Eye of the World vs. Eragon

[LapisPharaoh]

When I was reading Eragon (the first book) I thought the first half of the book is almost a complete rip-off of EotW.

Don't get me wrong, I love Inheritance Cycle and Christopher Paloni, but he was 15 when he wrote Eragon and it seems he completely plagiarized the first half of EotW.

I'm sorry if this has been discussed before, I couldn't find the thread...

[wotfan4472]

You should have been here with the Sword of Truth debacle before RJ passed. Paolini probably did, because he loved how the story began and felt it would be cool to use it in his story, but the Goodkind was worse.

[BFG]

Lol, I always viewed Eragon as a retelling of Star Wars with dragons instead of lightsabers :p

[jack of shadows]

paolini's eragon is heavy dose of tolkien sprinkled (like bfg said) with

star wars lol,incidentally,eye of the world,relies heavily on tolkien too.

[Kesiera_Sedai]

Yeah, you even have a Rand and a Nynaeve, I guess you would say...The Sword of Truth has a sort of Rand/Elayne thing going, and I've read one more series by a woman named G.R R. Martin that has an incredibly powerful young mage who is accompanied by a young woman who is a mage with an incredible talent for healing.The guy even cleanses their source of magic when it's tainted by evil...the source of their power is even called the Flow...Even though it was a complete rip-off it was a good story... There are even several times in the book were they link their powers to do things no one mage was supposed to be able to do (a circle).The wilders were called hedge witches...And there was a woman who'd had her powers taken away (stilling?) but later restored at a reduced level (Suian, Leane?)...The plot was somewhat different but the system was so similar that the author obviously had read WoT. By the way, it didn't really have any resemblance to Tolkien or Goodkind.

[DojoToad]

There is nothing new under the sun.

[Sabio]

Ughh Goodkind.

[LapisPharaoh]

Preach, Dojo

[wotfan4472]

True that Dojo. Nothing new just new presentation