[Basic] Operation Domination - Game Over - Mafia Wins

[Ishamael-Mafia]

Can we have less of the meta discussing, then? It's distracting and unhelpful.

[Graendal-Mafia]

skimmy skimmy I did. Instant defense mode is not one of my scum tells, it's actually one of my town tells. Even in the FF game when I was scum and Ithi got me day 1 I had cased her before going defensive. *shrug*

 

Wifom.........

 

No not really there Arez, btw way to break the rules and edit again.

 

I will face up to it when it comes, It was a stupid mistake -.- I panicked and pressed edit. Anyway, back to my confession.

 

Either you are Usher or you're scum. Anything else is kind of a waste of time right now.

[Dashiva-Mafia]

I actually viewed Ishy last night. I got a SCUM read, more flavourly, "He has attempted to assume control of the server"

 

The reason why I didn't come out and say it? Simple, first of all, this is a deadline game. Secondly I wanted to see what side he took in this argument.

 

So no, I actually never viewed either Graendal or SH, as you said, revealing my role for a town read would be pretty fudging stupid.

Why did I claim to view SH? It was just another opportunity to gauge Graendal's reactions. Most will probably say I'm retarded and so, but past is past.

 

So now I know that Ishy is against Asmo, because Asmo is on Graendal (sure he didn't say it, but it's his reason). unvote, Vote Ishy

If I'm alive tommorow Graendal, you're deeeaaaad.

[Ishamael-Mafia]

The trouble with metagaming is that people rely on it to make their cases instead of the real evidence that can be found. This results in really bad reads, leading to flawed cases, leading to bad lynches. It's also used as a cop-out if somebody does not have a valid argument to provide in their defense. Finally, as mentioned previously, it's unhelpful and distracting.

[Rita Skeeter]

I actually viewed Ishy last night. I got a SCUM read, more flavourly, "He has attempted to assume control of the server"

 

The reason why I didn't come out and say it? Simple, first of all, this is a deadline game. Secondly I wanted to see what side he took in this argument.

 

So no, I actually never viewed either Graendal or SH, as you said, revealing my role for a town read would be pretty fudging stupid.

Why did I claim to view SH? It was just another opportunity to gauge Graendal's reactions. Most will probably say I'm retarded and so, but past is past.

 

So now I know that Ishy is against Asmo, because Asmo is on Graendal (sure he didn't say it, but it's his reason). unvote, Vote Ishy

If I'm alive tommorow Graendal, you're deeeaaaad.

 

lol

 

Vote Ishy.

[Graendal-Mafia]

View me tonight Arez don't just assume.

 

Unvote Vote Ishy.

 

uncounted cop scum read anyone who doesn't vote Ishy is probably scum.

[Asmodean-Mafia]

skimmy skimmy I did. Instant defense mode is not one of my scum tells, it's actually one of my town tells. Even in the FF game when I was scum and Ithi got me day 1 I had cased her before going defensive. *shrug*

 

I don't consider metagaming to be a proper defense, especially in a game where we're not meant to know who each player is (and we've been doing a bang-up job of that, haven't we?). I'm going after Asmo because of his claim to have led the charge against Moridin, but every time you use a meta-game argument, it pings me.

 

Enough of this - every post of mine that Graen used to "case" was in context to the SH/Moridin situation. Putting them up with pretend scoring system because players names were not mentioned was obviously just meant to paint the picture he was trying to sell.

 

Count the posts I made in regards to the matter. Then read them to see the theme - each and every one had to do with my calling Moridin out, as well as Demandred (whom I"m not finished with by any means) and to say that they were anything but that is spinning it. Period.

 

I did lead the charge in numbers of posts and intent, which is a great deal more valuable to the town than folks who barely post - my posts prove that I'm active and that I'm not afraid to put myself on record - two things that always help the town.

 

If you think I'm lying, put together a chart proving it. Show numbers of posts, and who people were voting for.

[Dashiva-Mafia]

Asmo, chill, lets just kill Ishy first, he has already confirmed that Graendal is scum aswell.

[Graendal-Mafia]

The trouble with metagaming is that people rely on it to make their cases instead of the real evidence that can be found. This results in really bad reads, leading to flawed cases, leading to bad lynches. It's also used as a cop-out if somebody does not have a valid argument to provide in their defense. Finally, as mentioned previously, it's unhelpful and distracting.

 

It's to bad you are now dead lol and Arez will have a chance to view me to prove I'm town, your sidling up to me is going to back fire because it will bring us back to Asmo who you were sure wouldn't get lynched in light of his "case" on me.

[Dashiva-Mafia]

man, this game has been rediculesly fun, except all the times I messed up with the rules >_<

[Graendal-Mafia]

skimmy skimmy I did. Instant defense mode is not one of my scum tells, it's actually one of my town tells. Even in the FF game when I was scum and Ithi got me day 1 I had cased her before going defensive. *shrug*

 

I don't consider metagaming to be a proper defense, especially in a game where we're not meant to know who each player is (and we've been doing a bang-up job of that, haven't we?). I'm going after Asmo because of his claim to have led the charge against Moridin, but every time you use a meta-game argument, it pings me.

 

Enough of this - every post of mine that Graen used to "case" was in context to the SH/Moridin situation. Putting them up with pretend scoring system because players names were not mentioned was obviously just meant to paint the picture he was trying to sell.

 

Count the posts I made in regards to the matter. Then read them to see the theme - each and every one had to do with my calling Moridin out, as well as Demandred (whom I"m not finished with by any means) and to say that they were anything but that is spinning it. Period.

 

I did lead the charge in numbers of posts and intent, which is a great deal more valuable to the town than folks who barely post - my posts prove that I'm active and that I'm not afraid to put myself on record - two things that always help the town.

 

If you think I'm lying, put together a chart proving it. Show numbers of posts, and who people were voting for.

 

You were attacking Dembat not Moridin no matter how you twist it that is the facts admit it.

 

Also I showed everyone's votes on Moridin half of them jumped to SH after the claim I did not quote those but half stayed on Moridin.

[Asmodean-Mafia]

View me tonight Arez don't just assume.

 

Unvote Vote Ishy.

 

uncounted cop scum read anyone who doesn't vote Ishy is probably scum.

 

Subtlety really ain't your thing, is it? LMAO

 

Unvote Graen - Vote Ishy

 

Aside from being quite clever, Dashiva's reveal makes a lot more sense now. Nice work.

[Graendal-Mafia]

Asmo, chill, lets just kill Ishy first, he has already confirmed that Graendal is scum aswell.

 

Then view me, if you don't view me you are scum bussing Ishy. Either way yes Ishy dies here.

[Asmodean-Mafia]

skimmy skimmy I did. Instant defense mode is not one of my scum tells, it's actually one of my town tells. Even in the FF game when I was scum and Ithi got me day 1 I had cased her before going defensive. *shrug*

 

I don't consider metagaming to be a proper defense, especially in a game where we're not meant to know who each player is (and we've been doing a bang-up job of that, haven't we?). I'm going after Asmo because of his claim to have led the charge against Moridin, but every time you use a meta-game argument, it pings me.

 

Enough of this - every post of mine that Graen used to "case" was in context to the SH/Moridin situation. Putting them up with pretend scoring system because players names were not mentioned was obviously just meant to paint the picture he was trying to sell.

 

Count the posts I made in regards to the matter. Then read them to see the theme - each and every one had to do with my calling Moridin out, as well as Demandred (whom I"m not finished with by any means) and to say that they were anything but that is spinning it. Period.

 

I did lead the charge in numbers of posts and intent, which is a great deal more valuable to the town than folks who barely post - my posts prove that I'm active and that I'm not afraid to put myself on record - two things that always help the town.

 

If you think I'm lying, put together a chart proving it. Show numbers of posts, and who people were voting for.

 

You were attacking Dembat not Moridin no matter how you twist it that is the facts admit it.

 

Also I showed everyone's votes on Moridin half of them jumped to SH after the claim I did not quote those but half stayed on Moridin.

 

Put a sock in it Skippy.

[Graendal-Mafia]

View me tonight Arez don't just assume.

 

Unvote Vote Ishy.

 

uncounted cop scum read anyone who doesn't vote Ishy is probably scum.

 

Subtlety really ain't your thing, is it? LMAO

 

Unvote Graen - Vote Ishy

 

Aside from being quite clever, Dashiva's reveal makes a lot more sense now. Nice work.

 

what's this subtlety you speak of?

[Graendal-Mafia]

skimmy skimmy I did. Instant defense mode is not one of my scum tells, it's actually one of my town tells. Even in the FF game when I was scum and Ithi got me day 1 I had cased her before going defensive. *shrug*

 

I don't consider metagaming to be a proper defense, especially in a game where we're not meant to know who each player is (and we've been doing a bang-up job of that, haven't we?). I'm going after Asmo because of his claim to have led the charge against Moridin, but every time you use a meta-game argument, it pings me.

 

Enough of this - every post of mine that Graen used to "case" was in context to the SH/Moridin situation. Putting them up with pretend scoring system because players names were not mentioned was obviously just meant to paint the picture he was trying to sell.

 

Count the posts I made in regards to the matter. Then read them to see the theme - each and every one had to do with my calling Moridin out, as well as Demandred (whom I"m not finished with by any means) and to say that they were anything but that is spinning it. Period.

 

I did lead the charge in numbers of posts and intent, which is a great deal more valuable to the town than folks who barely post - my posts prove that I'm active and that I'm not afraid to put myself on record - two things that always help the town.

 

If you think I'm lying, put together a chart proving it. Show numbers of posts, and who people were voting for.

 

You were attacking Dembat not Moridin no matter how you twist it that is the facts admit it.

 

Also I showed everyone's votes on Moridin half of them jumped to SH after the claim I did not quote those but half stayed on Moridin.

 

Put a sock in it Skippy.

 

Why because I'm right?

[Ishamael-Mafia]

Is nobody else going to ask why we're taking the word of a claimed cop who has already lied once and fuddled the truth once? First he hints at viewing GraendEP, then claims to have viewed SH, now claims to have viewed me. Anyone else here that you've viewed?

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

Asmo, chill, lets just kill Ishy first, he has already confirmed that Graendal is scum aswell.

 

Then view me, if you don't view me you are scum bussing Ishy. Either way yes Ishy dies here.

So what was that about you accusing me of directing the cop view before? Pot and kettle mate.

 

unvote vote Ishy

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

I actually viewed Ishy last night. I got a SCUM read, more flavourly, "He has attempted to assume control of the server"

 

The reason why I didn't come out and say it? Simple, first of all, this is a deadline game. Secondly I wanted to see what side he took in this argument.

 

So no, I actually never viewed either Graendal or SH, as you said, revealing my role for a town read would be pretty fudging stupid.

Why did I claim to view SH? It was just another opportunity to gauge Graendal's reactions. Most will probably say I'm retarded and so, but past is past.

 

So now I know that Ishy is against Asmo, because Asmo is on Graendal (sure he didn't say it, but it's his reason). unvote, Vote Ishy

If I'm alive tommorow Graendal, you're deeeaaaad.

 

 

Heh, Actually, it's quite clever.

 

This is something I am able to follow in good conscious, as opposed to your earlier alleged viewing.

 

Still got my eye on you, SH. :P

 

Unvote. Vote Ishy.

[Graendal-Mafia]

Is nobody else going to ask why we're taking the word of a claimed cop who has already lied once and fuddled the truth once? First he hints at viewing GraendEP, then claims to have viewed SH, now claims to have viewed me. Anyone else here that you've viewed?

 

I'd rather take his word lynch you and if you flip town lynch him tomorrow, Either way you have to be scum though other wise this has been the easiest town game ever.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Is nobody else going to ask why we're taking the word of a claimed cop who has already lied once and fuddled the truth once? First he hints at viewing GraendEP, then claims to have viewed SH, now claims to have viewed me. Anyone else here that you've viewed?

 

If you flip town then we'll deal with him. He's got everything to lose if his viewing is proved incorrect by your coroner report.

[Graendal-Mafia]

Asmo, chill, lets just kill Ishy first, he has already confirmed that Graendal is scum aswell.

 

Then view me, if you don't view me you are scum bussing Ishy. Either way yes Ishy dies here.

So what was that about you accusing me of directing the cop view before? Pot and kettle mate.

 

unvote vote Ishy

 

I was accusing you because you were advocating letting a scum live another night just to let the cop view them.

[Ishamael-Mafia]

How am I scum "either way"?

[Dashiva-Mafia]

Hope to live through the night, cause I have another ace up my sleve

 

Glad people didn't think my move was stupid xP

[Graendal-Mafia]

How am I scum "either way"?

 

if Arez is scum he needs to sacrifice a team mate to live.

 

If he is town, he has no reason to lie.

 

Hence -> scummy baguette