9 - 5 Mafia - Day 3 - GAME OVER! MAFIA WINS!

[Tim Dickens]

Also if darthe is a wolf I just noted tina echoing my earlier remark that if darthe is a wolf cory helped lead people off of him

 

Which is exactly what a mafioso would say when posturing for a future mislynch

[Tim Dickens]

Oh.

 

My god

 

Tina is supposed to be turin

[Tim Dickens]

I have no other read of turin I just wanted to note independently that one thing.

 

I'm going to reread from page 1 now and probably make one or two comments before my final big reread post.

[Yates]

It's a bad push because you explained the reason to hammer and then are trying to use the fact he hammered against him. I have doubts about Zander myself but the hammer of Ley is a null action.

Do you think I'm calling him scum for hammering? The hammer is null, yes. The REASON for the hammer is not.

[Tim Dickens]

What was his reason for the hammer?

[Zander?]

you may well be right but...

 

[Tim Dickens]

Ya sometimes you gotta go with the gut.

 

I think that a large portion or at least one of the mafia has yet to post tonight or post much tonight

[Yates]

*sigh* I hit return and posted instead of adding a paragraph...

 

The rest of 979 is this:

 

So I spent some time talking to Zander to figure out if he had a BETTER reason to hammer and to see how his story changed/evolved/remained consistent. If I saw a "Kaylee" response, I would have felt pretty good about just pushing forward with the lynch. That's not what I saw. It doesn't mean he's Town but it at least addresses one major concern.

[Tim Dickens]

Basically this large discussion feels like all villagers or at most one mafiat

[Yates]

What was his reason for the hammer?

Hypocrisy.

[Tim Dickens]

I kind of even don't understand his reason.

 

What does the hypocrisy in question have to do with you voting ley over darthe and why?

[Tim Dickens]

^for zander

[Tim Dickens]

He's calling out turin and ley in that post for being hypocritical okay

[Tim Dickens]

I don't really like that reason either but I've seen people hammer in worse spots onto worse players for worse reasons

[Yates]

He has since changed his answer to "to avoid a no lynch and Ley was one of my top 2 scum reads anyway."

 

I think if he had stated that in his vote post instead of the hypocrisy stuff, I wouldn't have looked at the hammer more than twice.

[Tim Dickens]

I think the way he's been handling himself these past few pages is rather villagery

 

There i said it

 

Now even if you're a wolf you still get a win zander!

[Zander?]

no Sooh had a post (from a previous game) saying Ley did the same thing that Darthe did to Ilit and Turrin.  This was after Ley lit into Darthe for it.  He was being a hypocrite. thats why i did it.  i had both as maf leans.

[Yates]

He has since changed his answer to "to avoid a no lynch and Ley was one of my top 2 scum reads anyway."

That's a paraphrase. This is what he said:

well for one deadline was 4am my time and i wasnt gonna be up for it.  thought i had explained my reasoning fairly well beforehand.

I also wanted to be sure sure a lynch was achieved... the rules say if no majority lynch then a random person will be killed with no info. This would only help mafia as they know who's on their team and who's not. So I thought it better to lynch someone whose was on my scum list then be on someone else and allow someone random to take that place.

[Tim Dickens]

I kind of think zander is a villager

 

I can see it if I squint my eyes

 

If you're a villager i think you're on the right track because your poe seems to reflect what I would imagine mine would be if you are in fact a villager.

 

Maybe minus cory

[Tim Dickens]

As in I still think cory is a villager

[Yates]

no Sooh had a post (from a previous game) saying Ley did the same thing that Darthe did to Ilit and Turrin.  This was after Ley lit into Darthe for it.  He was being a hypocrite. thats why i did it.  i had both as maf leans.

Is THAT what that meant? That is way different from what you posted...

[Zander?]

no look back i mentioned that as well.  the post you had posted just a few back was me elaborating on it.  my last was explaining the hypocrisy.

[Tim Dickens]

Nah yeah it means the same thing he just made a run - on sentence in his last post

 

Which is why it confused me too

 

I think he's telling the truth.

[Darthe]

Great we're all confused.

[Darthe]

1k get