Pokemon Mafia IV: The Mystery of Heart Island--GAME OVER--TEAM ROCKET WIN

[Leyrann]

I think Thane's given up to be honest.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I think Thane's given up to be honest.

 

I'd read that as town but I don't believe his moves.

 

Also he may just be AtEing. He's experienced enough to do so. 

[Leyrann]

 

Can you give some reasons on Seph and TMD?

 

I expect some new players on this mafia team. EP seemed to have been onto something with Seph and we know we can trust EP.

 

TMD playing the way he does really smells wolfy to me. Around but not really "here", not giving anything but not causing too much of a stir either. I also expect there is an experienced person on the mafia team(TMD or Dice or both) who due to time constraints has given fairly little input on the night kills and game in general to the scum team. Honestly think the scum team have been sitting back this whole game and watching town implode. Therefore, Dice, TMD, Thane, and one of either Seph or Zander being scum would not surprise me in the slightest. One of TMD or Dice is definitely scum, same for Seph and Zander IMO. And Thane's claim just seems too implausible for me. 

 

 

Quoted for future reference.

[Leyrann]

Dice, would like to see more from you.

[John Snow]

Thane, who are your suspects?

 

And what's AtE?

[John Snow]

i did post last night but i cant say much ive been spotty here.

 

i dont have a full readlist on everyone but right now like i eluded to in my previous post im leaning to Maf:

 

Jon Snow/Ley- were on the Turrin train hard, still believe that one of these are most likely a wolf

 

Thane: Mirror claim and that that what was killed one of them.  Because I know it wasn't one of them hence why I asked him about.  He seems like he'd hiding something.

 

 

So you're saying that one of the two people that are trying to keep this game moving along are scum?

[Zander?]

 

i did post last night but i cant say much ive been spotty here.

 

i dont have a full readlist on everyone but right now like i eluded to in my previous post im leaning to Maf:

 

Jon Snow/Ley- were on the Turrin train hard, still believe that one of these are most likely a wolf

 

Thane: Mirror claim and that that what was killed one of them.  Because I know it wasn't one of them hence why I asked him about.  He seems like he'd hiding something.

 

 

So you're saying that one of the two people that are trying to keep this game moving along are scum?

 

 

i believe at least ONE is....

[Leyrann]

Well, my role PM says I'm town and I believe JS is too...

 

No read is ever definite for me though.

[Leyrann]

I'm gonna sleep by the way.

 

Keep the game going and find some more scum while I'm gone.

[TheMasterDude]

RTE you never answered why you though Seph was scum.

 

Also did you not see my "I viewed JS last night and he attacked with bite" post? And then right after that JS confirmes that he used that night move?

[John Snow]

TMD, afaicr, all you've done this game is throw in the occasional vote and report your NAs. You've also claimed one of your moves is a Role Cop, traditionally a mafia role. 

 

Why should we believe you're town. 

[TheMasterDude]

Also havent been able to get a read on many people this game, currently top of my list town:

Ley

JS

 

Neutral:

Everyone else

 

Scum:

Dice

Thane

[TheMasterDude]

Since when has roll cop been a mafia roll?

 

I have roll cop roll. And then vig action. And thwn i can either raise or lower a persons night action percentage.

[John Snow]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Role_Cop

 

Role Cops have been seen aligned with Town and scum, and is actually a somewhat popular Mafia role in games with many power roles.

 

 

And it just so happens that this game has many power roles. Sure, it can be town, but town usually has normal cops. 

 

 

And you didn't answer my question. Why should we believe you're town?

[John Snow]

And I certainly didn't ask for a full move reveal. 

[TheMasterDude]

It kind of doesnt matter if i reveal now. We have to get a mafia member today or we are screwed.

[John Snow]

It kind of doesnt matter if i reveal now. We have to get a mafia member today or we are screwed.

 

[v]TMD[/v]

 

 

Stop avoiding my question. 

[TheMasterDude]

What can I say. I can say Im town. What cant I say? I cant say ive been active, i cant say ive found anyone that i know for sure is scum. What do you want me to say? Lol

[TheMasterDude]

You are either going to already believe what Ive done so far has lead me to be scum or town. I dont currently have any insightful info to pass along to the town.

[John Snow]

Mash, can we get a reads list? 

 

TMD, your defeatist attitude is reminiscent of Thane's. Not sure what it means. 

[BFG]

2. RTE

4. Mashiara

5. dice

6. seph

7. TMD

9. Ithi/cory BFG

10. Zander

12. Ley

13. Thane

14. John Snow

 

 

I think either RTE or TMD are mafia. Im leaning more RTE. Tinfoil has them both. TMD got a point for his JS view

Im seriously spinning JS in my head. He got outed useing a aggressive move but just came out saying yep i did. But wont say who he attacked. That bit is whats making me spin.

Im believing thane.

Ley i had as town but this latest stuff with Thane has me questioning it.

BFG  there are hints of TownBFG here   like focussing on me :D  but your catch up felt different. lean town

Cant remember what i made of Zander.

Seph leaning mafia but very unsure

Mash   no idea  think town

Why is this the first set of reads you've given all game? (other than Snow and EP Day 1) why did you have to be prompted for these??? Out of these who do you want to vote?

[BFG]

 

 

I agree with Ley.

 

[v]Thane[/v]

 

Anyone remember how reluctant Mash was to follow Darthe?

 

But she sheeps Ley without a second thought. I don't like this at all.

 

I'm not "sheeping" anyone. If you read anything from the past few days, you've seen that Ley's on my list of scum. I'm not following him, only stating that he's making sense with this information.

 

I would have voted Thane regardless of what Ley said.

 

So does this mean you now thing Ley is town or bussing?

[BFG]

for the record. I know what a mirror DOES. I was looking for a role link to something like mafiwiki that tells you if a role is more commonly seen as this or as that or what

No follow up with Zander?

[dicetosser1]

because I didnt want to give one. because as you can see there my reads list sux.

 

im gonna vote TMD

[dicetosser1]

 

for the record. I know what a mirror DOES. I was looking for a role link to something like mafiwiki that tells you if a role is more commonly seen as this or as that or what

No follow up with Zander?

 

 

I forgot to do it last night.