[Basic] Operation Domination - Game Over - Mafia Wins

[Dashiva-Mafia]

I don't care who you are as person, I'm judging your gameplay.

[Graendal-Mafia]

Ninjad.

 

Naive Cyadane. I'm telling you, Lynch Graendal and we have another scum in the bag. If it she turns out not to be scum, I WILL put myself up on the choppingblock without ANY argument at all.

 

And I'm standing by that sentiment. I'm not going to be like Graendal and go back on my word, flail and whatnot. I will just shut up and die.

 

You didn't view me no one would be willing to lynch you. You are spouting nonsense.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

What makes you so sure?

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

*That's directed at Dashiva

[Graendal-Mafia]

I don't care who you are as person, I'm judging your gameplay.

 

Then play the game and stop making bs cases, because I defended a bs hedged hint at viewing me I must be scum?! LAZY is what that is Ithi you did the same thing in the FF game you think people would fall for it twice in a row?

[Graendal-Mafia]

I have half a mind to break a rule get modkilled and throw it back in your faces. That's an effective way to get people to believe me. That however is the lazy way out and exactly the kind of bs that I'm trying to get you guys to stop.

[Dashiva-Mafia]

How can you not know who I am -.- How could you possibly not know?! Did you skim?

 

@Cyndane

 

Why I think Graendal is scum?

Who was so adamant at going after SH when Moridin got killed without even considering the alternatives? She wanted a speedlynch so she could say "Ops, that didn't go as I had thought". Then she'd continue attacking someone who was on that train because they were scum hiding in a speedlynch.

 

Why is Graendal voting Asmo even though she several times stated that Asmo is a "screwed up Town (something like that)".

 

Why are you more content with believing that SH is a GF rather than the possibilty Graendal is mafia?

 

Can you explain why Graendal reacted the way she did when the possibility she was viewed came up? Why was she so erratic and inconstitent in her posting?

 

THAT, is why my vote is on her.

[Demandred-Mafia]

First and foremost, Dashiva, that was a terrible play. You outed for no reason and your antics are actually distracting from the Graendal lynch. I think you are town because I don't see a reason why scum would do what you did, but that was the worst play of the game so far. Even worse than Moridin suicidally defending SH.

 

 

Moggy defended me, Cyndane didn't show interest in wanting to lynch me, and Osangar put in the effort to understand my logic night one. Osangar died, and both Moggy and Cyndane were FoS'd, the only one hesitent to vote me that did not get FoS'd/killed was Halima for obvious reasons. Does anyone else see the pattern here? Or am I just ape shit crazy?

 

You are just crazy. Also, spinning Osan'gar as being someone who was sympathetic to you is laughable given the spat you two had.

 

1. The possibility that Dash is fake revealing, and then admitting his findings like he did is remote.

 

Why is the chance remote? On the contrary. If you think about it it's a clever way to fake claim. He's claiming he's the cop but at the same time offers up a lynch that he didn't view so if the person lynched flips town he can always say 'yo, I viewed SH. I never said I viewed X. So it isn't on me.' Or alternatively he just might know that Graendal is going to flip town. So if he gave us reassurances about viewing her as scum and then the corner report saying otherwise...he'd be on the chopping block the next day. So, it stands to reason that he would present his findings the way that he has, even if he's fake claiming. It's the only way that he could survive the following days while feeding us BS.

 

I don't know if Dashiva is the cop or not. But I'm not going to act upon information that originate from his personal opinion if I disagree with it. His possible role as cop doesn't guarantee anything cause he could still be wrong in his impression.

 

Starting to think you would be a terrific lynch with the staunch defense you are putting up for Graendal.

 

I don't see how anyone has a town read on Graendal right now. She claimed for no good reason, has been spewing crap all over the thread, and instead of just taking her lynch to prove Dashiva wrong like a good vanilla townie, she fought tooth and nail to get him lynched when no one had counterclaimed him. Not the actions of a townie imo.

[Dashiva-Mafia]

And the vanilla town claim she made at the wierdest of times.

 

AND, the formatting on the message she claimed to have gotten does not match mine or Halima's.

 

Do I need to find more reasons?

[Dashiva-Mafia]

Demadred, you are really over-exaggurating. That was terrible in no way at all. Hopefully it'll get more people to realise that SH most likely isn't scum and that Graendal is the one who has to go.

[Demandred-Mafia]

Demadred, you are really over-exaggurating. That was terrible in no way at all. Hopefully it'll get more people to realise that SH most likely isn't scum and that Graendal is the one who has to go.

 

No. It was terrible. And like I said, it is actually distracting from the Graendal lynch.

[Graendal-Mafia]

Now that I know the player behind Dashiva, I know Dashiva is town, but the case is still lazy. Try pulling that bull dog case on any other townie and they would react the same exact way I did the strategy is flawed, because it did not net you a scum. You saying you'll put yourself on the chopping block if you are wrong does not mean anyone will vote you. Half the people that checked in during day 2 would not vote me until your little "grand strategy" and I was telling them to. Just because someone is willing to be lynched doesn't mean they will. I genuinely meant it when I told everyone to lynch me during night 1 did everyone jump in for the easy lynch? No because there was reasonable doubt.

 

 

How can you not know who I am -.- How could you possibly not know?! Did you skim?

 

No, if you were one of the misposters I ignored those after SH's they just got annoying because people were breaking the rules so I thought you were Ithi because you used her flawed strategy from the FF game

 

@Cyndane

 

Why I think Graendal is scum?

Who was so adamant at going after SH when Moridin got killed without even considering the alternatives? She wanted a speedlynch so she could say "Ops, that didn't go as I had thought". Then she'd continue attacking someone who was on that train because they were scum hiding in a speedlynch.

 

I voted SH day 2 did you not see it? Are you blind? I changed it and stated why I changed it.

 

Why is Graendal voting Asmo even though she several times stated that Asmo is a "screwed up Town (something like that)".

 

When did I say this? can you tell me? hmm? can you?

 

Why are you more content with believing that SH is a GF rather than the possibilty Graendal is mafia?

 

It makes sense, nobody would defend a townie so hard that it gets them lynched as scum btw it's funny that since we got a new SH they have vanished.

 

Can you explain why Graendal reacted the way she did when the possibility she was viewed came up? Why was she so erratic and inconstitent in her posting?

 

I explained it myself several times. When you let people think you viewed me I thought you were definately scum since I know I'm town.

 

THAT, is why my vote is on her.

[Graendal-Mafia]

First and foremost, Dashiva, that was a terrible play. You outed for no reason and your antics are actually distracting from the Graendal lynch. I think you are town because I don't see a reason why scum would do what you did, but that was the worst play of the game so far. Even worse than Moridin suicidally defending SH.

 

 

Moggy defended me, Cyndane didn't show interest in wanting to lynch me, and Osangar put in the effort to understand my logic night one. Osangar died, and both Moggy and Cyndane were FoS'd, the only one hesitent to vote me that did not get FoS'd/killed was Halima for obvious reasons. Does anyone else see the pattern here? Or am I just ape shit crazy?

 

You are just crazy. Also, spinning Osan'gar as being someone who was sympathetic to you is laughable given the spat you two had.

 

1. The possibility that Dash is fake revealing, and then admitting his findings like he did is remote.

 

Why is the chance remote? On the contrary. If you think about it it's a clever way to fake claim. He's claiming he's the cop but at the same time offers up a lynch that he didn't view so if the person lynched flips town he can always say 'yo, I viewed SH. I never said I viewed X. So it isn't on me.' Or alternatively he just might know that Graendal is going to flip town. So if he gave us reassurances about viewing her as scum and then the corner report saying otherwise...he'd be on the chopping block the next day. So, it stands to reason that he would present his findings the way that he has, even if he's fake claiming. It's the only way that he could survive the following days while feeding us BS.

 

I don't know if Dashiva is the cop or not. But I'm not going to act upon information that originate from his personal opinion if I disagree with it. His possible role as cop doesn't guarantee anything cause he could still be wrong in his impression.

 

Starting to think you would be a terrific lynch with the staunch defense you are putting up for Graendal.

 

I don't see how anyone has a town read on Graendal right now. She claimed for no good reason, has been spewing crap all over the thread, and instead of just taking her lynch to prove Dashiva wrong like a good vanilla townie, she fought tooth and nail to get him lynched when no one had counterclaimed him. Not the actions of a townie imo.

 

I know I am town and thought I had sure scum. so I went at the opening

[Graendal-Mafia]

And the vanilla town claim she made at the wierdest of times.

 

AND, the formatting on the message she claimed to have gotten does not match mine or Halima's.

 

Do I need to find more reasons?

 

explain this formatting? I only revealed the name role and identity. not exactly how Red sent it that would be quoting the mod. I asked for a full complete reveal. and did so myself. I figured out how the text got small it's the x₂ button apparently if I click into the quick reply box haphazardly I click the buttons that are not there.

[Graendal-Mafia]

Demadred, you are really over-exaggurating. That was terrible in no way at all. Hopefully it'll get more people to realise that SH most likely isn't scum and that Graendal is the one who has to go.

 

YOU OUTED YOURSELF WITH NO REASON AND YOUR PUSHING A LYNCH ON A TOWNIE.

 

How is that play in any way good? I kinda hope the scum win with all the lazy play from the people that are active.

[Graendal-Mafia]

I'd say view me tonight, but the odds of you making it through the night is about 50/50 so not good.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

AND, the formatting on the message she claimed to have gotten does not match mine or Halima's.

 

It matches mine.

 

I'm not ruling out the option of Graendal being scum. But right now I'm more sure of SH being scum while I'm undecided about Graendal. I already stated why I think SH is scum both on day 1 and night 1. Nothing has changed since then and Dashiva's viewing on him doesn't clarify a thing about it.

[Dashiva-Mafia]

I just can't believe it that you're so convinced SH is a GF.

 

If you're going to introduce powers like that in the game, I might aswell say that "HEY, MY VIEW COULD HAVE BEEN REDIRECTED GUYS!!"

 

You go on the information you have, not on the information you've fabricated.

[Graendal-Mafia]

GF is in almost every game are you kidding me? That's not introducing a role into a game. It's odd to not have a GF in a game. This is a basic game, so it's likely we are looking at cop doc GF and maybe 1 more role if any.

[Dashiva-Mafia]

I have never had a gf in any game I played.

[Graendal-Mafia]

You go on the information you have, not on the information you've fabricated.

 

Maybe you should follow your own advice, your whole case on me is fabricated.

[Graendal-Mafia]

I have never had a gf in any game I played.

 

then you have not played many games.

[Graendal-Mafia]

Also I am calling BS you seem to think I should know who you are, if that's the case you would have played a game with a GF in it.

[Demandred-Mafia]

GF is in almost every game are you kidding me? That's not introducing a role into a game. It's odd to not have a GF in a game. This is a basic game, so it's likely we are looking at cop doc GF and maybe 1 more role if any.

 

Blatant exaggeration. More often than not, GF is not used. It is a very powerful scum role and should be used sparingly.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

@ Dashiva

 

Way before your viewing the theory stood on SH being godfather. If they were both scum goons then there was no point in one sacrificing himself for the other. If they were going to lose one, it might as well be SH. No point in risking a second scum the off chance of both of them coming out clean. The only reason for Moridin to jump in to defend SH, under the assumption of both of them being scum, is if SH is the godfather.

 

Then you show up claiming you viewed SH as town and I'm supposed to change my mind? Your reading disproves nothing. You might as well not have viewed him at all and we would have been facing the same dilemma.