[Basic] Operation Domination - Game Over - Mafia Wins

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

@Halima Both Masaana and Sammael are a good pick in my opinion. Marsh's slip, while intriguing, is not really enough for me to vote him. I'll case him when I get home in two hours and see if anything of interest comes up

that might change my mind.

 

But right now Masaana is the one more likely to get my vote. The only thing about her that made ne hesitate was a scum's votes on her. But since it can just be distancing it doesn't hold up really vs her scummy moves.

 

 

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

As an added note....Could you guys spend more time casing and less time flinging about votes with no apparent backing?

 

 

[Lanfear-Mafia]

I'm tired of the inactivity and it is more damning to me right now that some of the suspicious activity going on.

[Graendal-Mafia]

Belal, Graendal, Rahvin - thanks for nothing. Everybody else who didn't bother voting to secure the lynch - same.

 

Semirhage, I wouldn't be surprised if SH was told that he couldn't reveal his alignment. If he could, it would ruin the point of Red doing it. If he were mafia and able to reveal an alignment, the best play would have been to say 'go town!'

 

Cyndane, want to lynch Mesaana today?

 

As if it was not obvious why I didn't vote..

[Balthamel-Mafia]

VOTE BATH

Got a reason for that? Grendael, you too. Is there a particular reason you want me dead besides my own stupidity?

[Gabriel Kross]

VOTE BATH

Got a reason for that? Grendael, you too. Is there a particular reason you want me dead besides my own stupidity?

 

I cased you day 3 there buddy.

[Graendal-Mafia]

FML Red you can rep me if you want...

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

I cased you day 3 there buddy.

 

You couldn't speak on day 3. We couldn't make heads or tails from what you were trying to say aside from support of some stuff that other people said. Refering to that as casing is laughable at best. Considering the amount of time you spent talking throughout the game, I would have expected you to have loads to say after a whole game day of not being able to speak your mind. Instead you just cast your vote with a bogus casing claim? Why don't you elaborate a bit more about why you're casting your vote. humor us.

 

Also I apologize for not following through with the casing. I crashed when I got home. I'll do it later today.

[Graendal-Mafia]

I cased you day 3 there buddy.

 

You couldn't speak on day 3. We couldn't make heads or tails from what you were trying to say aside from support of some stuff that other people said. Refering to that as casing is laughable at best. Considering the amount of time you spent talking throughout the game, I would have expected you to have loads to say after a whole game day of not being able to speak your mind. Instead you just cast your vote with a bogus casing claim? Why don't you elaborate a bit more about why you're casting your vote. humor us.

 

Also I apologize for not following through with the casing. I crashed when I got home. I'll do it later today.

 

I also said why I put my vote on him when I did it. Did you not read my vote post?

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

As it happen I did read you 'reason'. Lets review.

 

Had there buddy did you not see that he was one of the 2 killed?

 

 

Also it was pretty obvious due to the fact that Demandred was night killed, the mafia team wouldn't have killed one of their own. The surprised act will not work especially since you botched it.

 

Vote Balthemel

 

So you voted him cause his comment on the beginning of day 4 seemed scummy? But his comment is recent and you say you've made this case on him on day 3. Lets see it. I mean hell if someone already cased him and isn't basing his vote on one remark then you'll save me the trouble of going through his posts. So please refer me to the ample reasons you offered for him being scummy.

 

[Graendal-Mafia]

That was added to my case on day 3

[Graendal-Mafia]

Ive given all the info I need, if you don't like it to bad, I'm not going to scum hunt for the inactives. I'll put my vote where it seems the most warranted and let that speak for itself, that way no one can parrot me and bandwagon. I'm forcing people to think for themselves.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

*laughs* Noted.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Though... why wouldn't you want people to bandwagon? This is a team play. You casting a vote on your own isn't going to get you anywhere. And commom sense would say that if you believe someone to be scum then you'd like to see him lynched and find out. You're using inactives to avoid providing something you claim you said on a day you couldnt speak lol

 

But I'm not going to keep derailing the thread with your usual banter. As previously said.... noted ;-)

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

Still feeling Graendal on this one. For all my reasons before plus their refusal to actually give a case on someone. I dont care if you dont want to repeat what you have supposedly said or if you say you dont want to scum hunt for the inactives, not helping us and not giving us the information we need to find the scum is hurting us more. Great job your making people think for them selves! Guess what? Its not helping us at this late in the game. We have, at most, maybe 2 mafia still alive. We are ahead by a fair margin. No reason to withhold things like that.

 

vote Graendal... again

[Red2111]

Deadline

 

Thursday 3pm CST

 

 

Vote Count

 

Balth (2): Graendal, Aginor

Belal (1): Lanny

Graendal (1): Mesaana

 

No Vote: Belal, Rahvin, Cyndane, Semi, Mordeth, Balth, Halima, Sammy

 

 

 

Roll Call Challenge. due to inactivity i'm inacting a DPResque rule. Votes are now to be in the color green and in italics. Votes up to this VC will count as normal.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Ok, here's Balthy's casing. I quoted when I thought it was needed... otherwise not so much. I know it's a little long but it's the best I could do.

 

He comes across some technical problems and only posts 5 days after checking in. And when he does, he votes SH and also says that Moridin looks scummy. He backs off his FOS on Moridin when Moridin claims doc. He keeps using meta to claim that SH is being scummy and acting the same he did in a previous game they both played together. He also says that age is no excuse for SH/Rand’s flailing and uses EP as an example for a teenager LOL (Graen sets him straight!). Halima shows up with her counterclaim and Balthamel removes his vote from SH and places it on Moridin.

 

And Demandred is definitely on the radar for tomorrow. I can leave Mr. Haran for day three.

 

Balthy then goes on a vacation and only posts again 6 days later. He starts catching up. He agrees with Asmodean that Graendal pings like crazy. He then places his vote on Ishy and promises he’ll have a lot more online time once school starts up.

 

Dashiva's death was probably the mafia kill, and Demandred was probably a vig. I'd care to guess that the mafia shot Dashiva to keep him from revealing the results on his view. Now, who did he say he was going to view? Wasn't it Grendael?

 

I don’t like this post. He tries to make it seem like Graendal had the most to lose with Dashiva’s death. There’s no real way to know who Dashiva tried to view so this feels like him trying to throw dirt in Graen’s direction.

 

So I guess that the basic-game Silencer got Graendal? Is that what what we're looking at?

If Gredael had been silenced, how would she have known about it in advance?

 

A legit question, in truth. Just figured I’d point it out as another thing he said to somewhat discredit Graen.

 

 

Anyways, Balthy isn’t sure which way to go. He’s leaning towards town as far as Asmo goes. Not sure about Graen and SH. Semirhage gives him some heat and says he pings. He agrees with Semirhage and Lanfear that Bel’al is being too quiet. Yada yada yade.

 

Doesn’t post for 3 days. Shows up for five minutes to vote for Bel’al. Doesn’t post for 3 days. Agrees with Masaana that Mordeth has been acting scummy…. But out of lack of time and since SH has the longest train, he places his vote on SH.

 

Interesting... proof we have an odd night vig.

 

This is the comment Graendal had a cow about. First of all Balthy already noted before that there’s a vig. I think his comment came to say that there’s an ODD night vig. Aka a vig that can nuke someone every other night. I don’t really find this comment suspicious. As for missing that the vig was one of the night's casualties...even I only noticed that after Graendal pointed it out :P So I'm hardly going to crucify him for it.

 

 

 

 

I don't really feel it. Balthy did go after Graen a bit but hell, Asmo rode her a$$ the entire game and he was a tonwnie. And him using meta with SH... again, it doesn't really hold. Graen has brought up meta loads as well. Aside from that there is nothing else that draws my attention *shrugs*

 

 

After some rereading of my casing I've decided to go with Masaana. She pings all over the place.

[Red2111]

Deadline

 

Thursday 3pm CST

 

 

Vote Count

 

Balth (2): Graendal, Aginor

Belal (1): Lanny

Graendal (1): Mesaana

Mesaana (1); Cyndane

 

No Vote: Belal, Rahvin, Semi, Mordeth, Balth, Halima, Sammy

 

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Actually I just checked and night one there was one kill and night two and three there were two night kills. So I'm unsure why he said that...

 

Care to clarify, Balthy?

[Rita Skeeter]

I don´t understand why you are tunneling on Graendal, Mesaana.

 

I´m still up for voting Mesaana or Sammael, like I have said before. I agree that Belal needs to go too. He is hurting town by being totally absent. Vote Mesaana.

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

I don´t understand why you are tunneling on Graendal, Mesaana.

 

I´m still up for voting Mesaana or Sammael, like I have said before. I agree that Belal needs to go too. He is hurting town by being totally absent. Vote Mesaana.

Im sorry that I am actively going for the person I believe to be scum? Would you prefer me to leave those who I think are scum alone and only vote for those who I think are town? Uh huh... Nice try.

[Graendal-Mafia]

Still feeling Graendal on this one. For all my reasons before plus their refusal to actually give a case on someone. I dont care if you dont want to repeat what you have supposedly said or if you say you dont want to scum hunt for the inactives, not helping us and not giving us the information we need to find the scum is hurting us more. Great job your making people think for them selves! Guess what? Its not helping us at this late in the game. We have, at most, maybe 2 mafia still alive. We are ahead by a fair margin. No reason to withhold things like that.

 

vote Graendal... again

 

You are one of the inactives I was talking about, if I'm wrong you can't all blame me for leading the case when I really didn't I'd still be accountable for starting the train and keeping my vote on Balth but everyone who voted him would be accountable for their own vote. instead of it being "oh Graendal had a really convincing case" However, Cyndane did quote about everything I had on Balth.

[Guest Halima-Mafia]

After some rereading of my casing I've decided to go with Masaana. She pings all over the place.

 

Good. Mesaana

[Guest Halima-Mafia]

....Mesaana

[Red2111]

Deadline

 

Thursday 5:00pm CST; 12 alive, 7 to Lynch

 

 

Vote Count

 

Balth (2): Graendal, Aginor

Belal (1): Lanny

Graendal (1): Mesaana

Mesaana (3); Cyndane, Mordeth, Halima

 

No Vote: Belal, Rahvin, Semi, Balth, Sammy