[Mafia Game Over] Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark - Mafia Wins!

[dapianoplay3r]

And I make no promises lol. But i think after this i might need to lay low for a while

[ReleaseTheEvil]

According to the responses in this thread, it sounds like Mafia will be dead on DM for a while now

[dapianoplay3r]

Yea. Just as I start a game lol

 

But I wont bow out unless im continuously targeted just in case. I like playing too much

[Ithillian Turambar]

If you had attempted to shoot yourself, it would have put you into an eternal loop of almost deadness.

 

Until morning.

 

When I would remove the bullet from its ricocheting and your Action would have failed.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I don't think you will be continuously targeted. People need to be more vigilant of you is all. Just because you case extremely well doesn't mean you are always town...

[dapianoplay3r]

It would of been great if the bullet went randomly off into the night or hit anyone that targeted me or something cool

 

RTE cases arent hard to make. They just take time. The trick is to look at them closely. Sometimes people dont and it bugs me. Ed reads them. I appreciate that

The thing with cases is I can twist anything. So sometimes im wrong with who I pick to case, and it annoys me when people blindly follow

[michellem]

I gotta say it again; thank you Ithi and Turin for this game, absolutley one of the most entertaining I've played in a while! And I'm so happy I ended up as mafia. Sucks DM and RL stopped me from playing as much as I liked until the end, but oh well.

 

Dice, I haven't gotten to the part in the dead thread yet where I "revealed" as a tracker, but I guess you were furious lol

 

(but pssst, soft claiming really sucks for town ya'll. I wasn't making it up when I said it's a great stalling technique, and if you are town and soft claiming, all you'll achieve is that town will be confused for a while and have a hard time moving on, and you're more or less sure to bring on a NK anyway)

[Arez Al'Loke]

Star wars mafia > idianna Jones mafia

 

Come at me bro!

[ed2funy]

Rude.

[Arez Al'Loke]

Both are her games xP

[ed2funy]

Ok then. Today, you live.

[Arez Al'Loke]

Thanks god!

 

*gets random missdirect killed*

[Turin Turambar]

Sith was epic. This game was very fun also. It did not play anything like I expected. I thought the mafia would use their roles to basically nullify the doc and cop. I also thought they would pick up on the danger the oracle presented.

 

It would have been conceivable to let both cop and doc live while killing whoever they wanted to. And having a good chance at getting some town views from the cop.

 

Arez, sorry you got killed. I thought town would figure that out quickly. The monkey died by accidental date eating. Arez died cause wbk missed with his kill attempt.

[michellem]

Just finished reading the dead thread, mucho entertaining! Sorry Dice ;P lol

[ruairidh7]

Thank you for a wonderful game Ithi and Turin, loads of fun to play.

 

Well done mafia! Particularly Dap, who played an absolute blinder.

[ruairidh7]

Did I post a dog gif or something?

[ruairidh7]

Oh yes, the ruh roh pic what are the chances of that?!

[Turin Turambar]

Yes. The dog gif the mafia had requested from their symps. Too bad the real symps couldn't even see the QT to get hints.

[Arez Al'Loke]

Arez, sorry you got killed. I thought town would figure that out quickly. The monkey died by accidental date eating. Arez died cause wbk missed with his kill attempt.

 

I admit I think it's a little unfair (considering it's completly random and my gameplay had nothing to do with it) BUT, at the moment I thought Kronos was lying anyway =P

[dicetosser1]

Just finished reading the dead thread, mucho entertaining! Sorry Dice ;P lol

 

 

so you should be mish! :biggrin:

[Ithillian Turambar]

*unpins ready for Darthe's Game*

 

I will still add all the info and PMs later :)

[peacesells]

Thinking back on the oracle staff deal I think you guys over valued their contribution.  Since the holders are uninformed there is an inherent distrust of all other players.  Meaning that even though one person had the staff and could tell who held the Ark there is nothing that would make that person work with the oracle or even know the oracle existed.

 

The next problem was that even if the Oracle came out and stated his role in some manner he then becomes a NK target.    So basically, that muffles the Oracle.  Information can't flow freely. 

 

The best case scenario would be for the Oracle got go 4 or 5 nights and then list all his results at once, hoping that the true staff's holders were still alive to give their results thus clearly or implicating 4 to 5 players.

 

So, when considering game balance...and building roles that involve 2 uninformed players you must consider that the players are more likely to not work in concert than they are to work together.  Not to mention that the chance to ruin this combination is doubled since you only have to kill one of 2 players to ruin the role.  These 2 roles should then be given less weight when considering overall balance.

 

I only point this out because, I believe Turin stated his shock that the oracle and staff holders didn't work together.   I would have been shocked that they did..since this game is based on mistrust. 

[dapianoplay3r]

I think all the vigs firing night 1 was also an issue

 

but why did it take town so long to realise they were bad lol

[Ithillian Turambar]

Well. You also had a normal cop and a Tracker and a Voyeur so I think it was ok. And Reggie was designed to find misdirection Roles.

 

The Mafia didn't seem that worried about the Oracle at first.

 

And in the end, people are way too reliant on Roles finding out who the Mafia are. I wanted a Game where people would need to play and figure stuff out.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Well that's why the Monkey Man had his caveat to be careful ... To make sure at least one didn't.

 

And Darthe had his BPV.