Also never discount Gitara Sedai. She seems to be super influential with varius characters, and what she might have said to certain carachters off screen did not make it into the series as quotes. We really only have Dylin and a couple of other people to "play" witness to what she said. Most of the time it is second hand knowledge. Honestly from what we have seen from those with the "foretelling" They do not remember what they said. Interpretations weigh heavily.

Like you said maybe Rhuarc was meant to be Clan chief. i was thinking maybe Jonduin was meant not to be clan chief. If Rand had crossed and found his biological father waiting, perhaps Couladin wouldnt have taken the Shaido over the wall. A whole lot of stuff could have been different. And as Rand contemplates the chain of events that brought him to Camelyn in book 6, everything might have been ruined had he found Jonduin. That is why I come up with what I do. It wasnt enough that Tigraine was his mother, if his bio father still lived what would that have done to the story. As far as the whole Luc/Isam thing, IMO that is part of the shadow prophecy shown in TGH. BTW thanks for not just dismissing my theory, I appreciate it.

Well when he crossed to the Aiel Waste and met up with his fathers clan Rand would have met him. So my idea still stands that she sent him to the waste which set up the encounter with Jonduin. From there I just assume he became a pawn of the Dark as in eleven books he hasnt had more than a cursory existence in the story. I think he has a part to play, but until some better evidence Im going to go with the idea that Luc was sent for his destiny, and part of that destiny was to kill Jonduin.

I thought Luc went to the waste after tigraine did. I just listened to Dylins explanation of events to Rand this morning, and thats what it sounded like to me. Also I believe (my opinion) the reason Gitara sent him was so that he would confront Rands father and kill him there by leaving Rand with no family to raise him, there may be another deeper reason yet to come but that seems more of the shadows work than Gitara Sedai.

I thought Luc went to the waste after tigraine did. I just listened to Dylins explanation of events to Rand this morning, and thats what it sounded like to me. Also I believe (my opinion) the reason Gitara sent him was so that he would confront Rands father and kill him there by leaving Rand with no family to raise him, there may be another deeper reason yet to come but that seems more of the shadows work than Gitara Sedai.