Begins backpedaling. 

 

He later unvotes after the mod clarifies that actions in use cannot be stolen.

 

 

Fair points to me Phantom Pain.

 

Vote Mummy

 

Hops on the next convenient train.

 

 

Back to Space Kook (who's been silent for quite a few pages).

 

 

 

To be serious: if we are given a tool for scumhunting, we should be using it.

 

It can also be used for misdirection.  I'd rather have it on thread.

 

 

Game-related thematically, but does nothing.

 

 

Typically, a town JIF would be all over what I'm seeing from Ghost - yet you are more focused on reversing momentum to take me out, because I'm likely a threat to you. Got it. You stay in my top 3.

 

I'm pretty sure Tar Monster is not JiF.

 

 

Worthless.

 

 

HUGD FOS on everyone pushing the Silencer angle. If you had actually read the thread you would know that Mummy has posted once today. It was early on and about a stupid clown outfit and how it clashes or something.

 

This.  Mummy needs to confirm/deny.

 

Vote: Mummy

 

 

Parroting what everyone else had been saying.  Stating the obvious.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I can't figure it out, sorry guys.  Just hit the spoiler button to see the whole thing in order.

[Mafia-17]

unvote MANTIS, vote CUTLER

 

Jaguaro doesn't get lynched unless we get a second lynch so we really need to get that lynch.

[Mafia-18]

OK, I've changed my mind about HYDE, sounds quite townish. I realized why I found him scummy, quite embarassing. OMGUS ...

Mainly because he attacked me quite a few times. Which he was very right to do, this one pinged most:

 

Was Werewolf against the Black Knight lynch yesterday as well?

This one felt off:

 

I'm tired of all the lying in the thread, if you are town tell the freaking truth. On prinicple I want to vote for Jags and Mantis. I'm going to take a short time to think about that though. I think Elias should tell us who he stole the mirror from so we can test if that was originally a scum item.

Well, if you're tired of all the lying, you're playibng the wrong game (in general and in particular). But the Jags story got me confused as well. ade me wanna policy lynch, TBH.