[Themed] AVATAR Mafia Game Thread - GAME ON

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

*waits*

[Kivam]

"Fire Nation? Me? I'm not Fire Nation! I hate Fire Nation! Hate hate hate hate hate. I want them dead! Dead! Do you know how many times I've tried to kill them? Hate!"

 

But you didn't listen.

 

 

JET (ISHAMAEL), THE TOWNIE WHO KIND OF SORT OF REALLY DISLIKED THE FIRE NATION, HAS BEEN LYNCHED

 

NIGHT HAS FALLEN> GET ALL NIGHT ACTIONS IN BY MONDAY AT 8PM

 

FINAL VOTE COUNT

 

Aginor (1) - Ishamael

Ishamael (7) - Cyndane, Dashiva, Moghedien, Balthamel, Belal, Moridin, Mesaana

Moridin (1) - Osangar

 

7 to lynch

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

FML that was dumb and stupid. Why do we keep losing townies

[Osangar-Mafia]

That's... interesting. Wish I could ask if he was a vigilante. Perfect role for one. It'd explain some things.

[Guest Semirhage-Mafia]

Vote Ishamael

 

VOTE COUNT

Aginor (3) - Ishamael,Moridin, Belal

Ishamael (5) - Cyndane, Dashiva, Moghedien, Balthamel, Mesaana

Moridin (1) - Osangar

7 to lynch

 

If we both change thats L-1

I recon thats as close as we can get for now and we should hope that someone else comes along and gices the last vote

I'm so confused... You said you would change your vote, but it was already on Ishy... Trying to make it look like you didn't want to vote for a townie?

 

Sorry if that came out as mean, I didn't know for the longest time what it meant either. I just nodded and said yes.

 

Messy you didn't unvote, so I don't know if your vote will count or not.

Good catch.

 

oh sh*t

 

UNVOTE!

 

VOTE ISHAMAEL

 

 

thats a lynch i take it

 

 

i never remember to unvote

*doh!*

Nice cover

 

FML that was dumb and stupid. Why do we keep losing townies

I quoted all of these to point out the posts that led me to believe that Mesaana was just trying to get the last of the bandwagon to vote off a townie. She is pushing for pretty much any lynch at this point, and trying to get Belal to see it as they are thinking the same, but I saw quite a bit of manipulation there.

Also, her response to the scene was a bit overdone. Trying too hard to look town? I now have two people I am fully willing to vote for. Cyndane and Mesaana.

[Demandred-Mafia]

That's... interesting. Wish I could ask if he was a vigilante. Perfect role for one. It'd explain some things.

We'll just have to see who of us is nked tonight, right? Though, if I remember correctly the first two nights only had one kill... Hopefully if he was a Vig, we'll be able to keep more of our numbers in order to hunt down the bloody mafia.

 

I quoted all of these to point out the posts that led me to believe that Mesaana was just trying to get the last of the bandwagon to vote off a townie. She is pushing for pretty much any lynch at this point, and trying to get Belal to see it as they are thinking the same, but I saw quite a bit of manipulation there.

Also, her response to the scene was a bit overdone. Trying too hard to look town? I now have two people I am fully willing to vote for. Cyndane and Mesaana.

I find the underlined portion interesting and I had a witty remark, but I'll refrain because I forgot it while using multiquote for the FIRST TIME ZOMG. >.< I'm surprised we haven't lynched Cyn yet, though. The votes on her have backed off... not that I'm complaining, but a safe lynch is better than a hasty lynch, imo.

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

That's... interesting. Wish I could ask if he was a vigilante. Perfect role for one. It'd explain some things.

We'll just have to see who of us is nked tonight, right? Though, if I remember correctly the first two nights only had one kill... Hopefully if he was a Vig, we'll be able to keep more of our numbers in order to hunt down the bloody mafia.

 

I quoted all of these to point out the posts that led me to believe that Mesaana was just trying to get the last of the bandwagon to vote off a townie. She is pushing for pretty much any lynch at this point, and trying to get Belal to see it as they are thinking the same, but I saw quite a bit of manipulation there.

Also, her response to the scene was a bit overdone. Trying too hard to look town? I now have two people I am fully willing to vote for. Cyndane and Mesaana.

I find the underlined portion interesting and I had a witty remark, but I'll refrain because I forgot it while using multiquote for the FIRST TIME ZOMG. >.< I'm surprised we haven't lynched Cyn yet, though. The votes on her have backed off... not that I'm complaining, but a safe lynch is better than a hasty lynch, imo.

Yeah controlled lynch is better. Im not certain Cyndane is a "safe" lynch but with what we know shes seemingly high on peoples scum lists.

We will have to see what morning brings but im happy to be discussing other options until then.

Semmy - you bring Mesaana to the forefront for manipulation. I can see where you get this from but is it enough to say for certain shes scum? Id like to hear what others have to say on this

[Osangar-Mafia]

Vote Ishamael

VOTE COUNTAginor (3) - Ishamael,Moridin, BelalIshamael (5) - Cyndane, Dashiva, Moghedien, Balthamel, MesaanaMoridin (1) - Osangar7 to lynch

If we both change thats L-1I recon thats as close as we can get for now and we should hope that someone else comes along and gices the last vote

I'm so confused... You said you would change your vote, but it was already on Ishy... Trying to make it look like you didn't want to vote for a townie?

Sorry if that came out as mean, I didn't know for the longest time what it meant either. I just nodded and said yes.Messy you didn't unvote, so I don't know if your vote will count or not.

Good catch.

oh sh*tUNVOTE!VOTE ISHAMAELthats a lynch i take it

i never remember to unvote*doh!*

Nice cover

FML that was dumb and stupid. Why do we keep losing townies

I quoted all of these to point out the posts that led me to believe that Mesaana was just trying to get the last of the bandwagon to vote off a townie. She is pushing for pretty much any lynch at this point, and trying to get Belal to see it as they are thinking the same, but I saw quite a bit of manipulation there.Also, her response to the scene was a bit overdone. Trying too hard to look town? I now have two people I am fully willing to vote for. Cyndane and Mesaana.

*snorts* I quoted all that to say... You should participate more, and you are more suspicious than all that put together. ;) I mean, you haven't helped the town; you didn't vote; you make interesting comments, but rarely a topical one. It goes on. I'm bored.

 

One last thing. If she was voting the person she was trying to vote for, why is someone pointing out her not unvoting a good catch?

[Osangar-Mafia]

That's... interesting. Wish I could ask if he was a vigilante. Perfect role for one. It'd explain some things.

We'll just have to see who of us is nked tonight, right? Though, if I remember correctly the first two nights only had one kill... Hopefully if he was a Vig, we'll be able to keep more of our numbers in order to hunt down the bloody mafia.

I quoted all of these to point out the posts that led me to believe that Mesaana was just trying to get the last of the bandwagon to vote off a townie. She is pushing for pretty much any lynch at this point, and trying to get Belal to see it as they are thinking the same, but I saw quite a bit of manipulation there.Also, her response to the scene was a bit overdone. Trying too hard to look town? I now have two people I am fully willing to vote for. Cyndane and Mesaana.

I find the underlined portion interesting and I had a witty remark, but I'll refrain because I forgot it while using multiquote for the FIRST TIME ZOMG. >.< I'm surprised we haven't lynched Cyn yet, though. The votes on her have backed off... not that I'm complaining, but a safe lynch is better than a hasty lynch, imo.

I find it interesting that people keep saying that when she was a bandwagon to try to prevent a no lynch day. It's actually scary to me that you people keep doing this. Makes me not want to vote her, and I KNOW I have found enough reason. Reeks of manipulation.

 

 

 

 

Oh, and the mod pointedly resent me my role. I lied though I didn't mean to. I can target 2 people and they don't have to include me. Wish I'd have realized sooner. Stupid PMs for not working.

[Guest Semirhage-Mafia]

Yeah controlled lynch is better. Im not certain Cyndane is a "safe" lynch but with what we know shes seemingly high on peoples scum lists.

We will have to see what morning brings but im happy to be discussing other options until then.

Semmy - you bring Mesaana to the forefront for manipulation. I can see where you get this from but is it enough to say for certain shes scum? Id like to hear what others have to say on this

I agree, there isn't much that could be called a "safe" lynch. I'm just really not sure how or why people stopped voting for her. She didn't do anything expect become more suspicious IMO.

 

*snorts* I quoted all that to say... You should participate more, and you are more suspicious than all that put together. ;) I mean, you haven't helped the town; you didn't vote; you make interesting comments, but rarely a topical one. It goes on. I'm bored.

 

One last thing. If she was voting the person she was trying to vote for, why is someone pointing out her not unvoting a good catch?

This IS me participating more you looby...

And who ever said there could only be one topic? I have nothing to add or no thoughts at all on the topics you guys choose, so I announce my own train of thought. Stop pointing this out, it's getting old.

 

I find it interesting that people keep saying that when she was a bandwagon to try to prevent a no lynch day. It's actually scary to me that you people keep doing this. Makes me not want to vote her, and I KNOW I have found enough reason. Reeks of manipulation.

 

 

 

 

Oh, and the mod pointedly resent me my role. I lied though I didn't mean to. I can target 2 people and they don't have to include me. Wish I'd have realized sooner. Stupid PMs for not working.

People had SOME serious thoughts on her, and I'm just really confused about why that group of people stopped those thoughts. She has been distracting to NEW targets, I have been reminding people of their own thoughts they seem to have forgotten.

[Ishamael-Mafia]

Well, I did say I was town. I am sad that I was not around to try to defend myself. We had a few people at work quit so the rest of us are trying to scramble to cover.

 

Well, it was a decent game. Thanks Kiv for the chance.

 

Bah. The information you seek is in the questions you ask.

[Osangar-Mafia]

*snorts* I quoted all that to say... You should participate more, and you are more suspicious than all that put together. ;) I mean, you haven't helped the town; you didn't vote; you make interesting comments, but rarely a topical one. It goes on. I'm bored.One last thing. If she was voting the person she was trying to vote for, why is someone pointing out her not unvoting a good catch?

This IS me participating more you looby... And who ever said there could only be one topic? I have nothing to add or no thoughts at all on the topics you guys choose, so I announce my own train of thought. Stop pointing this out, it's getting old.

I find it interesting that people keep saying that when she was a bandwagon to try to prevent a no lynch day. It's actually scary to me that you people keep doing this. Makes me not want to vote her, and I KNOW I have found enough reason. Reeks of manipulation.Oh, and the mod pointedly resent me my role. I lied though I didn't mean to. I can target 2 people and they don't have to include me. Wish I'd have realized sooner. Stupid PMs for not working.

People had SOME serious thoughts on her, and I'm just really confused about why that group of people stopped those thoughts. She has been distracting to NEW targets, I have been reminding people of their own thoughts they seem to have forgotten.

I didn't say it wasn't participating. I said it was suspicious which is a much more likely reason for you to not want me to point it out... again. You claim there are big things to discuss, but you only gloss over them when other big topics are in play. You have ignored virtually every big discussion for some minuscule thing. Distraction is a technique, and it appears to be yours. All the more funny that you've been doing it and claim Cyndane is scummy for the same. :P Please read that EXACTLY how it was meant. Cyndane is scummy by your own thoughts, so you manage to implicate yourself through utilization of the same action. Curious who you are trying to save.

[Kivam]

Well, I did say I was town. I am sad that I was not around to try to defend myself. We had a few people at work quit so the rest of us are trying to scramble to cover.

 

Well, it was a decent game. Thanks Kiv for the chance.

 

Bah. The information you seek is in the questions you ask.

 

Any time - you played well.

[Kivam]

 

KATARA (AGINOR) THE GIRL WITH THE LOVELY HANDS, HAS BEEN NIGHT KILLED.

 

With 11 players left, it takes 6 votes to lynch

 

 

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Funny story. I was holding my newborn baby nephew in the warm Arizona air when the thought came to me: "Ishamael is Jet, huh?" Funny as in unreal.

 

It is very logical to believe him to be the Vigilante. Fits quite nicely into place. Would have been something to reveal, IMO, but to each their own. Might have been enough to save him, though.

 

However, IF he was the vigilante, this answers a few questions. It seems to confirm Aginor's little dream. Though the timing of that is still unsettling to me. The only thing I can think of is that Kiv sent that out ahead of time on accident or something. But that's just wild speculation and can't be confirmed, so BOO!

 

I do believe this to be the most informative lynch yet.

 

However, I think we've been looking in the wrong direction. The proof? We've yet to find a scum on our own. Moridin and Aginor are still suspect for last Day's events, however, I'm considering looking elsewhere at the moment.

 

Semi, semi, semi. Always back to me. Why is that? Are you upset over not lynching ANOTHER innocent?

 

I am willing to readdress any concerns anyone has with me. Ask away. I will not degrade to sarcasm ( at Osangar). I'm aware that past actions cannot be undone, but future actions are still yet to be made.

 

Suspects by Most to Least:

 

Semirhage

Belal

Moghedien

Demandred

Moridin

Shaidar Haran

Aginor

Balthamel

Dashiva

Osangar

Mesaana

 

Note: those at the bottom are not free of suspicion, just deemed less suspect than those above. For the moment.

 

I quickly wanted to adress the Mesaana reveal. It helped solidify Osangar and even Aginors to an extent.

 

CONSTANT VIGILANCE!!

 

--

 

See what I mean?

 

So, I'm going to assume that was our Healer. Fair assessment?

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Any new info from our two revealed players?

[Osangar-Mafia]

Aginor was worse than I thought, what with being Katara; Ishamael was not so bad since he was Jet.

 

I'm still looking at Semi, Mori, and I am suddenly curious about others that I'll need to take notes on. For now, I am reinstating yesterday's vote. It's not likely to change without some massive shift in information.

 

MORIDIN

[Osangar-Mafia]

Out of curiousity, why is Dashiva at the bottom?

[Osangar-Mafia]

If my proportions are correct, we have 3 days left until end game, if we don't make a kill, if they don't hit Aang.

 

I seriously think we need to do the Moridin thing since Aginor was so sure (thinking he saw something) on top of the rest of us having voiced doubts about him. I want to see where we go before I voice other thoughts.

[Belal-Mafia]

I agree with you Osangar. Right now it's the best we have to go on. Everything else has failed. Aginor was Killed last night, so we can't clear anything up, not that he was really willing or able to clear anything up before his death. I also don't feel I was manipulated by anyone with that last lynch. The activity has been sucking the last week, and that's an understatement. Talking had stopped and we were inching towards deadline. It was only a day away. There's no way I was going to risk any random shennanigans from our Dark Mod. Ishy was scummy the whole game, I thought so, and so did many other people. Maybe if the remaining people were more active so we could all collectively discuss things and come up with a consensus we would be doing a lot better in this game. That's all I'm going to say for now. I know I'm beating a dead horse, but you know what, I'm probably going to beat it a whole heck of a lot more until this game is done, or until I'm lynch/or nk'd whichever comes first. So this game is drawing closer to an end, if we have maximum participation I think we can pull this win out of our butts. So let's do it team!

 

(that was my pep talk, sort of)

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Good question, Osangar.

 

Half feeling, half changing my focus. He was always somewhere in the middle to me, but there's just more suspect players than him. Again, for now. He's not out of the race just yet. Always plenty of time to slip up the ladder.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Oh, and with Aginor coming up Innocent, that does change a few things.

 

Moridin

Semirhage

Moghedien

Shaidar Haran

Belal

Demandred

Balthamel

Dashiva

Osangar

Mesaana

[Osangar-Mafia]

You both agree... and yet, I'm still the only vote. O...k...? Consensus voting: not our strong suit.

[Belal-Mafia]

VOTE MORIDIN

 

haha Sorry about that, I went off on a tangent and then forgot my initial reason for posting.

[Belal-Mafia]

I get distracted by shiny things okay? Like calandor or bale fire or the likes.