4 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

There was so much sketch mixed with people just bailing ffs.

 

Tress didnt even vote.

 

FML

 

Just awful all around ffs

What do you mean?

sigh

Okay then.

Do you guys think it'll speed things up if I sing Two Princes by the spin doctors?

And if you like to talk for hours

just go ahead now.

11 minutes ago, Lessa Nikia said:

Sorry to say but I've never heard of you either but I do get the feeling that you're a really experienced mafia player.

 

I'm not too sure about lynching Tress as I don't have a read on her but I do get what you're saying about the big recap post and no anaylsis.

No worried, I kind of figured that.  

I've played a couple of times.  

Just now, Zanatron said:

VC PLEASE?!?!?!?!

 

HOW MUCH TIME WE GOT LEFT TILL DL?!?!?!?

It was five minutes ago by my watch.

Here's to hoping???

Just now, dicetosser1 said:

vote clov

Spicy.

FWIW I fully believe Tress is busy with work.  I mean, it's 2 in the afternoon and she's made no attempts to hide her schedule over the years.  If the thought is whether or not she's just sitting back at home and lurking the thread as scum and lying...she's not.  She just isn't.

But somebody's mafia, and I have 4 or 5 people I don't want to lynch and not that many options left.  And I know Tress can take a while to kind of... warm up to certain people, in terms of trust and whatnot... but having the time to take that lengthy of notes and not have really any thoughts on anyone is not a good sign.

1 minute ago, dicetosser1 said:

here   where we at?

 

Vote count I've got is:

Tress - 3 - Me, Zander, Iron

Me - 1 - Verbal

2 minutes ago, Katiora said:

And I don't know that I love the single train thing going on right now :/ 

I'd make a snarky comment, but I'm trying to be on my best behavior <3

2 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

 

I disagree on Hallia...dont want her lynched today.  

 

I def vote Tress over Verb atp

Her content is fine.  Her...presentation?... is strange to me.  I thought her response to me from last night was more aggressive than it should have been for what I thought was a very straight forward, simple question.  Normally I'd say that kind of agitation is mor elikely from town, but it kind of pinged from BFG's game I spectated where I whiffed on her bad.  

It would definitely by a POE lynch, but that's pretty much where I'm at on ANYBODY, outside of that one thing against Verb.

Zander/Iron/whoever: am I just focused on the fact I know Verb is wrong about me, and I think his reasoning sucks?  Because I'll give him credit for going back and fact checking - I sort of skimmed the past couple pages so I don't know how valid his argument was - but beyond that...I'm really not feeling him this game.  And I don't think I've been terrible at reading him.

Granted, it's been a while since I've played with him, so maybe I'm expecting more overlap in our thoughts/styles if he's town than I should be.

10 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

 

Heres a question.

 

If you think Clov is Town do you think Scum!Lessa pushes the strongest player in the game?!?!?!?!

 

Only world i see that us if theyre W/W and Clov HATES needless bussing.

 

Thoughts?

I don't know if everybody else in the game has this opinion, but fwiw, Lessa has never played with me and I've never even heard of her.  Maybe a teammate tells her to avoid me, but IDK.

I'm here.

Not going Zander/Kat/Dice.

Don't want to go Iron/Lessa.  I'm not going to strongly argue against any of them, but barring a counterwagon on one of the those three/myself, I won't vote there.

I still don't have any strong preference between Tress/Verb.  I'm fine with a Hallia lynch, but between Tress's massive notes with no analysis and Verb pushing based on a POE that I thought was pretty straight forward, I'd prefer one of htem.

Just now, Katiora said:

I don't know what you're talking about.... 

Who you making dead today? =)

Iron's list looks ~okay to me (I disagree about Verb, but I "get" his thought process about looking past the early contribution), but I really want to see what he was reading as suspicion.  That seems... not right.

46 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

 

 

FML

 

I don't know what to make of this Clov/Verb sussing each other?

 

I mean Verb, do you have s solid grasp of the game atp?

 

Who are you top town and scum reads (besides Clov obv) and why?

I wasn't sus of him until that post where he apparently doesn't understand a really basic concept.  I just saw no reason to feel good about him.  His only content was fos Hallia and townreading me, neither of which felt... anything, the.  He's just there. 

I'm really damn good at this game.  I can't read people that aren't posting, especially when my D1 approach is basically "do they believe what they're saying" + meta.

2 hours ago, Verbal32 said:

 

How in this world did you end up with me in your top 3 after my initial posts?  You have no idea what to do?  Who says that?  Keep posting, keep reading people's responses, and keep digging maybe?

 

D1 scum catch?  One can hope.  Added to what I just said, this early D1 from you is super weird from a townie POV.

 

Vote: Clov

There are eight slots for two scum.  I have reasons to feel good about four people.  That leaves four.

I had a bottom four (or three + one, if you want to account for Hallia being slightly above the rest).  

But I'm pretty sure you know how a POE works...

2 hours ago, Ironeyes said:

Possible, yeah. 

 

Reads? Not yet. Leans? You and Dice 

 

OK... I read it as you sussing her. Am I just misinterpreting?

You read me saying absolutely nothing to suggest she's > rand mafia, while saying three times she has good things going for her, as sussing her?

What did you interpret as suspicion?

1 minute ago, Zanatron said:

 

 

I thought it was a pressure vote....sadface.gif

It can be taken that way, I don't really care.  But it's not... not a real vote?  If that makes sense.

And saying I've "dug at Kat" for four pages seems pretty ??? to me, given I said originally it was probably a GOOD sign for her...

That actually wasn't a joke.  I have no way to differentiate who I want to lynch between Iron/Verb/Tress, and I inly feel a hair better about Hallia.  I have no reason to not lynch any of them.

I already said who I feel even fairly decent about being town and why.

Vote: Songstress

I random.orged it. 

I legitimately have no idea what to do atp.  Iron/Tress/Verb, and if that doesn't solve it, Hallia?

Zander is still the one I feel best about.  Like his effort, like his energy, but most importantly feel he's sincerely trying to solve.  The questions to Lessa and his response to me seemed right, and I thought his take on me to Dice seemed genuine.

I'm never going to accept where Kat's coming from on a personal level, but I realize there's more than one way to play.  Not going to beat that horse - especially when I think she'd be more inclined to force some reads as mafia, and even though I don't like how she's arguing, i don't think it's scummy.

Dice being suspicious of me is probably more null than anything, but it's not a bad sign for him.  No issues with his questioning about me to Zander.  I think his thought process is more likely to be interpreting something differently than a deliberate misrep to make me look bad.

Lessa's the one I'm probably struggling with the most.  I disagree that there's likely to be a fight from that discussion pretty much ever (and I've been in a lot of mafia fights....), and even if she does believe that, I don't see where there's mafia motivation in THAT specific topic.  So that conclusion has me scratching my head.  At the same time, gut feeling says that would be a really strange way to make me look bad and kind of just want to believe it's a genuine thought of hers.  IDK.

Of course you're allowed to.  That's why I was asking if it was serious or not... 

Are you still there IRT him?

35 minutes ago, Lessa Nikia said:

I feel that Kat is more town and I'm leaning toward wolf for Clov. Kat is responding to the questions being directed at her whereas Clov kept going on about the explanation/motivation of saying someone is town/wolf. Since that post, it's been the center of discussion and everyone has something to say about it. In my experience, those sort of arguments leads to everyone getting angry at each other due to different views. I get wanting to say something along the lines of avoiding the argument but I think had it not been mentioned, it would have been avoided entirely. 

 

Do you have any other reads?