-
Posts
3 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Store
Gallery
Blogs
News
Downloads
Events
Posts posted by James Michaels
-
-
One of the greatest things that Tokein ever did (in my opinion) was give us a full ending of what happened when the dust settled and when everyone went home to their families and how awesome they were etc....
I was really hoping that Jordan had a bigger epilogue so we could enjoy the characters who we slogged through 14 books with (should have been 10 books) to a fuller extent and see them be happy and their towns grow etc.....
That is my only real big complaint.
I must really compliment Sanderson on the Final Battle chapter because at the end of the chapter... I was as tired of the war as the soldiers were. They were holding out on the lines and I was holding out in the book saying, "holy cow this war stuff is exhausting!!" It was well done - and it drained you emotionally with all the death.
I cringed at the almost forced abortion of Elaynes babies by the dreadlord... creeped me out abit. I didn't like the gayness add in the book, because it wasn't in any of the other books so it stuck out as some type of political correctness thing which I can do without.
Lastly, I dind't like the philosophy of the book that you need evil to have people not be robots as if you ened a Satan to somehow tempt you. Thats like saying if it wasn't for Satan we would never be tempted to be bad - which I believe is stupid - people would still be evil without a Devil and without a Satan/Shaitan. Free will gives people a choice to be evil - not the existence of an evil creature which somehow extends the possability of evil.
I thought tha was dumb - maybe it's a philosophy I don't understand (I am a free will / personal responsability kind of guy.) So I disagreed with sealing off the dark one rather than killing him... but it's a novel so who cares right?
Also, I didn't like how Perrin didn't kill Graendal in the first meeting. The guy has been around enough to know how evil Forsaken are. You just kill em - I thought that was cheezy, but it made for a better story.
Lastly - I dont' understand why Tarwins Gap and other placed were not held off with gateways opening under the ocean or (finally they did the lava thing) or flat out opening a gateway to stop trollocs and tying it off. Some holes there - but I'm a complainer.
:) Love the book overall - loved the series. Best fantasy series ever minus book 11.
Mike
Egwene's Arc (Full Spoilers)
in Wheel of Time Books
Posted · Edited by Brazil M
I 100% agree with the 2nd post on this thread.
Egwene by book 12/13 had become the best character in the books with her iron nerves and sheer determination to beat Elaida by passive aggression (like Gandhi). Her speech and actions were that of a 1,000 year old monarch - WAY ahead of her time. Then in the last book - her speech and actions go back to being a little girl who I lost a lot of respect for. She didn't have the right dialogue that made her Amyrlin. At times I forgot she was Amyrlin!!!
I didn't like it - but her death was really cool. I did not expect it. The books definitely kept me guessing as to who was going to kill taim/demandred and how logain would gain his halo of fame . . . of course we all thought it was through killing demandred or taim or both.
Out of the main characters that left Emonds Field - Lan, Moraine, Mat, Perrin, Rand, Nynaeve and Egwene.... only Egwene died. Was def. surprising (to me) and I was sad - but impressed. It was her best part of this last book after reading all her horrible dialogue at the meeting etc... as described in post 2.
MB