Jump to content




  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About b3arz3rg3r

  • Birthday 01/01/1

b3arz3rg3r's Achievements


Experienced (11/16)

  • First Post
  • Collaborator
  • Posting Machine Rare
  • Week One Done
  • One Month Later

Recent Badges

  1. I disagree. Yes, the Seanchan system of controlling channellers will eventually fall apart, but not because the Sul'dam leave the Seanchan lands to become channellers of their own initiative. The sul'dam regard channelling as a crime. They really believe that. I'm pretty sure the solution will be provided by Seta and Bethamin. Mat send them to the WT with the command to find a way for channellers to live openly and freely in the empire without destroying it and they'll succeed. I'd say RJ planned for them to come back in the outriggers.
  2. My points of criticism are pretty much the same as those of most here I think. The inexplicable absence of a majority of channellers especially WO and Asha'man, whatever genius possessed Egwene and the Hall from commanding a thousand beginning channellers from helping on the battlefield. The disappearance of about 200k Aiel who should have been far more effective than all the armies of the Westlands other than the Seanchan combined. The tactics which were really all over the place. Graendal's immortality cheat- I mean really how many times did she barely escape from a surprise attack? Demandred being challenged to a swordfight three times as the utter height of stupidity.
  3. Let's see: Mat remains ta'veren much to his sorrow and spends the next decades retaking Seanchan and convincing Fortuona to change the Seanchan culture of social darwinism. The damane problem gets solved by Seta and Bethamin. They take a binder back to Seanchan and establish two new oaths for all Seanchan channellers. The first oath is to serve the empire faithfully without breaking laws and the second is to never release the first oath. Perrin is named Wolfking and spends his time rebuilding Saldaea, the Two Rivers and Ghealdan and transforming them into one of the strongest alliances in Randland Faile is crowned Queen of Saldaea Alliandre eventually marries Tam who retains the Stewardship over the Two Rivers and eventually the Two Rivers and Ghealdan merge all but in name. Rand keeps on travelling around the world for a couple of decades before he decides to explore other worlds through the portal stones. He'll live for as long as he likes, though probably not longer than the regular lifespan of a channeller, but he won't ever interfere openly in the affairs of the world. Even when the Dragon's Peace gets broken eventually he won't interfere. Min will live as long as she wants too since Rand can just will her to retain her youth. Elayne will unite Andor and Cairhien and then she will invade Shara to balance Tuon's reclamation of Seanchan. Aviendha will look to the future of the Aiel. Creating holds and septs in all the unclaimed stretches of land between the nations. Asha'man and Aes Sedai won't merge any time soon. Men and women will work together often, but they'll remain separate. Eventually women will join the Asha'man and men will join the Aes Sedai.
  4. Egwene shouldn't have married Gawyn. When I read that oneliner telling us that the two of them had married I just knew they would both. XD Gawyn was a given since like all the other Trakands he's pathologically suicidal and thus was always living on borrowed time. That said Egwene totally died the death of a Sue. As I read I was running out of fingers for all the indicators. As someone who never liked Egwene this didn't bother me all that much, but I think all of you who truly liked her character have reason to be disappointed. Other than that, yeah Egwene was all over the place in the book, curiously it seemed to me as BS got better at writing Mat he got worse at writing Egwene. As for the Aes Sedai and the female channellers as a whole where were so many of them? I thought there were several hundred windfinders and over a thousand Wise Ones, why did we only see a few dozen of them? And what sort of madness possessed Egwene and the Hall to send all their novices and Accepted to Mayene and not recall them when they found themselves outnumbered against the Sharans all the time?
  5. He really said there are "wolfsisters"? Curious. I always thought that the wolfbrothers were the balance for the all female dreamwalkers.
  6. Unlike Caemlyn, Tar Valon's army has unprecedented mobility. If the Seanchan come in via Gateway, all the Tower needs is 13 sisters to make a humongous Gateway that can concentrate their troops far, far better than the Seanchan can. Which doesn't mean the Waygate shouldn't be destroyed right away, though. That only works if their army is prepared to fight immediately. If not it'll take hours to get the army organized while the Seanchan destroy pretty much to their liking. With Travelling the attacker has a huge advantage because unless the defender is ready exactly when the attack is taking place. Moreover unlike the Aes Sedai the Seanchan aren't limited by the three oaths. If the Aes Sedai open a huge Gateway the Seanchan would sense it and could just bombard the location with weaves which killed every soldier as he stepped through. Six Kinswomen, versus a lot of women in the Tower. Even if the majority of the Tower is in Merrilor, the Novices and Accepted obviously are not. Plus, there is a steady stream of communication between the two locations by Gateway. It does indeed need a circle. The risks come when you use less than a circle of 13. Loial speaks of a botched attempt in the Blight that involvled nine Aes Sedai and a sa'angreal. But the Tower has no difficulties producing many circles of 13, so they're covered, here. No would I be surprised to learn the Tar Valon Waygate is strongly warded. In fact, I'm going to go ahead an predict that the relatively small distance via the Ways between Tar Valon and Caemlyn will play a role soon. I think a surprise ambush from within the ways will be planned to complement a thrust at the Waygate from Caemlyn itself. It actually took 13 Aes Sedai and a sangreal to destroy a waygate. And that was only 500 AB meaning that those thirteen Aes Sedai were likely to be quite a bit stronger than the strongest thirteen Aes Sedai currently alive other than Elayne, Egwene, Nyneave and perhaps Cadsuane.
  7. You missunderstand what the nine moons are. Daughter of the Nine Moons is the title of the female heir of the empress. The court in Seandar was also called the court of the nine moons meaning that the nine moons are a metaphor for the empire and the empress in particular. Therefore binding the nine moons to him still means that Rand has to come to some sort of accord with empire and empress.
  8. Calling it unexpected isn't a sign of being an Egwene hater. All it means is that one didn't expect that sort of introspection from Egwene. That's neither an insult nor an accusation.
  9. I don't think you could get Tuon to swear an oath on the Oath Rod by her free will. For her to be forced to do such a thing would be the greatest insult anyone could give her. Tuon keeps her word she doesn't need any oaths. I really don't have any idea what will convince Tuon to give up the practice of damane. She is already aware that she can learn to channel and if she is careful how she spreads that knowledge she could even continue with the practice. Her rationale that while she can learn to channel that she chooses not to just like she chooses not to become a criminal might be enough for the sul'dam to cling to. As idolized and revered as the empress is among the Seanchan the fact that the empress herself gives them absolution of their ability to learn might be enough to keep the sul'dam together. And if she can convince the people to continue to give the sul'dam their trust by reminding them of near 1,000 years of reliable service to the empire even the general populace might accept it. That said I expect the practice of damane to be at least on the way towards abolition at the end of AMOL, the question is what Tuon will demand in return for freeing them. There has to be some kind of means to ensure control. Perhaps Bethamin and Seta might acquire a binder and bring it back to Tuon and from that day onwards all Seanchan channelers swear two oaths one to serve the empire and abide by its laws and the second to never undo that oath.
  10. I think Tam will do no such thing. The purpose of a sparring match is to simulate and prepare for actual combat. Rand has to overcome his handicap and he won't be able to do that if his partner handicaps himself as well. In all likelihood whenever Rand will have to fight with his sword he'll face an opponent who can use both hands. If Tam only uses one hand it can't be considered sparring it's just playing around. Rand won't learn from the experience.
  11. I always considered the Whites a dumping ground for those Aes Sedai unsuited to the rigours of the outside world. There will be always such in a group as large and diverse as the Aes Sedai.
  12. I just don't want things to happen too easily. Human beings are really stubborn about things like this, for the most we tend to fight change even when it's inevitable. The Aes Sedai have 3,000 years of ingrained discrimination against men in their system to overcome. That isn't meant as an insult, I'm not saying every Aes Sedai is sexist, but their system has a clear bias in this direction. Aes Sedai are trained to think they are better than everyone around them. That's what all this serenity nonsense is all about, they learn to think that they stand beyond the concerns of regular people and in their world view the only equals they have are a few other women. Men at best are the hired help. By the same token the men will have to overcome a 3,000 year old inferiority complex. Like every other group that has been discriminated against the men will have to struggle to gain equal standing with the Aes Sedai. What I meant by knuckling under was the popular theory that the Asha'man will immediately become male Aes Sedai again after TG and move in the tower Elaida had built. Instead I believe the Asha'man should find their own place in the world first. They have to decide what their role in the world is and not just accept the role others give them. If their slogan is "Defend. Guard. Protect." they have to define what that actually means and make others believe it too. That's how things ought to be. And that struggle should take longer than the few weeks AMOL apart from the epilogue will cover. Same for the Seanchan view on channellers. It's a culture that has grown over 1,000 years. By rights it shouldn't disappear so quickly.
  13. Let's hope that surprise will be a good one. The Asha'man simply knuckling under Egwene and joining them in Tar Valon would be a disappointment, the Seanchan empire having an epiphany and ending the practice of damane within a couple of days or weeks would be a disappointment. By rights those changes should take years.
  14. It's hard to say who because there are mixed signals. For one there is no emotion shown with the question. If it was Nynaeve, Egwene or Elayne I'm sure there would be some exclamation of shock or surprise because it'd be the first thing they asked once they saw him. Nynaeve in particular wouldn't be so calm about it. Rand and Perrin are the ones most likely imo to be able to ask that question without any sign of surprise since they are likely to see Mat in their visions. But I don't think Mat would deflect the question with either of them. With Rand and Perrin I'd say Mat would actually tell them that it happened in the ToG. Those kinds of jokes are what Mat usually says to women or people he doesn't trust all that much. Well, most of the people Mat doesn't trust happen to be women. XD If you combine both Tuon actually isn't a bad choice. She has a very strong self-control and she has been trained to keep such reactions hidden. Besides she has those odd Seanchan notions of propriety, I could see her deadpanning the question. That said I think the most likely candidate is a woman probably not part of the maincast who isn't all that close to Mat, especially one who is used to have people jump at her every word. I know again this applies to most of the women Mat knows, but someone like Teslyn or Joline or even Aludra would be my guess.
  15. Teslyn's problem is that from what we've seen she still is suffering from the trauma of having been leashed. With time I'm sure she can overcome this, but I don't think there's enough time in AMOL for that. She will have trouble facing the Seanchan. Becoming Tuon's Truthspeaker would be too much for her I'd say.
  • Create New...