Jump to content

DRAGONMOUNT

A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY
Sign in to follow this  
Werthead

[Book review]: Red Country by Joe Abercrombie

Recommended Posts

Red Country

 

Gold has been discovered in the hills and mountains of the Far Country, that untamed frontier beyond the Old Empire and far to the west of the Union. Prospectors, mercenaries and those eager to find a new life flock to those lands, only to find the greed and violence of their pasts following them, even those of honourable intentions. Shy South and her adopted father are searching for missing kinfolk, kidnapped for purposes unknown. Their pursuit across the Far Country leads them into an alliance with a fellowship of the plains, a caravan hoping for a better life in the distant mining town of Crease. But, with rebels gathering in the mountains and Nicomo Cosca and his Company of the Gracious Hand also on a sworn mission to root them out for His Majesty's Inquisition, this is a journey where nothing will turn out as hoped.

 

Red Country is Joe Abercrombie's sixth novel and his third semi-stand-alone set in the same world as The First Law sequence. As with its two immediate predecessors, Best Served Cold and The Heroes, Red Country can be read by itself, but regular readers will pick up on a lot of nods and winks to previous novels, from cameo character appearances to the ongoing development of a 'cold war' between two opposing factions.

 

The book moves between several major POV characters. Shy is our main protagonist, but shares a lot of the page-time with Temple, a lawyer in Cosca's army whose moral centre is gradually crumbling in the face of so much pain and violence. Other characters also flitter in and out of the story, with Abercrombie re-using the 'POV handover' trick from The Heroes to great effect several times, where the perspective shifts between several characters in succession to help clearly tell the story of a battle or confrontation. As usual with Abercrombie, the characters' personalities and motivations are convincingly laid out and developed, and there are some nice pay-offs for returning characters (Cosca, in particular, gets some fairly thorough character development here). One slight flaw is that the storyline following one of the kidnapped children never seems to really develop, and feels like it either needed several more chapters dedicated to it or the whole thing dropped and the reader (like Shy) made to discern for themselves what happened off-page.

 

The novel has been billed as 'Joe Abercrombie's Western' and there is certainly a degree of that in the book's influences. Brief nods to The Searchers, Unforgiven and the mighty Deadwood can be discerned, though unexpectedly the most constant cultural reference is the original Star Wars movie: one brief line of dialogue by Obi-Wan Kenobi inspires an entire subplot in the novel. However, there are significant deviations from the Western motif. The West in this case is the long-abandoned northern provinces of the Old Empire, festooned with ruins from ancient times, rather than a totally virgin and untamed land (apart from the natives, of course). The area is also (relatively) close to the Old Empire, the Union and the North, making it much more of a cultural melting-pot and having it effect (and be effected by) events in more established lands than you might expect. Finally, there's no six-shooters, with everyone falling back on the old stand-bys of swords and bows. More or less.

 

The tone of the book is bloody and cynical, with Abercrombie's trademark line in black humour preventing things from getting too depressing. However, the cynicism feels a little harder-edged and a bit blacker than in his previous books, the humour perhaps a tad less prevalent. It's still a page-turning, well-written book with points to make about human nature, but at times the tone feels wearier than his previous books. However, this also ties in with a feeling of tragedy underpinning the book, one that results in a grimly satisfying pay-off at the end (and one element of the novel that is completely lifted - if appropriately - from a Western).

 

Red Country (****½) is Joe Abercrombie doing what he does best, writing a story of violence, mayhem and vengeance and the effect it has on all-too-human characters. As with his previous stand-alones, the book works as both a satisfying novel in its own right and also moves a lot of political and religious pieces into position to be (presumably) used to good effect in his next work, a full-on trilogy. Some may find the cynicism a tad overwhelming at times and at least one of the subplots doesn't quite work as well as it could have, but this is a strong effort from one of the better writers in the genre. The novel will be available on 18 October in the UK and 13 November in the USA.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Question to the Abercrombie fans out there.

 

I read the First Law trilogy, enjoyed it quite a bit until what I considered to be an absolutely abysmal ending. (not because it was depressing, but because it threw all plot progression that had been made through 3 books out of the window)

 

Should I read the 3 stand alone novels or will I be equally disappointed?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Frankly, I consider The First Law trilogy to have the single finest ending of any fantasy trilogy released to this time (not counting LotR, since that's one novel split in three rather than a proper trilogy). A seriously brilliant idea, well-executed:

 

 

The ending basically showing us that the trilogy was never about saving the world or good vs. evil, but instead the game of chess between Bayaz and his opposite number, with everything in the trilogy basically being Bayaz maneuvering things so he ends up in control (effectively) of the Union.

 

 

The stand-alone books continue this storyline, that of a 'cold war' between the two factions as they maneuver around one another, form alliances and put things in place for another big epic story. However, these elements form the background setting, at best, with the main plots in each of the three books being self-contained.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Frankly, I consider The First Law trilogy to have the single finest ending of any fantasy trilogy released to this time (not counting LotR, since that's one novel split in three rather than a proper trilogy). A seriously brilliant idea, well-executed:

 

 

The ending basically showing us that the trilogy was never about saving the world or good vs. evil, but instead the game of chess between Bayaz and his opposite number, with everything in the trilogy basically being Bayaz maneuvering things so he ends up in control (effectively) of the Union.

 

 

The stand-alone books continue this storyline, that of a 'cold war' between the two factions as they maneuver around one another, form alliances and put things in place for another big epic story. However, these elements form the background setting, at best, with the main plots in each of the three books being self-contained.

 

Indeed, I loved the moment when I realized there was a much deeper game going on. It really makes things far more interesting for the series as a whole moving forward. Just a brilliant spin Abercrombie has put on things.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just finished the book, would have finished earlier if it came out in America the same date as it did for the Brits. Once again, Joe is my favorite current fantasy author. All in all, a great book, though I was sad to see one character who I enjoyed from previous books fall to such depths and die.

 

As far as the stand alone novels go, I would say it is right behind The Heroes and a good ways ahead of Best Served Cold.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...