Game Over - Insane Mafia Game. Page 94

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Moggy, you're right.  I wasn't trying to be stubborn, but I suppose I was.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote Ishy[/glow], But you're still on my radar.

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

I'm gonna case Moridin. I don't feel like casing someone active atm.

He's got 26 posts.

 

First he randomly votes Asmodean

 

Then he defends Be'lal on the idea of finder-viewing Semi; but in the same post declares he dislikes the go-to-night idea.

 

In the next posts, he keeps on going on about Be'lal. Positively ánd negatively, but each time less + and more -. And spamming a lót

 

In one of his more sens-making posts, he votes:

First of all, Sammael gets a cookie. Second of all, bad Moggie! Bad! I demand a solid half hour of foot-licking for this, or else I'm giving your cour'souvra to Balthamel to play with!

 

Okay, Bel'al is looking quite suspicious after this. If the following things are true:

1) Forfeiting a lynch gives the evils extra power and

2) They were aware of this

 

Then, look for evils amongst those advocating a no-lynch, chief amongst them Bel'al. Yes, if those things were both true he could still be an innocent who was ignorant of this and was genuinely playing the numbers game for the good of the innocents, but what are the odds that he got there before the evils, who would be looking for a reason to bring about a no-kill vote?

 

Of course, these things are speculation and we don't know that the double kill and the fact that we voted to go to night are in any way related. Going to night might still have been the best thing to do. So can we shoot the messenger just because the night turned out bad. The short answer is no. But the long answer (with a few additional points) is yes. The points are:

 

We can't know if going to night without a lynch caused the double murder, but we do know that going to night without lynching is an anomaly in any mafia game, and there's no denying that what happened last night was highly anomalous. So we have two anomalies. Occam's Razor  :P says they're linked in some way: one anomaly rather than two.

 

There's another thing. Someone posted of the possibility that Bel'al had a role that required him to name his kill. He named Osan'gar. In fact, he did more. He speculated about Osangar's identity. It could be that his role required him to not only name his kill but correctly guess their true identity. Now the general consensus is that Bel'al is Kivam. Kivam always goes for the smart play. Just how is trying to out the identity of a player (indeed one of several players, particularly those with formidable reputations and/or a track record of getting night killed) the smart play, mmm? Even if it isn't Kivam, the same applies. Something fishy is going on.

 

So without further ado I'll put my vote where my mouth is: [glow=red,2,300]Bel'al[/glow], it's time to leave the House.

 

Lots of spam, and, finally, the vote.

 

Large was my surprise 2 posts further when Moridin did this (I've deleted the spam):

(...)I'm going to [glow=red,2,300]unvote Bel'al[/glow] while I think it over, though I may regret that later.

 

Then he votes for me because he totally misunderstood my reasoning for voting Sammael; and unvotes in his next post.

 

That's about it. So: Moridin likes to spam, and slowely built up a suspicion against Be'lal. A little bit too slowly in my opinion, but I'm gonna give him the advantage of the doubt.

 

My scum-o-meter reads:

1)Graendal (has my vote)

2)Aran'gar

3)Moridin

4)Lanfear

5)Ishamael

...

10)Balthamel

...

16)Mesaana

 

You may have noticed I've switched Lanfear and Ishy. They were very close, and I've had to drop one of the suspicions against Ishy. That's why.

 

Ishy: I just don't see how you can think "he's evil" ánd at the same time write down what you have writen down. It can be just me that isn't smart enough to get it, but it could also be you knowing he isn't evil (as far as I know).

[Barmacral]

Attention: Graendal is on a semi-LOA right now and likely will not be able to post for a little while.

[Barmacral]

Also, being the Great Mod in the Sky, I can see the future, and one potential path which humanity may take could lead to deadlines... and hungry underfed Rancor pits.

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

Okay, let's case Be'lal. 42 posts.

 

In her first real one, he votes Semirhage."for disliking random voting".

 

After that, he declares the real healer must reveal, if he exists.

 

Then he convinces us all to go for the no kill. He uses quite a lot of posts on this.

 

One short intermezzo between this, after I've voted for him:

Be'lal:

 

Correct - Mesaana was either operating on false info about the healer (why would they die that night?) or deliberately spreading it; either way, its worth pointing out that the info was false.

 

What are you talking about?

 

And I also don't get why we shouldn't lynch someone today?

 

And seeing you encouraged the real healer to reveal, I'll vote [glow=red,2,300]Be'lal[/glow].

 

1)  You said "if the real healer reveals, they'll get nightkilled."  That's false - the healer can self protect, even if it isn't Semi.  Unless this is a wacky variation on the healer role, but we have no reason to think it is.

 

2) We shouldn't lynch someone today because it does us no good.  WE HAVE NO INFORMATION TODAY, any lynch would be very nearly random, since the primary factor we are reacting to - Semi's actions - haven't been definitively classified guilty or innocent yet.  TOMORROW, WE WILL HAVE THAT INFORMATION, based on the finder reveal/non-reveal.

I think this response fits more with an inocent then with an evil. But that's only personal opinion. And, before you're going for me on this information: I hadn't got time to read the maths before. I unvoted as soon as I had.

 

I'm also gonna quote her suspect-list:

OK, my suspect list, as promised:

 

Assuming Semi is innocent:

 

1) Mesaana, for reasons already stated

 

2) Sammael, ditto, and for trying to get a lynch today

 

3) Balthamel, for fighting the no kill and then fading into the background

 

4) Ishamael, for leaving the vote on me

 

5) Demandred, Graendal, Halima, Lanfear, Asmodean, Aginor, Aran'gar, Cyndane, Rahvin (in no particular order) for fading into the background and/or leaving their votes on irrelevant players (at least 1, probably 2 of this group is evil, IMO)

 

6) likely innocents - Moridin, Osan'gar, Moghedien (1 is probably evil)

 

If Semi is guilty, Mesaana and Sammael drop in priority, Ishamael and Balthamel rise.

Nothing to remark upon here.

 

 

 

Next one:

BTW, given the possibility that our healer killed himself, I think we need to consider whether the finder is also getting opposite readings.  Obviously, there's no way for us to know, but: [glow=green,2,300]finder, if you got a guilty reading on Semi, name yourself the target tonight.  If you get a guilty result, you'll know that either:

 

a) everyone you view comes up guilty (you're paranoid); or

 

b) everyone you view comes up the opposite of what they actually are (you're insane).

 

Either way, continue viewing others after tonight, as any "innocent" verdict you get would be proof of guilt[/glow]

He wants to continue this game in a way he likes. And I must say I agree.

 

Then she votes for me (the reason is in one of the above quotes)

 

Then a lot of posts in which he gives all possible reasons for different outcomes. One example:

(...)Occam's razor again - the "healer who kills" is the only thing that explains last night - unless we have a vigilante who used their nightkill on night 1?  Anyone want to own up to that?  If not, the smart play is to assume that he was, in fact, a "healer who kills."  (The only other option I see is for a two mafia team game where there are 2 kills per night, and I think that's a bit much, since there's no way for the innocents to win that.)(...)

 

And, from the same post:

Twisting words to try and influence others is a bad sign.

 

Interestingly enough, I agree.  But between the two of us, you're the one who is doing the word-twisting, as far as I can tell.  I'm still leaning towards Mesaana, but if the rest of you haven't lynched anyone by the time I get back and the vote is running Ishamael's way, I'd have no aversion to switching.

 

And if you lynch me before I get back - well, its understandable, since the "no lynch" argument backfired.  But when you get my coroner result, keep in mind what I said about Mesaana, Ishamael and Balthamel.  (My 4th tier suspects are Sammael and Lanfear)

 

(edited to change a glow to a quote)

Willingness to lynch about anyone is not very apreciate in mafiosi-circles.

 

To conclude: I think you're innocent.

 

So, to the scum-o-meter:

My scum-o-meter reads:

1)Graendal (has my vote)

2)Aran'gar

3)Moridin

4)Lanfear

5)Ishamael

...

11)Be'lal

12)Balthamel

...

16)Mesaana

 

(edited the quotes)

And I thought mods were not allowed to defend players? First saying we must not vote Graendal (who's got 4 votes, as opposed to 2 for Be'lal and me); and then saying we must vote someone of quickly???

[Guest Moghedien-Mafia]

Since Graendal isn't here, I will change my vote to [glow=red,2,300]Cyndane[/glow]. Among the reasons discussed earlier, I think her wishy washy when anyone points out that she has done something odd. She has no firm opinions and not much help that I remember.

 

Going to read Mesaana's last post now.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

I've noticed that too.  Moridin tends to say a lot, while not saying much.  Worth keeping an eye on.

 

Be'lal I'm sort of sitting on the fence.  The no-kill didn't help us at all, however, it's possible he did it in total innosence.  I'm just not sure where to stand on him.

 

I'm going to see how things play out for a bit before I lay my vote.

[Barmacral]

I did not defend Graendal, I did inform you that she is on LOA. And there are no deadlines set yet, nor will there be in the immediate future, as we have to wait for the week to begin still, however, should this day drag out, then I'll start setting deadlines.

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

So there won't be a deadline before Graendal's back?

[Barmacral]

That really depends on when Graendal's back... I'm pretty sure she'll be back soon enough, but if not, the game will have to go on without her.

[Arangar-Mafia]

OK before I begin... I am REALLY sorry about this... maybe this is why I shouldn't do reviews....

 

This is only a review of the first 20 pages.

 

1. Balthamel- first to vote Day 1... votes for Demandred and does shifty eyes and gives Mesaana her random number.... 6

 

2. Be'lal votes Semi for disliking random voting.

 

3. Rahvin waits til more show up to vote.

 

4. Mesaana says the random number 6 vote is Cyndane.

 

5.Rahvin votes Moggy just because she was playing drama queen with the ripping the dress.

 

6. Moridin votes Asmo... because someone had to.

 

7.  Ishy doesnt see a good reason to even vote yet.

 

8. Cyndane replies to Mesaanas vote that elephants never forget.

 

9. Aginor says time to put Cyndane to sleep for acting sane.

 

10. Lanfear says holding off voting for now.

 

11. Balth says random kill unless someone does something stupid to which Mesaana replies "does something stupid".

 

12. Just interesting to note... Semivemy asks Barm what the roles are in this game and I remember he later says he talked to Barmy on MSN and he confirmed there will not be role reveals. (Reply 79, pg. 7) He claimed they discussed this very early on... while the thread was just on the first page of posts.

 

13. Balth votes Semi until he can give better alternative to random voting.

 

14. Sammael throws dart at Mesaanas name in a vote for her.

 

15. Cyndane says she likes Sammael's avvie to which Aginor acts loony asking if Cyndane is Twitchy.

 

16. Graendal says tempted to vote Sammy just for squishing Mesaana's eye.

 

17. Semi votes Cyndane because "people had been discussing voting her". Also because she fears Be'lal and Balthamel will convince others to vote for her. (self preservation)

 

18. Cyndane says her vote still stays with her for now.

 

19. End of page 8 Halima finally shows up.  Apoligizes for delay but doesn't explain.  Random votes 18 which is Rahvin.

 

20. Moggy does a pounce vote on Be'lal.

 

21.  I say no thoughts yet as votes seem random... pretty much was.

Asmodean(1): Mordin

Be'lal(1): Moghedian

Cyndane(2): Mesaana, Semirhage

Mesaana(1): Sammael

Moghedian(1): Rahvin

Rahvin(1): Halima

Semirhage(2): Balthamel, Be'lal

 

22. Ishy proposes "scum test" and pokes Halima.

 

23. Lanfear says still no idea who to vote for and says may go random like her surroundings.

24. Mesaana says "I wasn't the one saying they look suspicious. To the contrary: the real scum will try to draw not too much attention to themselves by doing idiotic. That's why I can."  (( Or they can "hide in the open".  ))  Says to Semi that she was the only other one to vote Cyndane and that it was random.  Considers changing her vote.  Questions the Balth-Be'lal coupling.

 

25. MorIdIn says two I's in name.. also says we need to start random voting in the same direction.  Says he is not changing his vote though with a .. "Do as I say and not as I do." .

 

26. Mesaana gives him poison marshmallows... I pretty well disregard this as spam... but am going to note it anyways.

 

27.  Discussion of random voting... drawn out games.. no alternative...says there's  not enough to go on for "gut feelings" from anyone.

 

28.  Asmodean comments on Mesaana's poison bit... then votes Demandred.  Says its random but then comments that he has made only one post and is laying low.  My thoughts from later finding out that the Demandred player did a switch and someone new came into the game must be why the silence here but I could be wrong.

 

29. Mesaana recants the votes/voters/ nonvoters thus far.  Says if all 8 of the nonvoters voted for either one or the other of Cyndane or Semi we could get through day 1 with no one having to reposition voting.

Not yet voted: Aginor, Lanfear, Cyndane, Osan'gar, Aran'gar, Ishamael, Demandred and Graendal.

 

  Also says those who haven't yet been voted for shouldn't be and to wait til tommorow to vote any of those.

Not yet voted for: Aginor, Balthamel, Sammael, Lanfear, Osan'gar, Aran'gar, Ishamael, Moridin, Graendal and Halima.

 

30.  Cyndane sighs and votes for Semi because she is the only other one that has 2 votes.

31. Ishy votes Semi for the sake of moving on in the game.  Also said he will change it if something better comes along.

32. Aginor votes Semi.  Probably just bandwagoning.  So does Demandred and Lanfear.  Sammael changes his vote to Semi to get the day moving along.

33. With 8 votes on him Semi declares she is healer and calls us morons.  Votes Be'lal.  Defends Cyndane against Be'lal saying she hardly thinks Cyndane is evil.

Interesting to note... in Semi's reveal post she says and I quote.... "So when I turn up innocent you'll know I'm evil"  Typo?  or not....?

 

34. Cyndane immedietly says a bad word and unvotes Semi.  Semi replies with a "thanks twitch".

 

35. Lanfear also unvotes Semi with a reply " I was hoping something would turn up to help me make a decision."  Unvoted "just in case".

 

36. Cyndane retorts that she is not twitch.

 

37. Demandred stays his vote on Semi.

 

38. Much debate on Semi.  Is he evil is he Healer? Can he protect himself?

 

39. Yes.. page 12 post 142 is where Semivemy replies that he had a msn convo with Barmy. (see point 12)

40.  Debating on lynching and being able to heal that and what seems like utter confusion.  I'm fairly new and I know you can't heal lynches... Most of us are experienced players so I really didn't and don't understand the confusion here.  We all must have at least the general understanding of this game to be allowed to play the non-newb games and this debating was as if some didn't understand the rules. (starts at pg 12)

 

41. Cyndane says "Well, I'm keeping my vote off Semi for now. I've learned not to trust someone just cause they sound legit."  If you can't trust someone just because they sound legit then why keep your vote off of her?

 

42. Mesaana says to Semi "If you're evil, and the real healer shows up, you'll know who to kill tonight."  If Semi wasn't  the real healer and the real healer  showed up and survived a lynch they can heal themselves the same as Semi could have done if he was the real healer.

 

43. Lanfear  says shes waiting to see if anything becomes clearer.

 

44. Aginor speculates that if Semi knows roles won't be revealed on death she could be innocent but not healer.

 

45. Asmo says we should wait to see if there is a counter-claim.

 

46. Mesaana makes a good point that Semi would show up innocent if Symp or Healer either one.  This backs up her urgings for the Healer (if not Semi) to not reveal.

*OK page 15 and im already at 46 points... I'm sorry!!*

 

47.  Lots of posts about Semi's reveal being true or not... several have hashed and rehashed this so for the sake of my sanity I'm skimming this part.  Feel free to reread it.

 

48. Aginor stays his vote and says he doesn't know what a Symp is.  Claims noobishness.

 

49. Mesaana votes Semi... so she wont forget to later.

 

50.  Semi says he accidently posted under his own id not the Semi one and Rahvin might have seen it but said to please not reveal.  It's my opinion that most have figured it out at this point because of his several comments about naeann...

 

51. Speculation by me... didn't someone say there was a certain role where you had to say the name of the person in open game... Semi is the only one to more than once mention Osan'gar.

Vote count at the end of page 15

Semi(7)-Be'lal, Mesaana, Balthamel,Ishy, Aginor, Demandred, Sammael

Moggy(1)-Rahvin,

Asmo(1)-Moridin,

Rahvin(1)-Halima

Be'lal(1)-Moggy, Semi

Demandred(1)-Asmo

 

52. Mesaana asks what a roleblocker role is but you seem experienced to me... you really don't know?  It seemed rather obvious to me... roleblocker would... block roles?  Cyndane.. who claims newb... seemed to know what it was.

 

53. Asmo votes Mesaana.  Says its odd shes trying to prevent a counterclaim.

54. Vemy reveals he is Semi. (Duh)... Mesaana says shes leaving but leaving the vote up but then reads Vemy's reveal and unvotes.  Aginor also unvotes.

 

55. Graendal says too much has happened and says she will decide who to vote later.

56. Sammael unvotes...  Be'lal rehashes some of what was already said.

*END OF PAGE 19*  I'm tired as all heck and have made 56 points... I'll do the other 20 pages later... I need a break.

 

After reviewing that much [glow=red,2,300]Cyndane[/glow] looks very suspicious to me so I'm taking my vote off of Mesaana. 

 

 

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Did I say I was newb?  I can't recall.  I might have said something to the extent that I am newer to the game than most, not necisarrily a newb.  Anyways.  Looks like people have found suspicion in my posts.  What a surprise.

 

I sort of saw this coming, so I think it's a little funny.  But yeah.  I'm still trying to decide who I should vote for.  I may wait on the 'morrow.

 

Got to go for a little while.  I'm starving.

[Demandred-Mafia]

Okay, just an FYI so everyone doesn't think I fell off the face of the earth. During the week I have complete access to a pc and so I'm readily available for active playing. Weekends are less fun, and my access will be short and sweet when I'm around. I just don't want anyone to wonder why the disappearing act for a couple days, and then I spring back up in power mode. This will happen with every weekend that comes, so expect it, if this carries on through the week.

 

I've read most of the cases, but I'm still trying to sort through them. Interesting things brought up. I will do my best to finish them up tonight, and give some input, but if that falls through (I'm not at home atm) then I will be sure to go through it all tomorrow and post my thoughts asap. 

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Okay, “weeeeee” time! :D

 

8. Cyndane replies to Mesaanas vote that elephants never forget.

 

Well, that's what they say about elephants.

 

Seriously, this was just me using Mesaana’s vote for me as an excuse to spam.  Not that I need much excuse.

 

15. Cyndane says she likes Sammael's avvie to which Aginor acts loony asking if Cyndane is Twitchy.

 

Well, who doesn’t like Sammys Avvie?  Am I the only one?

 

30.  Cyndane sighs and votes for Semi because she is the only other one that has 2 votes.

 

Yep, pretty much.

 

34. Cyndane immedietly says a bad word and unvotes Semi.  Semi replies with a "thanks twitch".

 

36. Cyndane retorts that she is not twitch.

 

Self explanatory.  I hope.

 

41. Cyndane says "Well, I'm keeping my vote off Semi for now. I've learned not to trust someone just cause they sound legit."  If you can't trust someone just because they sound legit then why keep your vote off of her?

 

The reason this is misinterpreted is simply that I didn't emphasize "for now" as I thought I had.

 

Translation: "I'm not sure I believe you, but I'll give you the benefit of the doubt, for now."

 

Hope that's cleared up.

 

-----------------------------------

 

Hiya, Demi! :D

[Guest Moridin-Mafia]

w00t I'm Mesaana's lucky number three! I seem to have a way of ending up on suspect lists so by now I know better than to take it personal. Seems there's a few people here who could use the same lesson.

 

Right now the only information we have is that Semi claimed healer, Bel'al convinced us to go to night, and there was a double kill including our supposed healer. We also know that there is no poisoned healer role, so the double kill must be the work of nefarious forces and/or linked to other factors such as the go to night, or crazy stuff we don't even know about. The only surviving name in all of this is Bel'al, and the general consensus is to give him the benefit of doubt because, well, the numbers made sense. So for the game to move we really need another candidate, because I think we've got all we're gonna get out of this day.

 

Going mainly on the events of day one, I find it hard to trust Mesaana or Balthamel. I'd have to do a reread to find the specifics, but those were the names that were bugging me the most on that day. I'll vote for neither unless the vote seems to be going that way, because it's high time we stopped picking a different canditate each and talking each other round in circles.

Seriously, as helpful as player cases are, they mostly tend to happen when people are stuck for a course of action.

 

And the reason I cram so many words into so little substance is that I tend to work through my thoughts by putting them up on the screen  :P

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

15. Cyndane says she likes Sammael's avvie to which Aginor acts loony asking if Cyndane is Twitchy.

 

Well, who doesn’t like Sammys Avvie?  Am I the only one?

 

No you ain't

 

And we've reached page 50!!!

at this speed, we're gonna beat the doubleblind-record ;D

[Ishamael-Mafia]

If Graenedal is away than we can put her on the back burner. I unvote her and move back to [glow=red,2,300]Be'lal[/glow]

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

And we've reached page 50!!!

at this speed, we're gonna beat the doubleblind-record ;D

 

You're welcome, Messy ;)

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

Cyndane seems to be quite popular. 58 posts.

 

Out of the first 15, the most interesting one was:

I don't know about you, Mesaana, but I'd rather this game not drag on as long as the Double Blind did.

 

Then, after my prodding a choice between her and Semi:

*sigh*

 

[glow=red,2,300]Semirhage[/glow]

 

She's the only one besides me that has 2 votes and I'm not voting for me.

 

And after the reveal:

Oh Sh*t!!!!  ><

 

[glow=red,2,300]UNVOTE!!!!!!!!![/glow]

 

This is interesting, isn't it?

 

After the question of other roles, she proposes:

Semi, for someone not wanting anyone to know who you are, you just gave yourself away, unless that was to throw us off.

 

Any Other Twists to the Game:

 

Roleblocker role?

 

What about...nope, that's all I could come up with.

 

-----------------------------

 

Was typing this up when Aginor posted >.>

and after my comment about a cool role:

can be deadly too.  what if they block the Finder or Healer by accident?

a wish? (okay, it's far-fetched)

 

Then a lot of spam, with the most 'interesting' post:

Well, I can't say that im surprised that something like this happened.  It *is* the Nuthouse, after all.

 

So aparantly the question is, was Semi the Healer, or the Symp?  And what about Osan'gar?  Most likely a roleless innocent, but we wont know until endgame.

 

And then her suspects-list:

Well, here's my two top suspects. (not necisarily in this order)

 

Ishamael: For being one of the main people going after Semi after her reveal.  Plus, he just doesn't feel right to me.

 

Lanfear: For being very quiet.  She has 15 posts since the game started.

 

Not much, but it's the best I got for Day 2.

Why did she forget me? If the reason to go for Ishy is correct, I should be on this list as well.

 

Next one:

okay...

 

on with the game.

 

For some reason, I don't think it was an Assassin role that was responisble for this.  I do think it was semi.  Don't know how or why of course, but that's my pennys worth.(...)

Why do you think so? Unless you áre the assassin, and haven't killed her.

 

And, after congratulating Ishy on having cased her:

Hmm...I'm going to vote [glow=red,2,300]Ishy[/glow]

Dang.

 

After Ishy makes the opposite vote:

You just convinced me not to unvote you, Ishy.  If you're not mafia, you're being a reckless innocent atm.  And that's almost as bad.

 

First you say that Barm might make a timelimit soon, then you slow down the lynch by voting me.  Maybe I'm reading too much into your post, but that sounds like a contradiction to me.

it looks interesting, but I don't really see how.

 

But, a little while later:

Moggy, you're right.  I wasn't trying to be stubborn, but I suppose I was.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote Ishy[/glow], But you're still on my radar.

Clambering back?

 

Afterwards, she agrees with my statements. And she posted once between me starting her case and me posting it.

 

To conclude: she posts quite a lot, but most of it is spam. And the rest is not thát strange, just a little.

 

And my personal scum-o-meter:

 

1)Graendal

2)Aran'gar

3)Moridin

4)Lanfear

5)Ishamael

6)Cyndane

...

11)Be'lal

12)Balthamel

...

16)Mesaana

 

And, until Graendal returns, I'll give my vote to the second in line. Don't use this as an excuse not to post, but as the opposite, [glow=red,2,300]Aran'gar[/glow].

 

I hope no one saw the wrong username I posted this with originally?

[Asmodean-Mafia]

That's so precious, I doubt that anyone from prevous mafia games or fiddlesticks does not know who you are :-* .

 

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

I take it you mean me, Asmo?  If so:  Yeah, I stopped worrying about concealing who I really was a while ago.  :)

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

I've only a véry vague idea who you maybe could be, but not definitive.

 

And I think asmo meant me. I posted your case with the wrong account, and let it stand that way for a couple of minutes, before I realised.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Ah, I see.  Seriosly?  I thought I'd be figured out a long time ago.  *shrugs*

 

can be deadly too.  what if they block the Finder or Healer by accident?

a wish? (okay, it's far-fetched)

 

Not a wish.  A concern.  I would hope that would concern everyone.  (including the baddies, cause they get blocked too.  *snicker*)

 

Well, here's my two top suspects. (not necisarily in this order)

 

Ishamael: For being one of the main people going after Semi after her reveal.  Plus, he just doesn't feel right to me.

 

Lanfear: For being very quiet.  She has 15 posts since the game started.

 

Not much, but it's the best I got for Day 2.

Why did she forget me? If the reason to go for Ishy is correct, I should be on this list as well.

 

You were, probably, the person that went against semi the hardest after her reveal.  I chose Ishy because he seemed to be right behind you, and in my experience, as limited as it is, the baddies usually find someone to stand behind.  That's how I saw it anyways.

 

okay...

 

on with the game.

 

For some reason, I don't think it was an Assassin role that was responisble for this.  I do think it was semi.  Don't know how or why of course, but that's my pennys worth.(...)

Why do you think so? Unless you áre the assassin, and haven't killed her.

 

I thought I said I don’t know why. 

 

Call it “my gut feeling”.  Or even, “intuition”, maybe.  I dunno.

 

You just convinced me not to unvote you, Ishy.  If you're not mafia, you're being a reckless innocent atm.  And that's almost as bad.

 

First you say that Barm might make a timelimit soon, then you slow down the lynch by voting me.  Maybe I'm reading too much into your post, but that sounds like a contradiction to me.

it looks interesting, but I don't really see how.

 

What exactly don’t you “see how”?

 

Moggy, you're right.  I wasn't trying to be stubborn, but I suppose I was.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote Ishy[/glow], But you're still on my radar.

Clambering back?

 

I realized that I was being stupid.  I was saying that Ishy was holding up the lynch, when I started it by voting him.  Plus, at that time I voted him, I wasn't in the bestest of moods, but that's no excuse.

[Guest Mesaana-Mafia]

The "don't see how" is because I forgot why I quoted that post between the copy and the paste.

 

And I think I know who you are now.

[Guest Cyndane-Mafia]

Well, that's good, cause I don't know who anyone is, except maybe Moggy.  But that's a maybe.  Ah well, that's the point of these alts.

 

*puts on shiney, "Mr/Mrs State-The-Obvious" badge*

 

Looks good, don't it?